"Society must be prepared for a disaster like Chernobyl."

Fires, floods, widespread landfills, river pollution to the point of killing off their inhabitants, industrial emissions into the atmosphere—all these major and minor environmental disasters occur in Russian regions almost daily. World Environment Day NeMoskva spoke with environmentalists about the cause-and-effect relationships between major and minor environmental disasters, and whether we should expect changes in the government's approach to nature or whether we should act instead.
Lyubov Yakubovskaya: "Thousands would have to poison themselves and die for people to understand they did something wrong."
Lyubov Yakubovskaya is the deputy general director of Russia's oldest environmental organization. Wildlife Conservation CenterIt was founded in 1992 and is dedicated to addressing environmental issues in Russia.

- This is not "Ecologist Day", this is World Environment DayThis year, people involved in environmental protection won't be "celebrating" anything, of course. I can't imagine anyone in the mood to "celebrate" anything. "Celebrate" would be a better term. So, [the first Sunday in June] is a day when, for example, journalists can remember that there are environmentalists in our society; let's call them and ask how things are going. It's a day when we can identify priorities, tasks, and problems. It's good that such a date exists; it's necessary.
How are we celebrating this date? The environmental community has lost large and powerful allies (Greenpeace, WWF – editor's note), who can no longer even be named. Russian society as a whole has shifted its priorities, and the state apparatus is engaged in a substitution of concepts, with primary objectives being replaced by secondary ones.
Environmental protection is a complex of measures and actions, including educating the younger generation. This is a good thing in its entirety, but now everything else has faded into the background, leaving only education.
But the situation itself is paradoxical: children are initially taught to love and protect nature through high-quality printed materials, and they become imbued with this idea, only to later encounter the exact opposite in real life. Recalling the situation with families from the Stebaevskoye rural settlement, for whom we conducted a public environmental assessment of the Lipetsk Region Ecotechnopark project, we see that the children are defending the purity of their land alongside their parents.
This is true patriotism. And now their families are being pressured. How can this be? We invite children to cleanup days, make videos about it, and admire them. When children protect pristine nature, we should admire them in the same way, not bully them.
What we see from the other side. We, as an environmental organization, inform the Lipetsk Region Ministry of Ecology: Guys, the area where you're planning to build a landfill is home to endangered species. Endangered species roe deer are running around the field, but the [ecotechnopark] project states that there are no endangered species here. People saw and photographed a grey-headed woodpecker, also listed as an endangered species.
Usually, if two Red Data Book species are easily identified by non-professionals, a thorough study by biologists will reveal others. We report this, and the head of the ministry, Roshchupkina, responds, "What about the Red Data Book? We're doing just fine with it; we've published a new edition." What is the Red Data Book for officials? Not a guide to contemplating how to preserve these rare, endangered species and protect them from complete extinction, but a way to simply tell about them with beautiful illustrations.
It shouldn't have been us who mentioned the presence of endangered species, but the eco-technopark designer, who should have surveyed the area first. But businessmen and the authorities don't understand that people's lives are directly dependent on the state of the environment.
In such a society, we must inevitably be prepared—I don't know how prepared we can be—for a global man-made disaster like Chernobyl. Nature is very harsh on those who ignore it. A close examination of what happened at Chernobyl reveals the problem: a system of pervasive lies. Lies about the reactor's condition were passed down and escalated, preventing timely action to prevent the accident, the consequences of which we are still witnessing today.

A major problem for the country is its "Moscow-centricity." Moscow itself is monitored in terms of man-made disasters, but if something alarming were to happen far away, "the wind won't blow on Moscow in time" [in August 2022 near Ryazan]. managed to put out [The large forest fires are only because smoke is spreading toward Moscow—the capital sent equipment and people]—that's where a new "Chernobyl" will occur. It doesn't happen instantly; it's a process, where the "smoldering flame" is already flickering, and the chain of command sends word to Moscow: "Everything is fine here, everything is fine."
What should we do? This is a question for society. Society has allowed us to lose any institutions that protect the environment. No country in the world has a perfect environmental protection mechanism, but they do have non-governmental organizations that address the negative impact of business on the environment and the government's attitude toward it. In our country, however, the NGO system has been emasculated.
There are still NGOs that promote separate waste collection, encourage people to stop using plastic, and plant trees. They're important and necessary, but the problem is that they're the only ones left, while environmental protection requires a multifaceted, multitasking approach. And it's up to society to see that this isn't enough to protect the environment. But humanity doesn't know how to act proactively; only after global catastrophes does it slap itself on the forehead: "Oh, what must we do to prevent this from happening again?" So, I repeat, we're expecting a second Chernobyl. Perhaps it won't be radiation, but chemical contamination, but people don't understand any other way. It would take poisoning, thousands of deaths, for people to understand that they've been doing something wrong.
Arshak Makichyan: "The situation is horrific, and no one is talking about it—there's no one left to."
Arshak Makichyan is known as a Russian activist of the Swedish-born School Strikes for Climate movement ("Fridays for Future"). In 2019, he participated in the UN climate talks in Madrid with renowned environmental activist Greta Thunberg. He was arrested upon his return. In 2022, his family's Russian citizenship documents (they received their citizenship in 2004, after nine years of living in Russia) were invalidated and they were deported. Arshak now lives in Germany. He maintains that environmental problems exist there too, but the attitudes toward the environment among communities, people, businesses, and government officials are strikingly different from those in Russia. For the better.

