"My country went crazy for a while."

On May 31, former police lieutenant colonel from Tomsk Viktor Lavrentyev sentenced to a fine One million rubles for disseminating "fake news" about the Russian army's actions in Ukraine. The criminal case stemmed from Viktor's posts about the events in Mariupol and Bucha.
NeMoskva spoke with Viktor about his sentence, why many in Russia have succumbed to militaristic psychosis and whether it is possible to persuade them otherwise, about the "party of common sense," and about possible relations between Ukraine and Russia after the war.
— Did you expect such a verdict?
"I thought they'd give me whatever they asked for. I had all sorts of options in my head. It's hard to predict anything now. It's obvious to me that the judge didn't make this decision on his own."
— Judging by your latest post on Facebook, you're currently raising money for a lawyer, but do you intend to pay the fine?
"Yes, I was forced to ask. It's embarrassing, but I asked. We'll at least collect half, and I'll do the rest. And I won't pay the fine voluntarily. I'll never, ever voluntarily pay a single kopeck for anything."
— What are the risks of non-payment of a fine?
"I haven't seen a lawyer yet, but I'm capable of doing so; my previous law degree allows it. Sixty days pass and the sentence takes effect, after which it's automatically declared that I'm evading the sentence, and the case is forwarded to the bailiffs. Then the court decides on a different sentence. A fine can't be replaced with imprisonment, nor can forced labor, although I'll need to do some research because the retirement age has changed, so it'll end up being correctional labor, which is unlimited. No big deal, I'll find a low-paying job. Maybe as a security guard."

What did your friends and former colleagues say about your criminal case and the verdict? Did any of your former colleagues offer you unofficial support?
"Yes, people have called me. The problem is that my former colleagues are working elsewhere, so for them, expressing my position would be tantamount to losing my job."
— Were there any old acquaintances who turned their backs on you because of your support for Ukraine? You've been writing about the war for a long time, haven't you?
"No one turned their back on me. I cut down my Facebook feed myself. I can say that no matter what people expressed their opinions online, after a conversation with me, no one uttered the word 'khokhols' in my presence. It's quite easy to explain to people. You don't have to be rude or threaten: just show them that this is ordinary, everyday racism. And, oddly enough, it makes them feel ashamed. And when someone says, 'We're not there, there's a civil war in Ukraine,' that's also quite easy to explain. Well, weapons aren't sold at military stores. Heavy weapons, especially not."
— I understand you intend to sue the people who were witnesses for the prosecution. What will be the subject of the lawsuit?
"Not against those who testified against me, but against those who slandered me. I was very surprised and still can't understand why they're libelling me, just as they did TV2 before. Time has passed, and they're still publishing. I learned that the day after my arrest and search, a completely slanderous article appeared in the Tomsk newspaper Pressoboz. I can't say anything about it being ordered, but it was definitely slanderous. Then these slanderous passages from the article migrated into every commentary on VTomske. Some are now in hiding, while others, like Viktor Fefelov, are still openly lying. Lies like they breathe. I don't know what it's all about. I can assume a lot, but I can't prove it. He's still harassing me and my friends. He recently called my former business partners. He tried to talk to them about me.
Literally everything in that article was slander. The reasons for my dismissal. And the fact that they allegedly spoke with my ex-wife in Strezhevoy. And with one of my colleagues. If they had called my ex-wife, they would have found out we'd been strangers for seven years, and she couldn't tell them much. And they fired me for legitimate reasons: they were sending me into retirement.
I want to meet with this whole team; they have meetings anyway. I'll attend that meeting; I like to talk face to face. There's also another publication; a certain Irina Verkhorubova wrote two articles about me. I've already learned that she's Kostina. It's funny how they always write under pseudonyms. Given my previous work, I always understand who's behind the pseudonyms. Why would a journalist take a pseudonym if they're writing about socially important topics, if no one's threatening them, and if they're not slandering anyone? So I think we should talk to them first, and then go to court.
— Do you hope to win in our court?
"It would be a criminal case—defamation. Not a civil suit. That would be brought later in the trial."
The court also banned you from posting on social media. Will you express your position differently?
— Firstly, posting on social media doesn't prevent me from communicating with my friends on Messenger. At the first request, they gave me all their WhatsApp numbers. And they started calling me. I knew someone on social media, but we'd never spoken to each other. And now there are tons of them. It's been a really interesting experience. They've called from everywhere. From Kazakhstan, the US, Ukraine. And each time, it's an hour-long conversation. People don't so much want to hear from me as they want to talk.
The conversation begins with words of support, and then they talk about how they're taking it all. It's hard to listen to people from Ukraine. I have a friend, he's from Luhansk. He fled there, and after February 24th, he was forced to leave yet another place. He was also forced to move his family to Germany, and then return. It's very difficult. He's an entrepreneur, the same age as me. And this attitude towards me amazes me.
I was actually shocked that not all my Ukrainian friends told me to go to hell. There was only one, but she cut off communication not only with me but with all Russians in general. She didn't delete anyone, she simply moved to another account. Many Russians, so to speak, good dot ru, can't understand this current reluctance of many Ukrainians to communicate with Russians. I don't know what it's all about; perhaps it's an underdeveloped empathy from childhood. Or simply a lack of tact. People can't perceive other people's pain, other people's experiences. I go hiking, and no matter how many times I invite people for a week-long trip to a place where there are no people and wild nature, very few people want to go. A mere handful. Also, unfortunately, few can understand the situation of others, who are under daily bombing.
Yes, of course, the experience is incredible, but the fact is that we've all gone crazy. That's the saddest fact.

