Time to read: 13 minutes(s)

"If this is a marginalized person, is it worth helping him?"

What is modern slavery, how and who gets there?

Andrey Berdnikov A man from Voronezh fattened bulls on a Chechen farm. In exchange for this, he received food and shelter, and spent 13 years in forced labor. Oleg Fedorov Without legs and fingers on his left hand, he first ended up in a Moscow homeless shelter, then in labor slavery with the gypsies - he was taken daily to a "spot" for begging. Egor Degtyarev A man from Chelyabinsk went to work as a shepherd in the Samara region and found himself on a farm among fields and sheep, without money or cell phone service. The food was poor, and the man caught fish and crayfish. He, like мmany others, managed to give the volunteers of the Alternative movement his contact information and escape from labor slavery. The day before World Day Against Trafficking people NeMoskva spoke with the coordinator for applications and operational work at the Alternative movement. Alexey Nikitin — about modern slavery and its causes.

How do people, with so many sources of information, continue to trust the first person they meet and fall into slavery?

People know there are scams, financial pyramids, and scams, but they still fall victim to them. It's a philosophical question. People who end up in forced labor and other forms of slavery are usually in desperate circumstances. If a person has a family, a home, and a stable job, they're much less likely to fall victim. And recruiters take advantage of this. The same thing happens if someone wants to overcome an addiction and is offered rehabilitation in a workhouse. There are two options: you can end up in a very harsh environment, where you'll be forced to pray from morning until night, working in between and barely eating, or there are perfectly normal workhouses where even wheelchair users live and work peacefully from home. Sometimes workhouses, too, suffer in a sense from "runaway" residents who simply come to spend the night, wash and shave, and run away. They don't want to work at any kind of job. But you can’t tell from the ad what awaits you, it’s a bit of a guessing game.

They most often end up there by responding to ads on the internet or on a pole, to recruiters at train stations, or to stories from fellow travelers when a person is left in a desperate situation, especially alone on the road.

Help 
The Alternative movement was founded in 2011 to help people trapped in labor, poverty, sexual, and domestic slavery. It was founded by Oleg Melnikov, who disappeared on September 9, 2022, in the Kharkiv region while transporting humanitarian aid. Coordinator Alexey Nikitin, a volunteer with Alternative since its inception, has taken over as its leader. The movement relies on donations and does not participate in grant competitions. Melnikov previously donated almost all of his business profits to the movement, but now the volunteers are sponsored by fellow citizens. Every year, the volunteers rescue between 80 and 120 people from slavery. This year, 52 people were rescued.   

Can you paint a psychological and social portrait of a modern slave? Who falls for the recruiters' tricks?

— No. Society views these people as a generalized type—either a generic "alcoholic" or a generic "loafer," but it's much more complicated than that. If it were that simple—people willing to work for a drink would end up in labor slavery—there would be no one left to help. All labor slavery is based on the philosophy: "We'll use the labor force that's hanging around the streets doing nothing anyway, and we'll involve them in our economic activity—at least there's some benefit." It's a cynical philosophy. However, everyone is different, and those who don't agree to such conditions, who don't fit into these categories, end up in labor slavery. There's a high turnover rate there—people run away. And the public, and often the police, view these people as a specific social type, lumping them together without any compassion. Although, after all, even such conventional alcoholics and loafers shouldn't be forced into slavery.

Sometimes a person misses a train, has no documents, and is panicking, but at the station they're offered a part-time job. And they think, "I won't bother my family, I'll quickly solve my problems myself," and then they get caught. They're panicked and broke. It's clear that no one is going to recruit the prosecutor's son.

Do you have a story that particularly resonated with you?

"Once, we didn't exactly rescue, but rather helped a man who had already escaped from a farm in Kalmykia. His "owners" caught up with him on the road, ran him over with their car, and simply drove back. He suffered a fractured pelvis. A driver picked him up and took him to the hospital in Astrakhan, and then we helped him get home. He underwent treatment for several months, and his mother was waiting for him at home. Now he's in a wheelchair; if he completes rehabilitation, he'll probably be able to walk with a cane.

