Time to read: 21 minutes(s)

"I think he's a good man. He won't put me in jail."

How a pensioner, convicted for two reposts on VKontakte, lived and why she received five and a half years in prison.

Pensioner Evgeniya Maiboroda didn't call for rebellion or set fire to a military enlistment office. But she enjoyed social media—and didn't approve of the "special operation." This was enough to land her on the extremist watch list: on January 29, 2024, Maiboroda was sentenced to 5,5 years for two reposts on VKontakte. She defended herself by claiming they were made out of emotion—her cousin had been injured in a shelling attack in Dnipro the previous day. But the court didn't take this into account.

"NotMoscow Speaking" tells the story of a pensioner who became a victim of her own impetuosity—and immense loneliness.

Evgenia Maiboroda is 72 years old. She spent over forty of those years living in a five-story prefab apartment building on the outskirts of Shakhty, a mining town in the Rostov region. Neighbors respect her as "Auntie Zhenya": "A very intelligent woman with a subtle sense of humor."

In recent years, Mayboroda rarely left the house, even to her beloved church, as her health was failing her. She mostly prayed alone at home, and also watched YouTube and VKontakte—she had mastered social media several years ago.

That's why the building's residents were very surprised when police raided Evgenia's apartment on February 13, 2023.

"She was sitting in the hallway, and they were running around the apartment, stealing books, poking around everywhere," recalls Maiboroda's neighbor, Vera Ivanovna. Upon hearing about the search, she went up to the second floor to see Evgenia. "I told them, 'You won't find anything! I'll protect her!' I started yelling at them, and they kicked me out."

The next morning, Maiboroda was visited by another neighbor, Tamara Mikhailovna. All three women were pensioners. They chatted, sometimes helping each other with household chores.

— I ask: "Zhenya, what was that?" And she's scared, confused, her eyes are huge! She says: "I don't understand." They frayed her completely—the search lasted from four in the afternoon until ten in the evening.

Neighbors consider Evgeniya Mayboroda an exemplary wife and housewife.

The police found nothing illegal in the apartment. Their main "catch" was Mayboroda's phones and SIM cards. According to law enforcement, the pensioner used them to commit two criminal offenses: disseminating "fake news" about the Russian army and publicly calling for extremism (parts 2 of Articles 207.3 and 280 of the Russian Criminal Code). The charges were based on two reposts on VKontakte. One claimed 87 civilians had allegedly died in Mariupol, while the other depicted a girl against a swastika preparing to "slaughter Russians."

At the hearing, Maiboroda claimed she posted the images out of emotion: her cousin had been injured in a shelling attack in Dnipro the previous day. Despite this, on January 29, 2024, she was sentenced to five and a half years in prison. Immediately after the verdict, her nose began to bleed. She fainted in the pretrial detention center.

"She burned her hands with cigarette butts."

The buildings here are low—no more than five stories. Fresh signs reading "Shelter" are everywhere on the darkened walls. Tire sculptures and rows of garages line the courtyards. The streets seem to be crisscrossed with peeling heating pipes. This is what Maysky, the neighborhood where Evgenia Maiboroda lived, looks like.

Residents appreciate its convenience: "Everything is nearby—kindergartens, the hospital, schools. There are Pyaterochka, Magnit, and Chizhik."

Maysky used to be an urban-type settlement. After the Great Patriotic War, it was built by German prisoners of war for the workers of the mine of the same name, located ten kilometers away. But in 2002, the mine closed, and the settlement merged with the city. Only the remains of "Mayskaya," the original purpose of the project, remain. ruins.

House in the village of Maysky

Evgenia and her husband, Nikolai, worked at this mine their entire lives. They met at the mining technical school, where Maiboroda graduated with honors. She married and had a son. Neighbors say of her love for her husband: "She's all there for him, all there for him."

"He was an extraordinary beauty! A real hero. So strong, with pitch-black eyebrows," exclaims Evgenia's distant relative, Marina Ermolaeva.Name changed — note from "NotMoscow Speaking"). She's 54 years old, a teacher. – She was tiny compared to him, and he always picked her up in his arms. And their son, Sergei, was, of course, their beloved, their only one.

