Time to read: 9 minutes(s)

Shy and shameless

How homeopathy and other "alternative medicine" methods are entering mainstream medical practice

Pieter Quast, "The Operation of Extracting the Stone," Circa 1630. The extraction of the Stone of Folly is a common subject among Netherlandish artists of the 15th to 17th centuries.

Imagine you've caught a cold and go to the doctor. The doctor has prescribed you a medication, say, Ergoferon. The package says, "Treatment of viral infections"—and that seems reasonable, since any educated person now knows that seasonal colds are caused by viruses. And those who are especially knowledgeable also know that special proteins called interferons help the human body fight viruses, so the name should appeal to them.

Both of them—the literate one, the exceptionally literate one (and even the completely illiterate one along for the ride)—recover within a week, or at most ten days. And the next time they catch a cold, they themselves run to the pharmacy for the medicine that "helped them so well."

They, poor things, don't know that modern science has long since figured out the truth about Ergoferon, Anaferon, and many other "medicines" that contain no active ingredient. What's effective here are only vague pseudoscientific formulations mixed with clever marketing. 

Disguised as science

"Shy homeopathy"—that's how Alexander Panchin, a well-known popularizer of science and member of the Russian Academy of Sciences Commission on Combating Pseudoscience, calls these "medicines." Shy—because the word "homeopathic" is used to describe the so-called release-active  There are no products produced by Materia Medica. After all, popular science articles and podcasts are doing their job, and the ranks of homeopathy's fans are gradually dwindling. Incidentally, Materia Medica itself received the Ministry of Education and Science's Anti-Award in 2018 for being the "most harmful pseudoscientific project."

Homeopathy — an alternative medical practice that involves using ultra-low doses of substances that, when used in large doses, cause symptoms of a given disease in a healthy person. The concentration of the active substance is gradually reduced, often to the point of its complete absence in the resulting "solution." Adherents of homeopathy explain the action of their preparations by the "memory of water" and other changes in the structure of the diluent.  

In 2017, the Russian Academy of Sciences' Commission on Combating Pseudoscience issued a memorandum "On the Pseudoscience of Homeopathy," which stated, in part: "The principles of homeopathy and theoretical explanations for the mechanisms of its supposed action contradict known chemical, physical, and biological laws, and convincing experimental evidence of its effectiveness is lacking. Homeopathic diagnostic and treatment methods should be classified as pseudoscientific." 

Release activity — a concept developed by Oleg Epshtein, head of Materia Medica Holding, according to which something physically tangible is separated ("released") from the molecules of the original substance. This material is transferred to the solvent and is capable of exhibiting pharmacological activity. 

Release-active drugs:

  • "Anaferon";
  • "Arthrofoon";
  • Afala;
  • "Afalaza";
  • "Brisantine";
  • "Divaza";
  • Impaza;
  • "Kolofort";
  • "Proproten-100";
  • Rengalin;
  • Subetta;
  • Tenoten;
  • "Ergoferon".

"These release-active drugs are actually homeopathy in disguise, disguised as science. They want to achieve a higher level of respectability, and so they hide the fact that their medications simply don't contain any active ingredient," explains Panchin. Take, for example, the popular drug "Anaferon," which contains 10,000 EMU of "affinity-purified antibodies to human gamma interferon." EMU stands for some mysterious "action-modifying units," and, like the term "release activity" itself, it's the know-how of the drug's manufacturer, Materia Medica. How many grams this is "in grams" is known only to the company's management (spoiler: none). In the "Instructions for Use," under "Active ingredient," there's a telling "~" symbol. 

Ergoferon contains exactly the same amount of EMD—10,000. Meanwhile, the meticulous Panchin spotted This "release-active" drug is included in the current 2021 clinical guidelines for the treatment of acute respiratory viral infections. Two more of its homeopathic counterparts were also found in clinical guidelines for the treatment of acute sinusitis and irritable bowel syndrome.

And all would be well, but starting in 2025, clinical guidelines are to become mandatory for doctors, which implies liability for failure to comply. So, this includes failure to prescribe various "ergoferons"?

True, the question is still hanging.

"This isn't established by any law, including Federal Law No. 323 ["On the Fundamentals of Protecting Citizens' Health in the Russian Federation"], but there is a Ministry of Health order that clearly states that clinical guidelines are the document on the basis of which medical activity is assessed. Therefore, the Supreme Court ruled that clinical guidelines are mandatory, but there is no final ruling. And the more letters the Ministry of Health issues, the less clear it becomes. Currently, neither lawyers, nor doctors, nor the medical community—no one at all—can answer the question of the status of these clinical guidelines," says a highly qualified transfusion specialist who requested anonymity.


