Time to read: 15 minutes(s)

"Our parents grew up on myths, we grew up on myths, and young people grow up on myths."

Human rights activist, chairman of the regional branch of the Golos movement in the Ryazan region Sofia Ivanova — about what we would like to see in post-Putin Russia

Sofia Ivanova is the director of the Ryazan School of Human Rights and a laureate of the Moscow Helsinki Group Prize for her contribution to the promotion of human rights. She describes herself as a "child of propaganda" until the late 1980s: she headed the city's Komsomol headquarters, joined the communists, interacted with the party's elite, and returned her party card. In the mid-1990s, she learned of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other international documents enshrining human rights in the modern world and realized that this was "her thing." She began using training methods to promote human rights values. Around 2010, she became an election observer and the head of the regional "Golos" organization. Turnintimidation and “warnings” – the arson of a room where the Human Rights School classes were held, the looting and damage to a car, dismissal from the lyceum, вkey She survived her inclusion on the foreign agent registry philosophically, thanks to the support of her family and friends. She believes that Russia must change. But first, all the historical lies must be exposed, and change must take place in people's minds. A NeMoskva correspondent spoke with her about this.

— How do you envision Russia's state structure "after Putin"?

"I don't think Russia will transform itself overnight. For our country to be different, it's not enough to have just one model, even the most perfect one. Because change must happen in our minds. In the minds of so many people, the scale of which is incomparable to that of other countries."

Because it's 140 million. Because it's a vast territory. Because it's rooted in established traditions, large-scale and very stable connections and social attitudes that are absolutely impossible to reform overnight. 

Russia's cultural characteristics developed over several centuries. We have been shaken since the formation of the state. We have never had stability. As soon as it arose, either external conquerors arrived or rulers with a different vision of the state than those who came before. Or new territories with their own centuries-old foundations and traditions were annexed. These had to be adapted to Russia. Throughout its history, Russia has been and remains an empire—an empire uniting very different cultures.

— Will Russia remain a unified state or not? Which is best, in your opinion?

"I think it won't survive even under the best possible system. Because no empire ever leads to anything good. Empires have a certain peak, then inevitably decline, and then they disintegrate. And Russia, as a multicultural state, will disintegrate into those very cultures. I don't think that's the worst option."

Looking ahead to the question of which model to follow, I'll say I really like the European Union model. It's where different states—with their own characteristics, their own traditions, their own rich histories—unite under a single flag with a collective authority. European states, having traveled difficult historical paths without losing their distinctiveness and independence, have learned to live together.

I would very much like Russia to be structured in the same way. I would like every territory that feels self-sufficient, that has a sense of its own identity, to become an independent, self-governing territory. And I would like us to be able to join forces to solve common problems. 

It's similar to the US model, where each state enjoys a great deal of independence. American society is similar across the different states in its multiculturalism. But not in Europe. United Germans are one thing, united French are another, united Spaniards are a third... Each ethnic group retains its own distinct identity. At the same time, they live by common standards and rules. I really hope the Russia of the future will be something like this.

Of course, European culture is a product of hardship. Europeans fought so many wars, divided their territories, created their own property, passing it on to future generations... And yet, they preserved a rich cultural and historical potential.

Here's what seems very important to me: in modern, civilized Europe, there are fewer "historical lies." But we have a lot of them. We don't know the truth about the South, the North, the West, or the East. I'm not talking about the legal aspect, but the historical one. 

Take Siberia, for example, which we call our own. Whose land was it 300 years ago? And who owned it 500, or 1000 years ago? Yermak marched through Siberia, and that's it, Siberia is ours. But people had already lived there before, imbuing this land with their roots.

Or is the Far East ours? Why do the Chinese consider it theirs too? Why do the Japanese consider it theirs? We were the ones who invented it. Or why do we consider Yakutia, Buryatia, Kalmykia, Tatarstan, Bashkiria, Karelia, and so on, "our" territories? Let me clarify again: I'm not talking about the legally established borders established by states in the 19th and 20th centuries. I'm talking about "roots," about historical myths and facts.

We wrote today's history textbooks in the 20th century. And the 20th century wasn't that long ago. We saw with our own eyes how politicians drew new borders, dividing countries and peoples...

Let me return to the fact that modern Europe has more historical truth. We have a history that's been written and rewritten, driven by opportunistic political agendas. And perhaps if we lay out the real truth, the territories will also take a different approach. I'm not calling for collapse! No, I'm not. Because any restructuring, any perestroika, is traumatic for people; it's incredibly stressful for contemporaries. No one likes to live in times of change. Naturally, I don't want a civil war either.

— Is there a model to follow, or does Russia have its own path?

I like small states with a strong center and developed local government. I'm not insisting that Russia should have the same, because our traditions are somewhat different. And I've already said before that I like the European Union model. But within the EU, there's France, for example, with its unitary system, and there's Germany, for example, where federalism is very strong. Both work.