At Mayskaya, Evgenia worked as a power engineer at the substation, monitoring the electrical grid. Her husband was a team leader in the team of the famous Mikhail Chikh, a two-time Hero of Socialist Labor. Since the late 60s, this team thundered throughout the Union, setting record after record in coal production.

The miners earned a good living—Yevgenia's family knew no need. She and her husband traveled throughout the Soviet Union and the socialist bloc countries on union travel permits. They visited Cuba and the United States.

"We came to the country and didn't even sit in the hotel. We walked and drove around to see everything," Marina Ermolaeva marvels. "She walked along Broadway in New York, where there are all those huge music halls!"

Evgeniya's happiness ended on August 31, 1997, exactly on Miner's Day. Returning with friends from the seaside, her son Sergei, a financier and master of sports in swimming, was killed in an accident. The driver fell asleep at the wheel, and of the four passengers, only Maiboroda died. He was 26 years old and had no children.

"She used to say, 'I hate Miner's Day.' The whole town celebrates, and she's at the cemetery," Marina recalls.

Evgeniya Maiboroda and her family

Her son's death plunged Evgeniya into severe depression. She threw herself under cars several times and burned her hands with cigarette butts. She was sent to a psychiatric hospital for treatment.

"The crisis was protracted. I can't imagine how she recovered," says a relative.

According to Marina, everything in the apartment reminded her parents of their son. So they tried to "escape." They bought a plot of land, built a summer house, and lived at the dacha for months at a time. They grew vegetables and grapes.

But Evgenia found her main support elsewhere.

"I think someone put [spiritual] literature in her hands. People don't just come to God out of nowhere," Marina says.

After her hospital stay, Evgenia began attending the local Orthodox church. Her relatives believe that conversations with the priest helped her. In 2011, Nikolai Maiboroda died of a serious illness. He was not yet 63.

Having become a widow, Evgenia became completely immersed in church life.

“Maybe she needed a psychologist?”

There are dozens of icons in Evgenia's apartment. Some of them stand on a lacquered table. Beneath it is a small chair with a cushion. Leaning on it, Evgenia would kneel to pray.

"She knows so many prayers! How does she fit them all in?" Marina Ermolaeva marvels. "She'd get up before dawn and recite them for two hours. I'd be amazed: 'Your poor knees, how can you stand it?' And she'd say: 'I know my family feels better when I pray.'"

In Evgeniya Maiboroda's apartment

There are even more icons in the sideboard. An icon sits on the nightstand next to the bed, along with a blood pressure monitor and a mug of water. On the refrigerator is a magnetic cross: "I am the light, but you do not see me..."

Marina lives in a village, fifty kilometers from Shakhty. But she and her family attended church services at Evgenia's church—it was she who "introduced" her. They became close after Maiboroda's husband died. Before that, the relatives "lived their own lives" and rarely communicated.

Evgenia called Marina herself.

"She cried: 'I'm all alone now! I want us to meet, to become family.' We came to visit, and she's been with us ever since.

Marina says Evgenia devoted all her free time to the church. When she went there, she dressed up as if for a holiday. She participated in services, helped with cleaning, and baked prosphora. She also went on pilgrimages.

"She traveled a lot to holy places, visited the Diveyevo Monastery and the Trinity Lavra of St. Sergius. I said, 'Why? It's essentially the same thing.' And she said, 'I never cease to be amazed by this beauty!' And while she was traveling, everyone would go to lunch after church, and she would pray. After breakfast, she would pray again: 'Then I'll have something to eat—and that's enough for me.'"

Evgenia often helped in the temple

In 2021, the pensioner fell seriously ill with COVID-19. Since then, she has had difficulty walking—her legs are paralyzed—and has even stopped going to church.