The story of Dmitry Burtsev
A Stavropol resident went to work in Kalmykia. The farm owner, Magomed, confiscated his passport and phone, didn't pay him for the work, and frequently beat him. In March 2021, he fled the farm. His "owners" caught up with him on the highway and ran him over, breaking his pelvis. They then beat him while he was lying down and abandoned him on the side of the road, telling him, "Let him stay here to die." He crawled along the R-216 highway toward Astrakhan for two days, but no one paid attention to the injured man. Only on the third day did a concerned driver stop and call an ambulance. He spent three days in intensive care, after which his story became known to "Alternative." 

How willing are our police and law enforcement agencies in other countries to help you?

"They help more often than not, but I'll come back to that: the problem isn't corruption, it's people's minds. Many people think that if someone is marginalized, why help them? They'll end up back on the streets anyway, and then with another 'master.' So what difference does it make who they work for? Besides, the police don't benefit from it: more often than not, there's no crime. Forcible detention and imprisonment means the police show up and find people chained up. But who's going to keep them chained up—they won't be able to work then? It happens, but rarely and for short periods—as a punishment. More often than not, this detention isn't physical, but rather through blackmail and threats that can't be proven. Even if they take away someone's documents, they have a universal excuse: "He gave them to me for safekeeping."

Although, there are exceptions here too. Recently, we rescued a woman from Uzbekistan whose husband hadn't been abusing her, just locking her out. We went with the police, she filed a report, and has now flown home. I don't know how the criminal case is progressing, but at least there was all the evidence.

In contrast, Valery Galaktionov's story—he wasn't even told that two Russian citizens could fly in, sign for him, and he could have received a temporary certificate for his flight home. This is pure indifference.

The story of Valery Galaktionov
Valery Galaktionov from Tomsk served in a military unit in Armenia. After his discharge, his patronymic was misspelled in his documents: "Petrovich" was written instead of "Pavlovich." Because of this "document," he couldn't board a plane or even leave Karabakh. He was forced to take jobs in exchange for food and shelter—and this continued for 23 years. He could have asked two people with Russian citizenship to verify his identity, but the consulate "forgot" to tell him this. He could have been forcibly deported, but they didn't. Meanwhile, he was listed as missing in Russia. "Alternativa" helped him return home, despite another mistake in his documents, this time with his last name misspelled. Upon crossing the border, volunteers had to pay a fine for Galaktionov for overstaying his stay in the country.  

What is the ggeography of modern labor slavery?

"All agricultural regions and large cities, where there are many workhouses and cheap labor is needed. Primarily agriculture. There were also brick factories in Dagestan, but they've now closed. Everything there was simple: clay, barracks, two machines for making the bricks. And cheap labor brought in from Moscow."

The State Duma regularly passes laws. Are there any legislative changes that could end labor slavery?

"We have good legislation; you can work within it if you want to. It's not a legal problem that only six to eight cases a year reach court, and only if they're truly brutal. Take that man with the broken pelvis: the "owner" was given a one-year suspended sentence for using slave labor. And the investigation into the hit-and-run is still ongoing. Considering no one witnessed the hit-and-run..."

Alexander's story
Alexander, a Kaluga resident, came to Moscow and found a good job as an asphalt paver. He lived in a dormitory and earned a salary, but one day while working, he tripped and fell, and was hit by a crawler tractor. He lost his leg. Despite having relatives in his native Kaluga, no one wanted to help him return home, and he fell into "begging slavery." He was brought daily to his "workplace"—an area near three train stations. When a follower of the "Alternative" social media groups decided to rescue Alexander himself, he encountered serious resistance from his "owners." He was soon freed by "Alternative" volunteers and handed over to the Social Patrol. 

How seriously are you exposed to danger when you go to rescue someone from slavery?

"I wouldn't overdramatize it; nothing serious usually happens. Understand this: modern slavery is a hidden crime, difficult to prove; the entire charge can be based solely on the victim's word, nothing else. At best, he'll get a year's probation, as in the case already discussed. And why resort to open violence? For the sake of a worker who's easier to find a new one? Why? It's risky, it's unreasonable. When no one's watching, a slave can be beaten, but when volunteers arrive and everything happens "under the streetlight," and sometimes even right next to the police, the "owner" will simply say, "No, no, he came himself, he did the work himself." And the police will say, "Yes, yes, he did it himself, let's just leave and forget everything."