"Ecologist Day in Russia is more of a mockery, because most environmental organizations have been shut down; there's no longer an independent environmental movement in Russia. Activism is practically banned. Environmental organizations have either shut down or been labeled foreign agents."
Overall, the situation for environmental organizations in Russia is even worse than for political ones. Everyone tried to adapt to the new situation, but it didn't work: there's no longer an environmental movement in the country.
The state is failing to fulfill this role [of environmental protection]. Russia is experiencing an increasing number of environmental disasters, including fires and floods, while corporations are now using war as cover and continuing to destroy nature.
Meanwhile, the environmental organizations that remain in Russia and are dependent on the state are constantly saying: let's get rid of single-use plastic! If you give up plastic straws, the Russian environment will be happier. It doesn't work that way.
The main environmental damage is caused by corporations, and the war has set all environmental projects and climate policy back many years. There are also direct harms from the war: forests in Ukraine are burning due to bombing, and now Russia has seized the Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant. A disaster comparable only to Chernobyl is possible. The situation is horrific, and no one is talking about it—there's no one left to.
One more thing. Kolomensky Park, on Losiny Island, they cut down a lot of trees to install anti-aircraft missiles there because Putin is afraid he'll be hit. No one talks about this; they say, "Let's separate the plastic." That's not environmental activism. Activism, I think, can only be guerrilla-style right now, because it's impossible to do anything legally—they won't let you.
Why are they doing this [the authorities are leading the country toward environmental disaster]? Human stupidity cannot be underestimated. War is a catastrophe. And it's strange to think that people who committed genocide against their neighbors will rush to take care of the trees. If they don't think about their loved ones who are dying there, then there's no point in expecting them to care for nature.
The environmental agenda is dangerous for the government. Many people love nature and protect it wholeheartedly, so they might wonder: why, when our forests are burning, aren't our soldiers out there, on foreign soil, and not here, putting out the fires, protecting people from corporations, and forests from deforestation? And such thoughts will become more and more common.
There are plenty of targeted environmental protests even now: for example, people are defending their communities from landfills. They think environmental protests are safe, because they're protecting their environment; they're not against Putin, they're for their homeland. But they don't have the money or the resources to combat state and corporate propaganda. In fact, even this is quite dangerous right now.

I think environmental protests will become more and more widespread because climate change is causing more and more disasters. I have a feeling that the environmental agenda will still play a significant role in the future of the country. Therefore, it's necessary to talk and write about it; even "anti-war" journalists need to write about the environment, because everything is interconnected.
The hardest thing right now is fighting apathy, not Putin specifically or the specific problems. It's clear what needs to be done: spread information, unite, learn how to use activist tools, but people are afraid to do even small things because they understand that while it might change something, it's dangerous for them. A huge amount of work needs to be done—that's the only way things will change.
Now we need to come up with some tools that are safe for people. We need to find allies [among activists, journalists, and emigrants] so they can spread the information that a resident of a Russian village wouldn't be able to share. For example, you could write to me, or message the movement. Fridays for FutureI'm in another country, so it's safe for me to share this information. But so far, no one has contacted me.
Vladimir Slivyak: "I don't understand why you expect these authorities to show any interest in the environment."
Vladimir Slivyak is the founder of the Kaliningrad organization "Ecodefense!"In 2021, he was one of four laureates of the Swedish Right Livelihood Prize, known as the alternative Nobel Prize. In 2014, Ecodefense! was designated a foreign agent.