From Evgenia's house to the Church of St. Panteleimon, it's a mile and a half of broken asphalt. It stands in the center of Maiskoye. Across the street, two hundred meters away, is a monument to Lenin and the Chikh Community Center. A leaflet on the church's fence reads: "Every day, from morning until evening, they weave camouflage nets in this community center." Another notice from a "volunteer landing force" asks for help collecting humanitarian aid for mobilized soldiers, a hospital, and an orphanage in Donetsk.

There are few people at the Saturday service.

A dozen people bow their heads at the altar.

“Let us pray for our God-protected country, its authorities and army, and its people,” the priest chants.

The parishioners had not heard from Maiboroda for a long time.

"She hasn't been here in years. We forgot about her," the old woman at the checkout counter dismisses. She'd heard from friends that Evgenia had spoken negatively about the government. "She's got a nasty mouth. She got what she deserved."

Another pensioner, Anna Stepanovna (Name changed – Ed. "NotMoscow Speaking") remembers Evgenia as a "conscientious parishioner": "She strived to do more. Some are lazy, but she had a spirit of helping. We were glad she was like that."

But upon hearing about the criminal case, she unexpectedly confessed: the church believed Evgenia was "mentally unstable." For this reason, she was allegedly even suspended from baking prosphora—Maiboroda was eager to establish "her own order" in the kitchen. The parishioner believes Evgenia "spoke out" online due to her temper.

“She’s emotional... The church is the church, but maybe she needed a psychologist?”

Regarding the "special operation," the woman says she heard "different opinions." But she doesn't share the critical ones.

"So what if someone somewhere is against it? But we, on the contrary, are helping! My daughter bakes [sweets], and my parishioners and I are collecting [food and supplies]. The soldiers need warmth too. They're weaving nets, they're making mittens—that's what keeps them warm. It's not like they weren't supplied enough, weren't clothed, weren't given shoes..."

"It's not about help. Evgenia didn't like that the SVO even started."

Anna Stepanovna is perplexed for a second.

"What, Putin?" She lets out a laugh. "And who are we anyway? We have a government. We're nobody, you know?"

The pensioner cites the Great Patriotic War as an example, after which, in her opinion, "the people woke up." She hopes the "special operation" will have the same effect.

"And now [the people] are still asleep. Our souls have calmed down. Who wants war? No one. But it was inevitable—maybe she didn't understand?"

Maiboroda went to this temple for many years.

As we speak, parishioners bring bags of provisions to the church for the needs of the SVO. The service is over, and people leave, crossing themselves.

The church's rector, Father Sergei, remembers Evgenia and knows about her sentence. But he declines to comment in detail: "I have no desire to discuss this matter."

The priest hopes that what happened will bring Mayboroda to his senses.

"When she's sent [to the penal colony], we'll contact the priest there and work with the Federal Penitentiary Service to see how we can help her. And we'll pray that God will support her," the priest says.

"Hold on, my dear, Russia is behind you."

Two more of Evgenia's acquaintances mention her emotionality. But they insist that Maiboroda is a decent person, and her short temper only emerged after the death of her loved ones.

The pensioner's lawyer, Ivan Bondarenko, agrees with this.

"She seems broken. Some people feel sad after a tragedy and move on. But for her, life is, in a sense, over. It's a shame: everything seemed fine, and now you're living alone. That's why she can sometimes say something harsh. But it's not out of malice."

Despite the difficulties, Maiboroda helped those around her. Marina remembers Evgenia nursing an acquaintance from the mine who was ill, used crutches, and lived in his own apartment, "like a homeless person." She cleared out the trash, shaved the man, and rewallpapered the apartment with him. Then his son forbade them from communicating, thinking Evgenia was laying claim to the apartment, the relative believes: "She just wanted to fill the void."

A school near Maiboroda's house

Soon Evgenia's friend died.

In the second half of the 2010s, Maiboroda became fascinated with social media. First, she bought a smartphone instead of a push-button handset. At the store, they taught her how to use messaging apps—Evgenia used WhatsApp to send postcards, videos from her trips, and photos of her cat, Aza, whom she'd found on the street. Then, some friends helped her register on VKontakte. Maiboroda was delighted: "There's so much interesting stuff there!"

