The court denied a re-examination of the Birch Grove in Yekaterinburg.
However, the developer will not be able to cut down trees for now, said Denis Karakoz, one of the initiative group members. "But we're on the brink," he added.
The company plans to transform over 20 hectares of grove into a new residential complex in the Akademichesky District. Yekaterinburg residents are not planning to back down; the next meeting is scheduled for April 23.
Denis Karakoz explained to NeMoskva that the interim measures—the ban on logging—will definitely remain in effect until the next hearing.
"They refused to conduct an expert examination because the judge failed to consider the consequences and new obligations that would arise for the parties after it was conducted," Denis added.
Activist Alla Agarkova, speaking with NeMoskva, noted that there had been a lengthy discussion today about the inconsistencies in the assessments and rare plant species. But the main point: A city administration lawyer confirmed that no construction permits have yet been issued for the grove.
As noted on the activist channel "Berezovaya Roshcha Headquarters," quite a large number of people attended the hearing, including journalists and plaintiffs. The application was filed with the Oktyabrsky District Court of Yekaterinburg on December 6, 2024. filed Thirty-six defenders of the grove and the Eduard Brauer Charitable Foundation. The defendants are Specialized Developer Krasnolesye LLC, Dom.RF JSC, the city administration, the regional government, and the regional Ministry of Natural Resources.
The plaintiffs insist that the grove contains endangered species. Their expert, Pavel Levchenko, confirmed that protected species such as "nest-breeding, large-flowered variegated grass, locust lily, and adonis" grow there. However, Alyona Tretyakova, a doctor of biological sciences at the Ural Botanical Garden of the Russian Academy of Sciences who conducted the research commissioned by the defendants, asserts that there is only one endangered species there. If other species are found, they can be relocated to a safe location.
According to Tretyakova, 12% of the grove's trees are in a state of disrepair, posing a danger to residents. She also noted that the Birch Grove itself "does not deserve the status of a specially protected area."
A city administration representative noted at the meeting that when endangered plants are found, authorities are not obligated to create specially protected natural areas in their habitats, so a new assessment would only delay the case.
The birch grove began to be cut down on February 11. Yekaterinburg residents out When workers approached and attempted to stop the logging, several people were attacked by unknown assailants. After the police arrived, the work stopped. The next day, the court banned Cut down trees. Activists have been writing to the Investigative Committee, the Prosecutor's Office, and other agencies all this time: they believe the developer acquired the land illegally and construction should not have taken place there.
Video: "NotMoscow".