If there were more shelters and overnight shelters for homeless people in the regions, would this solve the problem at least partially?

— That's not it. Out of five people we rescue, maybe one is homeless. There are plenty of shelters. That's different. If you live in a more or less large city and are unemployed, finding another job isn't a problem. Homelessness is only tangentially related to slavery; most often, people are looking for work. Unemployment, the inability to find a decent job in small towns and villages—that's the reason. Especially for people who have been in prison, who were fired from their previous job for some bad thing. If someone slips up even once, it's a serious [stigma] for the employer. And they have to take on odd jobs, like security guards. But then a recruiter comes along and offers them the moon. And the person thinks: what if I leave now, I'll work hard, but at least I'll improve my financial situation. This is what happens with migrants: a friend of my second cousin's offered me a job in Russia for $500—that's crazy money for them. I came to Russia, and everything was different. It wasn't $500, and even $500 is nothing compared to the prices. The work was hard, and everything was terrible.

Another problem: ignorance, even unwillingness to know. You go to work in Burma [Myanmar], well, Google what this is countriesаWhat is this Golden Triangle? Just press the right keys—no, it doesn't come to mind. My head's already calculating my salary.

The story of Andrei Chorns
One of the latest cases brought by "Alternative" is that of Andrei Chorns. He arrived in the Adyghe village of Sadovoe to pick zucchini for a woman named Asya, who didn't pay him, fed him once a day, and generously "served" him alcohol. Andrei didn't drink and asked about his wages, but Asya replied that she was very ill and "had nothing to eat." The village consists of large farmsteads with greenhouses, owned by Kurds, often related to each other. Andrei was rescued, but dozens of other citizens, reduced to slave labor, have yet to be rescued. A local police officer explained it this way: there are approximately 600 migrant workers in the village. Their attempts to escape often result in them simply ending up in a neighboring house, where they are forced to work as well. From a legal perspective, there is nothing to complain about: people are not tied up or locked in their homes, and wages can be withheld "by mutual agreement."

Can the media and the public somehow help eradicate this phenomenon?

"Little by little, but information wears away a stone. We ourselves are constantly working on this. We still need to change people's mentalities [to stop considering those trapped in slavery as marginalized]; everyone is different. And we come across people who are very unpleasant—alcoholics, degenerates—but more often than not, perfectly normal people become our "clients." First of all, we need to get rid of our attitude toward those trapped in slavery, and secondly, we need to be a police officer. If someone comes to work, check their documents, talk to them. And if a worker complains to them about something, it means they're complaining, there's a reason. Domestic violence—this problem is usually dismissed as "below the radar," as some kind of intra-family, domestic squabble. These are not domestic squabbles. It's not like human rights are for some so-called "us, white people," and not for "them, other social categories"—they don't exist. Human rights aren't divided; they are for everyone. Let me repeat: sometimes we truly help marginalized people, but the question isn't whether we should help them or not, because we're not fighting people and their qualities, but a phenomenon. Many don't understand this; they start to argue: is it worth helping them if they're a migrant, if they're marginalized? But that's not the point, the point is that it worsens the state of society. If it's okay to [enslave and humiliate] migrants and marginalized people, then other segments of the population will be able to too. First the "second class," then the rest of us.

Harmful advice from "Alternative"

What can you do to ensure you're enslaved? "Alternative" gives you the lowdown!

1) Go to the train station to look for work. Drink alcohol to lift your spirits. 2) When someone approaches you with an offer of a good job at sea, don't ask about any of the terms—it's rude. Why do you need to know where you'll be going, what you'll have to do, and how much you'll be paid? You'll figure it out when you get there! 3) Don't tell any of your family that you've got a job—you're a self-sufficient adult. Don't tell them the bus number, the employer's name, or the destination. By the way, have a drink with your employer to celebrate the deal. 4) Upon arrival at the brick factory for a 16-hour workday, accept with wise calm that the terms are different from those originally outlined by your employer. Such people always embellish things a little. Give your phone and passport to the new employer as quickly as possible, otherwise you'll lose them. 5) In the evening, drink the alcohol the employer kindly offered you. Do this every evening. 6) If any of your coworkers decide to leave the workplace without permission, be sure to inform the boss. You might never see them again, but you'll get an extra helping of alcohol. Voila—you're in labor slavery!