One of her pages has over 1200 friends. On social media, she corresponded with distant relatives, church friends, and even strangers.

Marina recalls how Maiboroda marveled at her interactions with some opera actress: "An extraordinary person, so profound!" I said, "You don't know her personally. Maybe she's just pulling your leg!" But she had great faith in people.

Evgenia's pages are filled with thousands of postcards and memes. Sometimes she'd invite her neighbor, Tamara Mikhailovna, over to laugh at them. But she prefers crosswords and embroidery.

"She showed me some funny stuff, some jokes—I laughed and forgot about it; I didn't need it. But she found it interesting."

NeMoskva found at least five of Evgenia's VKontakte pages. Whenever the pensioner lost access to her account, they helped her create a new one. The earliest was created in July 2017. "You can't forget someone, but you can learn to live without them," says on the very first "save" in it.

Albums from those years include shots of churches, quotes about faith, and memes about relationships. There's also some "political" content—one photo, for example, depicts Vladimir Putin in military uniform. signed"Hold on, my dear. Russia is behind you."

There are dozens of patriotic posters on the page.

In 2020, everything changes – now Evgenia posts memes against amendments in the Constitution, "Victory Madness» on May 9 and Russian povertyAnd he quotes Leonid Filatov: "There is no more terrible misfortune in the world than an idiot who has seized power."

After the "special operation" began, anti-war and pro-Ukrainian posts were added to these images. When Evgenia mentioned them to her family, they warned her to drop it.

"My husband told her, 'You can't play with this. This is the state, this system—you can't break it, it will break you,'" recalls Marina Ermolaeva.

But Evgenia just waved it off.

And in vain: already in September 2022, she published two videos that attracted the attention of security forces.

How do law enforcement agencies search for such publications? Evgeny Smirnov, a lawyer for the First Department, answers:

Law enforcement agencies have entire programs designed to search online for specific words and expressions. They actively use VKontakte, for example: violations discovered there are easier to prove, as the social network provides law enforcement with a variety of information. And once information is found, there are several ways to "implement" it. For example, in the form of a report from an operative who uncovered a crime while "monitoring the internet." This can also be done by others—both known and semi-anonymous informers file complaints. And there's a third category of cases, where ordinary people search for something online themselves and report it to the police.

"I was walking to the mall and it hit me."

During the search, Evgenia argued with the police officer.

He was indignant: why repost a video with Nazi symbols that talks about killing Russians? Maiboroda snapped back: Russia started it, she said, and the sooner it gets its comeuppance, the sooner the "special operation" will end.

For this video, Evgenia was accused of inciting extremism. It's only twenty seconds long. In it, a girl of about four, waving a knife, barely pronounces the words she's clearly memorized: "Sieg Heil! I'll cut the Russians! Putin, we're coming for you." Behind her is a monitor with a Nazi cross as the background image.

As the title suggests, the video features "an ordinary Ukrainian child," and it's unclear whether this is ironic or not. The video was uploaded to VKontakte seven years ago.

The "fake news" case is based on a seven-minute report about Mariupol that Maiboroda posted on her wall. It claims that 87 civilians were killed during the Russian offensive in the city. "It's impossible to watch this without screaming and crying!!! Horrible! This idiot must answer for all his crimes," Evgenia commented on the report.

This reaction is understandable, says lawyer Ivan Bondarenko.

According to him, the "special operation" became a "tragedy" for Maiboroda. She read the news constantly, distressed by reports of civilian deaths. Before the death of her son, Yevgeny, she had visited Ukraine with her husband many times and treasured it. Her cousins, Lyubov and Nikolai Merenkov, lived there. Maiboroda spent more time with the man; they grew up together. Nikolai spent half his life in Shakhty, working as a car mechanic. In the late 90s, he met his future wife and moved to Dnipro to join her.

In the summer of 2022, Nikolai, according to Maiboroda, was hit by a missile strike while out for a walk.