— How long do you think the war will last?
— It all depends on what you consider the end. I think the hot phase will end in the fall. In September. Because it's clear that all this talk about red lines has been forgotten. And that by September, Ukraine will have modern aviation. And maybe even sooner. The latest events are a nightmare, of course. Shebekino, forgotten, not a single media outlet mentions it, but Telegram is filled with reports about it. It's a ghost town. It's impossible to live there. There's no electricity, no water, no power. There are no police there.
— In your final statement, you expressed hope that you would see those who persecuted you brought to justice.
"I'm not threatening anyone. It's just that—and they all understand this—by convicting a clearly innocent person, they are committing a criminal offense under the criminal code of the Russian Federation, in which we all live. There's no need to invent anything. No need for a Nuremberg, no need for anything at all. These people committed a criminal offense, that's all. And my appeal in the regional court is not an attempt to evade responsibility. My goal is to implicate as many people as possible, to cover them up for this crime. So that they will be heard in the future. I have no doubt about that. There will never be a situation where Lebedev, for example, first tried dissidents and then became the chairman of the Supreme Court. This must never happen again under any circumstances. Whether Russia survives or falls apart is irrelevant. What matters is that there cannot be a state that does not live within the rule of law. For me, that is obvious."
— How long do you think it will take for this state to cease to exist?
"The only thing I won't speculate about is timing. These are natural processes, and no one can ever predict them. And if someone says something and hits the nail on the head, it means they've said it a hundred times before and hit the nail on the head once. It happens to everyone."
— Are you planning to leave Russia?
— Initially, no. I don't even know what influenced it. Perhaps an unwillingness to give in, to leave my wife, my mother-in-law, a large circle of friends just because the country temporarily went crazy? I don't see any point in that. I'm not left-wing, I'm not right-wing, I have no ideology. The only ideology is common sense. I've long said that we need to create a party of common sense. 20% of the population can join it. The rest don't think rationally. They don't perceive arguments rationally, only the wrapping.
— So that’s why so many people fall victim to propaganda?
— Yes, that's why only 15-20% think. And it doesn't depend on progress. Digitalization, on the contrary, kills the thinking process. The more information there is, the less you have to think. I'm talking to a guy in the bathhouse, and I realize he's getting his information from the resources available on television. I'm trying to talk to him, and he says, "Look, it's everywhere." I pressed a button and it starts pouring out. I tell him, "Look, you use the internet and so do I." And we get completely different information. It's like in a library. You can go to a big library and get the Kama Sutra. And read it to your heart's content. Alone or in company with someone. Or you can pick up a book by a philosopher. It's a choice we make. And responsibility for our choice lies with us, but those same 15-20% are ready to accept it. The rest don't want to and won't. It's useless. And there's no need to convince them otherwise. It's impossible. But you can learn to talk to them in a way that gets them to ask questions and behave appropriately. And then the person changes before your eyes. Cognitive dissonance sets in, and some even start to get headaches.