I don't care which of these territorial models will be adopted in Russia. The existence of developed local self-government is fundamentally important. It is at the grassroots level that decisions should be made on how to live, what problems to solve, how, and with what resources.

And self-government must not be merely decorative, as in the Soviet Union, nor like that of the Gorbachev transition and Yeltsin periods. And especially not like what exists in the Russian Federation today. In fact, local territorial self-government does not exist in modern Putin's Russia. 

And it's not hard to guess why it was "cut down to the roots," even though it is provided for by the Constitution. The process of curtailing it began in the late 90s. Russia's policy during the Putin era is one of strong state power and decorative municipal authority. Today, everything is under the control of the central government.

The remnants of local self-government disappeared before our eyes. Reforms in this direction gradually began in the mid-2010s. Quietly, step by step. Many didn't even pay attention to them at first. Here, village councils were given slightly less authority, there, territorial entities were slightly enlarged, there, governors appointed supervisors over local government representatives... Direct mayoral elections disappeared almost everywhere. First at the district level, then at the level of large territorial entities like cities, making an important decision without approval from a higher authority is impossible.

Nowadays, to effectively resolve something locally, it's not enough to secure popular support. You won't accomplish anything unless you secure the support of higher authorities. 

A self-nominated mayor must join United Russia to repair a road in his village. If you don't join United Russia, you won't get a bridge, a playground, or a fence for your kindergarten. This isn't even Soviet-style; it's a more sophisticated version of centralized power.

— Should Russia become smaller in territorial terms?

I believe the population should decide how to live more comfortably. If Chechnya, or Ingushetia, or Yakutia want independence and believe they can handle their own problems, then there's no need to keep them. We shouldn't lose touch with them. Mutually beneficial economic, social, and cultural relations have been quite stable over the past 200-300 years. But to say: you have the right to self-determination.

Georgia, Armenia, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, and others seceded in the 1990s... Back then, they said, "They won't survive without us!" They survived, overcame difficulties, developed, forged their own paths, and built their own states. 

It's possible to live without Russia. Ukraine, for example, separated from Russia and began building a normal state focused on human rights, its people, and its culture. Belarus, however, failed to "splinter" from the Russian Federation—it remains a dictatorship. If the peoples living in today's Russia want to remain part of the Russia of the Future, that's also their right, their choice. The size of the country doesn't matter. You can be a large, repressive state, or a small, rule-of-law one. And vice versa.

How should power be structured during a period of transition? Which institution can serve as the governing body during this period?

We're in for a "power-sharing." A fight will begin over who will take the helm. I'd like to see educated people, scholars, come to power. What's that called? Aristocracy, meritocracy... I'd like them to be people who know history, political science, and cultural issues. I'd like them to be people who can add two and two together, think analytically, and understand cause and effect.

Academician Vernadsky called the type of political structure or social system "based on the primacy of human reason" noocracy. I would like to see noocrats come to power during the transition. 

No, they won't be able to stay in power for long, but during the transition period, they can play a very positive role in guiding society toward a model that would work specifically in the Russia of the Future. And to do that, we need to think ahead. I really want the vanguard to be people who understand our culture and have observed how other countries live. Moreover, they've seen different models of social organization. They've looked at them and said, "Aha, this can be applied to our culture, and this can't." We need analysts. They most likely won't become the ones to lead Russia forward, but they should bring in the optimal leadership.

— Can Russia avoid civil war after the fall of the current regime?

"I think a bloody war—precisely one with a lot of bloodshed—can be avoided. But a war without bloodshed is inevitable—it's already underway. The war began in 2014. We're divided between those who are "for" and those who are "against." Is Crimea ours or not, is the "special operation" in Ukraine good or bad? And we're not ready to talk. We've become very polarized."

We won't reach an agreement, we won't find common ground for decades to come. We, citizens, are at war with each other—on the same street, in our courtyards, in cities and villages, at work and at home—we don't see eye to eye. This is an ideological war. And changing anything here won't happen quickly.

I want less bloodshed. It's already there... Our march on Ukraine is already a civil war. The regime has pitted Russians and Ukrainians against each other—and yet we practically speak the same language, we share the same roots. Half of Russia has either relatives or friends in Ukraine. And conflicts have arisen between them. I don't know a single family right now that doesn't have its share of conflicts, small and large tragedies. The regime will fall, but the "front lines" will remain—some on one side, others on the other. So many tragedies! So much pain! So much tears and despair, I don't think we've ever seen in our lifetime. Perestroika was difficult, but we knew we had to tighten our belts, we'll survive, we'll cope. In our heads, we had this idea that we would build our democratic state, and everyone would live well. But now we're divided into "us" and "them" at the level of values. And changing them won't be easy. Even among the younger generation.

— Russia had a chance to democratize in the 20th century. What went wrong? Or was there no chance?