"She said he was going to the mall when he collapsed," Ivan Bondarenko recalls. "They took her wounded brother to the ambulance, and apparently, by mistake, they called Evgenia. The doctor described to her what had happened, Nikolai's condition. And that was the end of her. She hadn't been supportive of the 'special operation' anyway, and then..."

Neighbor Tamara Mikhailovna remembers how Maiboroda, in tears, told her about her brother.

— She said: “When I imagine him being found under the rubble, mutilated… [It drives me crazy].” This is what provoked her to write something on the Internet.

NeMoskva was unable to provide documentary confirmation of Evgenia’s story.

On July 16, 2022, shortly before she posted the "banned" videos, the Russian Ministry of Defense reported a strike on the Yuzhmash plant in Dnipro the previous day. "Precision weapons... destroyed the Tochka-U ballistic missile component production and repair shops," Reported department.

Ukrainian media claimed that three civilians were killed and fifteen wounded after a rocket attack in Dnipro on July 15.

The house where Nikolai lived is located five kilometers on foot from Yuzhmash.

NeMoskva has learned that the man is alive. Nikolai Merenkov refused to discuss his sister's story and demanded that he not be disturbed any further. "Is it not clear that nothing can be changed? That the sentence in Russia is forever?" he relayed through acquaintances.

Bondarenko's lawyer is confident that Evgenia's publications about the "SVO" are "a purely emotional story."

"They charged her with 'political hatred,' but where's the hatred in that? There has to be some pattern! Maiboroda had no trouble with the law and didn't attend protests. The investigators felt sorry for her, understanding that the old woman was in trouble. But they did their job and screwed her over as much as they could."

A courtyard in the village of Maysky

The persecution of the pensioner began in December 2022 - first her fined 40 rubles for "discrediting" the Russian army (Part 1, Article 20.3.3 of the Code of Administrative Offenses of the Russian Federation). The charges stemmed from critical memes on VKontakte.

Evgenia didn’t believe in the seriousness of what was happening: in one of the correspondences (It's in the case file – Ed. "NotMoscow Speaking") She boasted to her interlocutor that she "laughed and mocked" the security forces' questions. "Everything will be resolved by the New Year," the pensioner hoped.

She was wrong.

On February 13, 2023, a criminal case was opened against Maiboroda for allegedly spreading fake news. She was not arrested; Evgenia waited at home, wearing an electronic ankle monitor, until the investigation and subsequent trial were completed.

In March, she received two new administrative fines. One for propaganda Nazi symbols (Article 20.3, Part 1 of the Code of Administrative Offenses of the Russian Federation, the basis, most likely, was the same video with the “ordinary Ukrainian girl”). The second, a week later, Spread extremist materials (Article 20.29 of the Code of Administrative Offenses): investigators found on Evgenia's page an image with a chevron of the Azov Battalion, which is banned in Russia.

And only after that did the "extremist" case appear. At the end April Rosfinmonitoring added Maiboroda to its list of terrorists and extremists.

For both administrative sentences, Evgenia served first three and then four days in a special detention center. After one of those sentences, Marina and her husband picked her up from her cell.

"They brought her out to us, holding her by the arms; she couldn't really speak," the relative recalls. "The whole time she was in the detention center, they played heavy metal there, from morning until night. We came home, and she went straight to bed."

"I'll be back and surfing the internet again."

According to friends, Evgenia has seriously deteriorated since the criminal case was opened.

"She started walking like this," says neighbor Oksana, hunching her back and squeezing her shoulders. "A sense of doom has set in. She used to be an energetic woman, holding her own. And now she's become a grandmother."

Maiboroda didn't share any details with her neighbors. When asked how she was doing, she complained about her health. Or she'd joke, nodding at her bracelet: "Look how they keep an eye on that old woman."

In fact, Evgenia was embarrassed by the bracelet, neighbors say. When she went outside, she hid it under a long dress or socks.

The pensioner's relatives did not pry into her "soul" with questions.

After being added to the Rosfinmonitoring list, Maiboroda's bank account was blocked – this is a standard procedure for those involved in "extremist" articles. Wrote "BBC Russian Service." For her, collecting her pension has become a quest: filling out paperwork at the bank and waiting hours for approval, Evgenia complained to her neighbor, Tamara Mikhailovna.

