Time to read: 15 minutes(s)

"I have fulfilled my role in this story."

The court questioned Ilya Khesin, who launched the investigation into the possible involvement of defendants in the "Network"* case in a double murder in a forest near Ryazan.

Ilya Khesin. Still from Russia Today.

In order to conduct your own investigation, to engineer Ilya Khesin from St. Petersburg It took just over a year. The evidence he obtained formed the basis of an article in the online publication Meduza** and quelled the wave of protests in support of those involved in a high-profile criminal case against a terrorist organization. "Network"*, which took place throughout the country in February 2020.

At that moment, the parents of the defendants called Ilya Khesin is a "mentally ill FSB provocateur" who spreads "nonsense" about murder in order to discredit political prisoners.

However, in the end, the version he presented was confirmed, and the defendant in the “Network”* case Maxim Ivankin once again found himself in the dock on suspicion of committing murder.

April 12, Ilya Khesin appeared in court to give his testimony to the jury.

SVO and discreditation

Photo of Ilya Khesin from his VK page

About the fact that Ilya Khesin lives in MariupolJudge Natalia Kianovskaya reported this on April 3, when the participants in the trial discussed the possibility of his interrogation.

Due to the fact that a special military operation is currently underway, he does not always have a phone in the network coverage area, — the judge recounted the telephone conversation with the witness. He explained that it would be convenient for him to give testimony via videoconference in the city of Rostov-on-Don.

Defendant Maxim Ivankin insisted on Khesin's personal appearance in Ryazan Regional CourtAccording to his lawyer, Konstantin Kartashov, the witness faces numerous questions, including questions about physical evidence.

However, the court still decided to interrogate Khesin remotely. On April 12, he appeared in Soviet District Court of Rostov, an hour and a half late.

Photo of Ilya Khesin from his VK page

The road is very long, our border is locked, they check everything for a long time, — the witness explained the reasons for the delay and specified that he works for one of the construction companies in Mariupol.

When speaking to the jury, Khesin used complex, official language and spoke like an investigator. His interrogation lasted nearly three hours. During this time, the defense and prosecution even managed to quarrel. In particular, prosecutor Vladimir Aladyshev I noticed in the comments lawyer Konstantin Kartashov "discrediting law enforcement agencies."

The lawyer, in turn, emphasized that he never got the opportunity to ask Khesin all the questions that he considered “important enough.”

How the murder theory came about

Defendants in the Penza "Network* Case." 2019. Photo: 7x7

Ilya Khesin became interested the Network case*, because among the detained defendants were three of his acquaintances: Yulian Boyarshinov, Igor Shishkin and Arman Sagynbaev.

The gravity of the charges brought against the persons known to me was unclear and seemed unduly severe, — he explained to the court the motives for his own investigation.— I was interested in understanding why they were involved and how I could help organize their legal defense.

Trying to understand the details of the investigation, Khesin went to support group The Network* case defendants, which consisted of their relatives and close friends, were part of the activist's group. The activist communicated with them primarily through social media and instant messaging apps. It was there, in one of the chats, that he first heard the story of the missing person. Artem Dorofeev nicknamed "Timofey" and his girlfriend Ekaterina Levchenko. 

Artem Dorofeev is in the center, with Katya Levchenko and Mikhail Kulkov to his right. Photo: social media

According to support group members, the young couple left Penza in April 2017 together with Maxim Ivankin, Mikhail Kulkov and Alexey Poltavets, who at the time were suspects in a drug trafficking case. Later, in July 2018, Ivankin and Kulkov were detained in Moscow—this time as members of the terrorist group "Network"*. Poltavets managed to illegally cross the border and request political asylum in Ukraine.

At the same time, no one knew anything about the subsequent fate of Levchenko and Dorofeev, who had fled with them, and they did not contact their parents.

In the support group, the issue of the disappearance of these two individuals was raised only very briefly, — Ilya Khesin said— I found this detail quite interesting and incomprehensible.

Liza Alert, Penza

The thought that Artem Dorofeev killedThe activist was inspired by the criminal case materials on the terrorist group "Network"*, which he studied "cover to cover." Lawyers provided them to relatives, who, he says, posted them to a support group. Khesin drew attention to correspondence seized from the phones of the detained defendants. It mentioned certain "civilians" with whom "the matter has been resolved." It also mentioned "recruitment," the effectiveness of which only becomes clear after "the buddy is either in the Network* or eliminated."

The case materials do not clearly indicate that someone killed someone, — Ilya Khesin emphasized— But they gave me indirect thoughts that a murder had occurred.

Liza Alert, Penza

That a certain person was a member of the terrorist community Timofey, several detained defendants spoke at the initial interrogations. Including Dmitry Pchelintsev, who, according to investigators, was one of the organizers of the “Network”*.

According to Ilya Khesin, support group members repeatedly asked Pchelintsev about the fate of "Timofey," who fled Penza along with Ivankin and Poltavets. Ultimately, in one of the notes passed through his lawyer, he crossed out the name.