"As for Ecologist Day, there's absolutely nothing to celebrate because, alas, there's no positive news. Worse, none is expected. And the reasons for this are purely political."
The authorities in Russia today are 100% responsible for the public and media agenda. And, to put it mildly, the authorities are completely indifferent to environmental issues—they've always had far more important things, and even more so today.
You can strive for a society with equal opportunities, or you can say that unequal opportunities are the norm for us. If opportunities are equal, then the issue of the environment and its preservation naturally becomes a priority. Because it is a shared value for all people. It doesn't matter who you are—government or an ordinary person, a businessman or a journalist—it becomes important to you.
What can you do if the Russian authorities decided a long, long time ago that they're content with a society of unequal opportunities, a situation where "even if everything else is bad, at least we're better off than everyone else." I don't understand why you expect these authorities to show any interest in the environment?
For the authorities to protect not their own personal interests, but those of all, a strong civil society is needed. Democracy is needed so that people can demand that their government protect their interests. Democracy in Russia, alas, has been destroyed.
There are many countries around the world where civil society is suppressed, and, as a rule, environmental issues, like many other issues that matter to ordinary people, are of no concern to the authorities. You can find absolutely dire environmental conditions in many places in India—a fairly large country that proudly calls itself "the world's largest democracy." There is no democracy there.
It's a huge logical fallacy to try to present the situation as if there are some separate, unrelated parts of society's life: things might be bad, but let's separate the environmental issue from everything else. From democracy, for example—surely we can just put out fires and pick up trash from the river? But, alas, life is a bit more complicated.
Civil society, even in a democratic world, is just as inconvenient for the authorities as it is in authoritarian and dictatorial countries. Civil society always demands something from the authorities. The difference lies in how the authorities respond. If these demands are high democratic standards, then the authorities tolerate, concede, and are accountable to society. Because the principle is very simple: society votes for the authorities and feeds them with their taxes. Therefore, the authorities must be accountable, like any employee.
If there are no democratic standards and no specific institutions have been built that guarantee the maintenance of such an order, then the government is omnipotent and can do whatever it wants to anyone who criticizes it.
There's a separate concept—public interests. These are common interests—not for a group of people in power, not for a group that makes money, but for everyone. This public interest can only be protected by society itself. And democracy is the main instrument of protection here. If your tool is taken away, you can't do anything. You can't unscrew a tightly seated nut if you don't have a wrench for that nut. There's no way you can unscrew it with your bare hands. You can try for years, but you won't succeed.
Everyone is to blame for this happening. Everyone should have established some kind of order, everyone should have made an effort, developed this very tool that is needed to improve our lives. None of us did enough.

Regarding environmental problems, in Russia, even during the times when it was believed that society could demand something from the authorities, we didn't see any truly serious steps toward addressing them. And we've had a huge backlog of them since Soviet times.
And, unfortunately, we're now seeing deterioration across every metric in this area. That is, in more than 30 years of post-Soviet life, not a single serious problem has been resolved. Not because they're insurmountable, but because priorities have shifted.
There are landfills, there's plastic, there's radioactive waste, there's extreme air and water pollution in various places. Honestly, I don't understand how to single out any one thing here. I think when you talk to those who deal with fires, they'll probably say that fires are the most important thing. But I think that's wrong. What's the criterion for determining what's most important? It's like, if you solve a problem, then things will immediately improve dramatically not only with this problem but with everything else around it, right? So it has to have some fundamental significance.
But you put out the fires, and next year there will be more. They can't be put out forever. What can be done? They can be minimized. To minimize them, we need to manage the forests wisely. To manage the forests wisely, we need enough people and enough money to do it.

We all remember very well the legislative changes that happened a long time ago. (adoption of the forest code in 2006 - ed.), which led to the complete collapse of the forest protection system in Russia. The difference isn't that there weren't fires before, but now there are. The difference is that they didn't cause such damage before. And the damage today is a direct consequence of how the authorities managed this area.
No one in power was interested in allocating funds for this or taking it seriously. All these civil society advisory bodies, either with ministries or under the president, are a sham. No one, anywhere, has ever managed to systematically solve even a single problem.
If the government isn't interested in this, if it's the lowest priority for them, there's nothing you can do. You can even attend meetings with Putin. The system has to change for anything to change.
And those who demanded a change in the system are now all in places not so far away. Or far away—from the Motherland. Because the authorities didn't want to hear about changing the system. It was more or less tolerable if someone was messing around with some trivial matter and exerting no political influence whatsoever. They turned a blind eye to it: well, some kids were wandering around, collecting papers by the stream, fine, let them do it. In the end, the official would write in his report that he organized it all.
But if this is the only thing allowed, then there will be stinking landfills, leaks from radioactive waste storage facilities, accidents at nuclear power plants, oil refineries, oil tankers, pipeline ruptures, and a million other things—very sad, dangerous things that could have a very serious negative impact on us at any moment. And even lead to the deaths of some people. That's the fact.
What should the reasonable people left here do now? Let them save themselves. As much as we'd like to, there's no way for civil society to achieve anything from the authorities. Any attempt to get even the slightest favor from the authorities risks imprisonment.
If someone has the strength and time to take steps to create opportunities in the future, they must definitely take those steps. If you ask me what they are, I'll say I don't know. But I know this isn't forever. If people want to achieve something useful in life, let them focus on self-preservation for now. The time will come, and then they'll put their strength to good use.
Photos: RightLivelihood.org, KP.ru, Zefirka.net, Foto-ram.ru, "Eyewitnesses", from open sources