On the way to the Church of St. Panteleimon

Maiboroda's trial began in the fall of 2023. According to her lawyer, the pensioner spoke little in court, becoming nervous and out of breath. She admitted posting the video but denied "political hatred."

Evgenia didn't fully believe she'd get a prison sentence. Looking at Judge Poltavtsev at the hearing, she confided to her lawyer, "I think he's a good man. He won't send me to prison."

At night, Evgenia prayed for everything to end well, says Marina.

Shortly before the verdict, Maiboroda suddenly went missing – her family couldn't reach her by phone for several days. It turned out the pensioner had been bleeding from her nose all those days. She refused to call an ambulance: "What ambulance? The trial is tomorrow. Let everything be resolved, and then I'll go home."

The next morning, Judge Poltavtsev sentenced her to 5,5 years in prison.

The lawyer took a photo of Maiboroda immediately after the verdict – snapshot The pensioner holds her chest.

After that, her nose started bleeding again.

Marina Ermolaeva considers Evgenia’s sentence a “show execution.”

"They sentenced her to teach others a lesson. Of course, she's to blame; we warned her—she should have just lived and enjoyed every day. But she thought it was just a game—a quick chat [online] and that's it. She didn't understand the consequences."

Marina and I are sitting in Evgenia's house. A relative has come here to "mothball" the apartment and pick up their cat, Aza, who had been homeless and hungry for several days. The apartment is carpeted, but there's no dust anywhere, and things are in their proper places—friends say Maiboroda was a "clean freak."

There's only an unwashed frying pan on the stove. "I was hoping he'd come and clean it up," Marina explains. She's horrified by the verdict: Maiboroda didn't tell her family it was "that serious."

While Marina, tearful, is sorting out the communal apartment in the kitchen, neighbors are crowding in the hallway. They're outraged by her sentence and worried that the pensioner won't last until her release. Everyone is certain that Evgenia doesn't deserve prison.

"We're ready to bail her out! Just let her be placed under house arrest." Neighbor Vera Ivanovna couldn't calm down, peeking into the apartment a second time. She brought the "header" of the complaint to the prosecutor and is coaching Marina on how to file a criminal complaint: "There could be thousands of violations!"

She throws up her hands.

— I am not knowledgeable about the laws. I am a teacher.

The cat Aza hid under her owner's bed and meowed.

Marina calls herself a "non-political person." She didn't discuss Putin or the "special operation" with Evgenia—and she rebuffed any attempts to bring it up.

Marina is afraid of war.

Both her sons are conscripts. While the men are exempt from military service, they work at the factory, "twelve hours at a time at the machine." Marina doesn't think beyond that: "I can't talk about the war at all. I immediately start crying."

At the same time, the woman admits: she doesn't share Evgenia's opinion about the government. Putin is the man who "pays her salary."

"Under Yeltsin, we were starving. [And now] I know that the day will come, and I'll get my pay: my few kopecks, but I'll get them. I'm grateful to Putin for that. I understand that it goes without saying—a person has worked hard and should get paid. But we know other times when things were different."

- But now you're worried about your sons.

- Yes, I'm shaking, it's true.

Halfway through the conversation, Aza finally crawls out from under the bed and strolls around the room. At the door, she sniffs the bag—it contains the things she'd packed for Evgenia at the pretrial detention center.

— Are you afraid to live in such a country?

Marina is silent. She sighs, folding her hands over her face.

"Yes," he admits quietly. "It's scary. You don't know what tomorrow will bring. I've lived through the day, and I'm happy that you and your family are alive and well. I pray that Putin has the health to finish the Second World War. I'm scared, really."

A few days later, the lawyer handed over the things Evgenia had collected. Through him, a NeMoskva correspondent asked Maiboroda what she would do if she were released.

"She replied, 'When I get home, the first thing I'll do is have a good cry. And then I'll go back to surfing the internet. Waiting for this whole nightmare to end,'" says Ivan Bondarenko.