— There wasn't. There wasn't, because we didn't renounce imperial attitudes and imperial ambitions. We didn't conduct lustrations. We didn't ask for forgiveness. We didn't restore normal relations in society—the definition of "enemy of the people" hasn't disappeared; it remains. We haven't rid ourselves of corruption. We don't have an independent judiciary. We don't have freedom of speech. We haven't overcome slavish obedience.

We haven't arrived at the values ​​of human rights and humanism. So what, what will change if nothing has changed in our minds? Nothing will change. In other words, we never had a chance for democracy from the start.

I've come to this conclusion over the past few years. I've seen the institution of elections literally being destroyed by hand! There's nothing more important to a democratic state than the institution of elections. It was destroyed step by step, piecemeal, and very deliberately. And in the end, it practically disappeared. That is, we have electoral events called "elections," but we haven't had elections for several years. If we admit this, it means democracy was never intended to exist.

Maybe the people themselves want this? Many analysts say that, yes, the people are indifferent. And there are dozens of explanations for this. But I still can't understand why...

At one point, I blamed my parents' generation. How come you didn't see what was going on? You didn't see what Stalin was doing, what Khrushchev was doing? Then I realized—yes, you didn't. Take my parents, for example... As teenagers, they lived through the war and famine. They lived with their two children in a rented corner apartment, three by three meters, separated from three other similar families by curtains. And they got a three-room apartment in a Khrushchev-era building... And they were happy. They were happy that there were no bombings and that there was food. They were both convinced communists and worked honestly to ensure that the country would be prosperous, that their children would be healthy and receive a good education. They condemned the exploitative Americans, went to Brezhnev's elections and to the May Day demonstrations. They did it so honestly, so sincerely, that I, a Pioneer, also believed that we were building communism. They didn't even suspect that "something was going wrong."

I think my generation was also mistaken for a long time. My parents were mistaken in thinking they were building communism, and we were mistaken in thinking we were moving toward democracy...

Much of my consciousness has been reshaped by teaching human rights and observing elections. Human rights and elections are a combination that has transformed my outlook on life completely from what it was 30 years ago. I became firmly entrenched in the ideals of liberalism and humanism, but I stopped believing that we could change society and fundamentally alter the system. We failed. There is hope for today's youth. But I see how every day yet another great imperial "patriotic" lie is poured into their ears and hearts.

That is, our parents grew up on myths, we grew up on myths, and young people are also growing up on myths...

I believe that until we restore our history to its truest form, learn the hard lessons, and draw conclusions, nothing will change. Once we start calling a spade a spade, there will be a chance to build democracy.

— Can national entities become agents of change? Is it possible to predict what direction of change they would prefer? Complete sovereignty or…?

"In my opinion, national entities can be agents of individual change. But they lack the strength to effect global change. They lack the resources—material, human, or intellectual. The idea that people will rebel only when they're utterly impoverished also doesn't hold true. They've become so impoverished, they can't get any further. Even the last generation in the provinces doesn't even know what a toilet is..."

It's bittersweet to say, but... maybe someone who's been to Ukraine and seen that every village house has a proper toilet will come back and tell their fellow villagers that everyone's been living differently for a long time? And that Ukrainians don't expect handouts from the government—they build their own toilets, houses, and cities. And they elect the government they trust. The key word is "elect."

— Is there anything that can be done now? Who can be the agent of change for the better today? The opposition has been destroyed, and about a million active young people have emigrated. Is there any chance for change from within?

— To record the "historical truth." To document election crimes, crimes related to legislative changes, instances of corruption, abuse of office, usurpation of power, and so on. To tell the truth, to call a spade a spade. Even in these difficult times.

Now we [foreign agents, Golos] have been banned from observing, but there are many people we've trained in observation, trained to spot all the loopholes the authorities exploit for fraud. Golos's methods work even if a Golos representative isn't present in the electoral commission building. And when you also engage in long-term observation (analyzing the political situation six months or a year before the elections), a lot becomes clear.

For example, how municipal filters and signature collections are used to weed out "unnecessary" candidates. How spoilers are used. How administrative resources are deployed to promote the "right" candidate. 

It's possible to collect, analyze, and publish facts even with a small group, without millions of activists, and even without being in Russia. I believe that citizens who don't give up and continue to take "small steps"—each in their own area of ​​civic oversight and public engagement (for example, in human rights, elections, the environment, education, medicine, and social issues)—are the ones who bring about positive change.

And let's hope for the best. We need to take care of ourselves—our physical and emotional health. We need to maintain our connections, our social circles. We need to support each other. 

We need to continue organizing events, learning, exchanging information, discussing, debating, persuading, and being convinced. Who else but us? We also need to understand that we are not alone in our desire for change. Doubts and hopes live in a wide variety of communities—among businessmen, doctors, teachers, builders, taxi drivers, cyclists, urban planners, IT professionals, gardeners… Thinking people haven't gone anywhere; we just rarely interact with the majority. It's important to "signal" that they are not alone. Then they won't give up. And we must talk! Talk to each other. That's what we must do. At the very least. No matter what.

Photo: screenshots from the "MYR" and "7x7" segments