Ten out of ten

Alexandra Aksenova. Photo: Discours.io

Detailed investigation into the murder theory has begun. in January 2019 of the yearTo understand the situation, Ilya Khesin had to travel to Finland, where he lived. Alexandra Aksenova — the girlfriend of the St. Petersburg defendant in the "Network" case* Viktor FilinkovShe was an active member of the support group, was well-versed in the criminal case materials, and could explain events that remained outside its scope.

Khesin emphasized that by that time, the body of an unknown man discovered in the Ryazan forest was already known. Activists believed it to be Artem Dorofeev, nicknamed "Timofey." April 2019 of the year their guesses confirmed DNA examination.

Anna Shalunkina. Photo: from her personal social media account

Around the same time, a strange message appeared in one of the chats from Anna Shalunkina, who was a cousin To Dmitry Pchelintsev and was a member of a support group. According to her, at one of the court hearings to extend her arrest Ivankina и Kulkova A girl from Moscow arrived and said that both young men had been hiding in her Moscow apartment for some time.

She lived on the top floor [of a multi-story building] and one day she saw Kulkov and Ivankin living in the attic. She felt sorry for them and took them into her home. — he retold Ilya Khesin the girl's wordsWhile living there, they suffered a nervous breakdown and attempted to self-harm by cutting their wrists. Speaking in Russian, they tried to slit their wrists and confessed that their hands were covered in blood and that they had killed a man.

Anna Shalunkina and Maxim Ivankin. Photo: from personal social media account

After this, the possibility of murder became even more active in the support group. Members began asking awkward questions and demanding clarification.

Anna Shalunkina, as an emotionally sensitive person, was very worried about this story and about the fact that these guys [Artem Dorofeev and Ekaterina Levchenko] were possibly killed, — Ilya Khesin told the court. "As far as I know, she repeatedly contacted Pchelintsev, Ivankin, and Kulkov through their lawyers. And she forwarded one of the notes [a photo of the note with Dmitry Pchelintsev's response] to me. She was genuinely hysterical, because she was beginning to suspect that the people she had invested her heart and soul in and supported might have been involved in such a tragic event."

The village of Lopukhi, near which the murder took place

According to Khesin, Pchelintsev's answer to the question about his involvement in the murder of Levchenko and Dorofeev read: "I am zero out of ten, and Ivankin is ten out of ten."

Khesin clarified that after some time, Anna Shalunkina stopped all communication with him. She claimed that the girl from Moscow was "insane and talking nonsense."

Anna Shalunkina on her wedding day. Photo: 7x7

In January 2020 years Anna Shalunkina married Maxim Ivankin and became his wife. The marriage registration took place in Penza pretrial detention center No. 1Ivankin proposed marriage in September 2019, right in the courtroom where the trial of the terrorist group "Network"* was taking place.

"Two people were killed"

In the spring of 2019 year Ilya Khesin managed to talk to Alexey Poltavets, who fled Penza along with Levchenko and Dorofeev. He was essentially one of those who saw these men for the last time and could shed light on their subsequent fate.

Khesin communicated with Poltavets in a secret messenger, where it's impossible to take screenshots of messages. Therefore, the activist photographed all the phrases he considered important on another phone.

Alexey Poltavets confirmed my fears that along with the murder of Artem Dorofeev, the murder of Ekaterina Levchenko also took place, — Ilya Khesin explained to the court— But at the same time he claimed that his role there was that of a witness.

Maxim Ivankin

In response to a clarifying question from a lawyer Konstantin Kartashov Regarding the details of the murder, the activist explained that, according to Poltavets, "both people were killed by your client." In both cases, the weapons used were Knives, and the bodies were buried close to each other. The motive for the crime was fear of prosecution for drug-related crimes.

As follows from Poltavets’ words, there were people who [were not satisfied] with the presence of living witnesses in the criminal case opened regarding the sale of narcotic drugs, - Khesin clarified— The original plan was for the defendant [Ivankin], Poltavets, Kulkov, and the victims to leave the Russian Federation. But at some point, the victims decided it would be easier to stay home, since they hadn't actually done anything wrong. They were counting on returning home, but the court, acting through someone else, decided otherwise.

Alexey Poltavets. Photo: social media

Ilya Khesin found it hard to believe that Alexey Poltavets was not involved in the murder.

Did you have any doubts that Poltavets could be slandering Ivankin? — the judge asked him.

Of course, critical thinking was present, — the witness answeredPoltavets very firmly denied his role [in the murder], and spoke very negatively about Ivankin's role. From this, I concluded that the truth lies somewhere in between.

According to Ilya Khesin, he also communicated with a certain Nikita, who at one time crossed paths with Poltavets in Ukraine.

Poltavets told Nikita that two people were killed, killed by two people, and they were lying in the same place, Ilya Khesin clarified.

Selected passages from correspondence with Poltavets

Nineteen photographs containing fragments of correspondence between Khesin and Poltavets were added to the criminal case file. To familiarize the jury with its contents, the state prosecutor Vladimir Aladyshev together with his colleague Oksana Moryakova I read the dialogue in parts. It took the prosecution 15 minutes to do this.

As follows from the announced fragments, Khesin was interested in two important questions: Who made the decision to kill the "civilians" and where did Maxim Ivankin hide the body of Ekaterina Levchenko?