I've been through this pitfall. There's no need to attack anyone, no need to impose your opinion. You need to ask the right questions, ones that will force them to think a little before answering. How does one begin the thought process when answering a question they don't have an answer to? First, by running through cliches, and then, bam, that cliche isn't there. And you have to figure it out yourself. And the person's face even changes. I was into portrait photography and always wondered why people's faces changed on those same local history tours by Alexey Bagayev (Tomsk journalist and historian – editor's note) are strikingly different from the crowd in the store. Because people listen and think. And their faces change.
— You said the country had gone mad. Do you think it's possible to cure people of this psychosis?
"There's no need to treat anyone. I'll say it again: they haven't accepted rational arguments before, and they won't accept them in the future. And these stupid hopes that we'll start telling the whole truth online and everything will change are based on the ignorance of those who say them."
You know, I tried the questioning method on my mom. During the pandemic, my mom watched a video about Sputnik on YouTube. And she refused to get vaccinated. Because Putin did it. I asked her, "Where did you get this information? Do you know who invented this vaccine?" And so, step by step, step by step. And then I found out she went and got vaccinated. But it was useless. My mom wasn't an anti-vaxxer. There's no difference between anti-vaxxers and those who say Sputnik doesn't work. Both sides don't understand rational arguments.
— Will this questioning method work for the country as a whole? Or will defeat in the war be the answer?
"A defeat, yes. The entire paradigm of a strong, top-down government is based on the people thinking they're strong. But there's no power left, and this is all happening before our eyes. It will all end quite quickly. Sad or not, how will it go, what's the scenario? If someone starts saying they know how it will go, they seem like a self-righteous fool. They don't understand that these processes are impossible to predict. There are too many variables. It can't be calculated."
It depends on what you consider a victory. What's the timeframe? It all depends on many things. I know what needs to change. Unfortunately, no one ever talks about it here. I get the impression that our opposition isn't ready to think about anything other than how to get them to power. And then, supposedly, everything will change. And rational arguments are accepted by the same 15-20%, no matter who comes to power—Putin, Lenin, or Sakharov. And the figure doesn't change. The only thing that can change this is education, according to the Finnish model. And our education minister gave his daughter a push-button telephone for her 15th birthday.
— After the end of the war, do you see any kind of relationship between Russia and Ukraine?
— Only a generational change can change anything. Like it was in Germany. We're told this fairy tale that Germany was supposedly forced to change, denazified, because they were taken somewhere, shown a movie. And they keep telling us this nonsense. And the fact that it's nonsense isn't said because it didn't work, and hasn't worked. People left and said Hollywood made it all up. Exactly the same thing the so-called "wadding" is saying now. An unthinking generation. A generation has changed in Germany, and even in Germany itself, there are people who have broken the ice. I was very surprised when I received information from a feature film about when Auschwitz was first discussed. And what it cost two prosecutors. It's the film "In the Labyrinth of Silence." The year is 1958. How much time has passed!
But we have a big bonus. When we talk about the Germans and try to draw historical analogies, we immediately fall into the trap of ignorance. Because there can be no direct analogies. Under Hitler, there was a totalitarian regime. We don't have that. Here we are, looking out the window. Do we see Z-marks driving by? No. If there were totalitarianism, not a single car would drive by without a Z-mark. And how did totalitarianism work under Adolf Hitler? 41-42 million Germans lived in the Reich, of which 800 were sent to concentration camps for their anti-Nazi stance. 80 of them were shot. 80% of the adult population was destroyed or broken. But we don't have any of that. Many people like me ended up in prison. I was simply lucky; I was the first to have a criminal case brought against me. Why first? Because I was absolutely the first to be charged in the country. Then Novikova.
I don't believe anyone will serve seven or eight years. But even a year can be difficult, especially if you're being targeted, like Navalny, for example. And everyone involved must be held fully accountable for this crime. They all knew; none of them were mistaken, believe me. Yes, that FSB agent we questioned in court, when I asked him point-blank: "What constitutes direct intent?" And what of the materials you handed over to the investigation proves that I knew my post was knowingly false? Even if you believe it's untrue." The FSB agent froze. He was silent for forty seconds until the judge decided to deflect the question. And it seemed, for the first time, he considered the possibility that he'd simply committed a crime. If he still had any legal training left. That the prosecutor understood this perfectly was evident in her reaction. When we were waiting for the verdict, she said hello to the lawyer and ran past me.

We would like to add that Viktor Lavrentyev is currently raising money to pay for a lawyer to file an appeal. His Sberbank account details are 40817810464001112329. The account number is also linked to +7-906-954-44-71, and the owner is Valentina Dmitrievna S.