Live in Non-Moscow? Join us volunteers Media outlet "NeMoscow Speaks." Create a new NeMoscow with journalists. Together, we can do more.


"I recommend it to all my friends and family." 

While doctors are dealing with the Ministry of Health, and the Commission on Pseudoscience is dealing with charlatans, sales of homeopathic remedies of varying degrees of modesty are going quite well. Reviews in online pharmacies are a carbon copy: 

Screenshot: eapteka.ru

Are these bots or gullible citizens who, using their own money, succumbed to the placebo effect? ​​It's impossible to tell the difference on online pharmacy pages. But on VKontakte, using the extension Botanical Surveillance project, we immediately get this nice picture: 

Screenshot: VK group "Moms, Dads, Abakan, Chernogorsk, Khakassia" 

Pink is the color of the bots that visit patient or parent communities, praising the customer's drugs and criticizing competitors' products.

"Here they operate completely freely and without restrictions. Almost all posts in the thematic groups where they hang out are sent anonymously by them," says the Botnadzor administrator. He adds that manufacturers and sellers of "release-active" products are regular customers of bot farms. 

Two competing bots met in the VK group "Mothers of Ulyanovsk" 

Are you using plantain? Come and discuss it.

"A person comes to the doctor with acute respiratory viral infection symptoms, and the doctor concludes it's a viral infection. In most cases, a viral infection has no cure: only purely symptomatic treatment is possible, without prescribing anything specific. And then a very simple situation arises: the doctor, of course, can tell the patient that they don't need to take anything, that it's enough to just stay at home, but the patient can respond by claiming they were refused treatment and filing a complaint with a higher authority. Therefore, many doctors choose this approach: prescribing a safe medication. It won't do any good, but it won't do any harm either, but the patient will feel as if they've been cared for and prescribed something. Colleagues in private clinics usually don't prescribe this because private clinics are increasingly advocating for evidence-based medicine, but in public clinics, in my opinion, this is a very real situation," says Nikita R., a general practitioner. 

— Do the doctors themselves understand that this conditional Anaferon that they prescribe is a dummy?

"Most doctors, especially young ones, probably understand this, but there are also those who believe it works—and they may sincerely prescribe the drug for its effectiveness. I think it depends greatly on where the person studied and trained."

- Here the note about how a three-year-old boy who lost his speech after COVID was allegedly given the ability to speak again with the help of bioresonance therapyThe source cited is the Moscow Region Ministry of Health. What other questionable methods are recommended by the Russian Ministry of Health and regional health authorities?

Physiotherapy is very common in Russian clinics—it's a throwback to Soviet times. This treatment involves magnets, ultrasound frequencies, and, in short, various types of physical interventions. And there's no universal answer as to whether it works or is just nonsense: some of these methods have proven effectiveness, some are being studied but haven't been proven, and some may simply not be studied—we don't know how effective they are. It's important to understand that any research costs money. And who would agree to fund physiotherapy research is unclear, because people with money are interested in studying, say, heart attacks and strokes, not magnetic therapy for sprains. I want to recommend to my patients what's proven to work, not what might have helped someone in the past.

Of course, it's a pleasant pastime: a person comes and sits in a quiet room with dim lighting, the machine hums soothingly, they're not allowed to take their phone with them, no one bothers you—you just sit and relax for 15 minutes. Wonderful. I have nothing against that. But let's just tell patients straight: we're prescribing 15 minutes in a quiet room. 

— How do methods from the field get into the Ministry of Health’s clinical guidelines? alternative medicine?

Clinical guidelines are a highly decentralized system, involving various specialists from different regions. And the system itself isn't designed to distinguish truth from falsehood. There are formal criteria that must be met, and those who work on them know how to fit the data into these criteria. 

— It is widely distributed on the Internet. rocket preparations — "drugs potentially related to the pharmacological group of 'quasi-drugs'." Do you think it can be trusted?

"The most important thing is to remember that there is no absolute truth, so you should be critical of any information. For example, a new study might have been conducted on some of the medications on this list, which showed that they actually work. Or maybe we didn't have a sufficient sample size before, but now we do, and we have a different view on this medication. Please use this list, but never make decisions about your own health based solely on your own research. It's better to discuss this with a doctor you trust—not because they know the whole truth about this world, but because you trust them, they're there for you, can answer your questions, and can help you if the medication is ineffective or if there are any side effects. If that's not enough, get a second opinion. When a patient I recommend a treatment to says, "No, I'll use plantain," I won't tell them, "Well, get out of here with your plantain." I will say this: “If something happens while you are being treated with plantain, come back to me, we will discuss it.”