In his responses, Alexey Poltavets clarified that the murder was committed by Maxim Ivankin, who appears in the correspondence under a pseudonym Pasha"Pasha said about the knife that he did everything without making any noise."

Ilya Khesin. Still from Russia Today.

At the same time, the organization of the murder, according to Poltavets, was discussed with Dmitry Pchelintsev, who appears in the correspondence under pseudonyms Anton и "pch": "The first PC said that we have resolved this issue."

Answering the second question, Alexey Poltavets again referred to the words Maxim Ivankin“Pasha then told me how he did everything, and the PC and who knows who else he used [the knife], that they were lying there nearby.”

“They’re not fluffy at all either,” he concluded. Poltavets her story about the murdered Artem Dorofeev and Ekaterina Levchenko. "They were using synthetic drugs and signed a document declaring they were ready to die for the movement and so on, and then—we don't give a shit, we'll turn everyone in. Obviously, those who signed it are to blame, but they're not perfect either."

Unanswered Questions

Maxim Ivankin. At the Network* trial in Penza in 2019. Photo: 7x7

Despite the fact that both state prosecutors tried to read the correspondence with expression, the lawyer Konstantin Kartashov made some comments to them.

According to him, the prosecution overlooked Khesin's explanations that the conversation was interrupted at several points and that the correspondence discussed "other topics not captured in the seized photographs."

In addition, the lawyer drew attention to missing word in the phrase that law enforcement officers "need to put someone in jail for this, and the rest doesn't matter." In his opinion, it's "wrong and dishonest" to omit certain phrases from the documents being read, thereby distorting the meaning of what's written.

Your Honor, I object! — State Prosecutor Vladimir Aladyshev addressed the court.— Because it discredits law enforcement agencies.

Alexey Poltavets. Drawing of the murdered Katya Levchenko.

Continuing his questioning of Ilya Khesin, lawyer Kartashov drew attention to a deleted one-time message on one of the pages of the correspondence.

Why was it necessary to hide a one-time secret message in a secret service? — he asked.

To get sensitive information from Poltavets, — Ilya Khesin answered him— If a person doesn't particularly trust me, then a question asked in the form of a one-time message might prompt them to say more.

Why then did Poltavets not respond to you in a secret message? — continued Kartashov.

Ask this question to Poltavets, - Khesin retorted..

The site where the remains of Artem Dorofeev and Katerina Levchenko were discovered. Photo: Svetlana Vidanova / Novaya Gazeta

The lawyer also asked the activist to clarify the meaning of the word "deleted" on the penultimate page of the correspondence. However, the judge prohibited the witness from answering this question.

Why? — Konstantin Kartashov was indignant.— The specific circumstance.

Why are you arguing with the court? — State prosecutor Vladimir Aladyshev intervened in the discussion.

I want to ask a question about this phrase, — the lawyer continued.

Your question has been removed, — the judge snapped. - Please, next question.

Another motion, which was denied by the defense, concerned the disclosure of the interrogation protocol of Ilya Khesin. from 19 May 2020 years.

During interrogation at the investigation stage, he indicated the city and metro station where Poltavets was located [during correspondence with him], - Kartashov clarified. "One might conclude that he was trying to find out where Poltavets was at that time, and someone told him about it. So I want to know who told him about it."

However, the court decided that the said testimony was “presumptive in nature” and was “the subjective opinion of the witness.”

Correspondence that no one needs

Photo: Svetlana Vidanova / Novaya Gazeta

According to Ilya Khesin, in the same May 2019 years He posted his correspondence with Poltavets in a support group for those involved in the Network* case.

In addition, he provided it to several journalists and tried to contact the investigation.

I said that I had correspondence and that Levchenko could have been killed, - Khesin explained to the court"He said there was a chance that Ekaterina Levchenko's remains might also be found in the same area [where Artem Dorofeev's remains were found]. But I received no interest from the Penza and Ryazan Investigative Committees. In any case, I fulfilled my civic duty, and [for a while] I stopped thinking about it.

The activist made another attempt to contact journalists in February 2020, when a court in Penza announced the verdict against seven defendants and thousands of people took to the streets in their support.

Maxim Ivankin. Drawing of the murdered Katya Levchenko.

I found that Ekaterina Levchenko's mother is very active supported the guys from the "Network"* case, very involved. This was evident from her messages on the social network VKontakte, — explained Ilya Khesin— I simply couldn't watch it. Because I understood that someone from this "Network"* was probably involved in this murder.

After this, he turned to his old friend Maxim Solopov, who worked as a journalist for the online publication Meduza**.

He picked up the story and became interested. And then began Some procedural steps [to verify information and search for remains], and I fulfilled my role in this story. And here I am, a few more years later.

*In January 2019, the Moscow District Court designated "The Network" a terrorist organization. The defendants in the case claim that such an organization never existed.

**On January 26, 2023, the Prosecutor General's Office of the Russian Federation declared the online publication Meduza an undesirable organization whose activities pose a threat to the foundations of the constitutional order and security of the Russian Federation.