The Promised Land in the Land of Soviets
On August 20, 1930, the Central Executive Committee of the RSFSR issued a decree “On the formation of the Biro-Bidzhansky National Region as part of the Far Eastern Territory.”
Author: Andrey Filimonov.
Thus began the history of the Jewish Soviet Autonomy. A rather strange story, as was the very idea of creating a "national homeland" in the Far East.
The word "hearth"—as if referring to a home—was constantly used in the late 19th and early 20th centuries when discussing plans for a future Jewish state. Zionists, led by the Austrian journalist Theodor Herzl, insisted that such a state could only emerge in Palestine.
In 1902, Herzl published the German novel "Altneuland" (The Renewed Land), which, when translated into Hebrew, became "Spring Hill," or "Tel Aviv." In this utopian work, Herzl paints a picture of a glorious future for Jewish Palestine. The novel's characters are transported 20 years into the future—to 1922—and see a renewed Jerusalem:
"Here arose a modern city, crisscrossed by electric roads; wide, tree-lined streets, gardens, boulevards, parks, educational institutions, shopping arcades, and magnificent public and theatrical buildings... It was a world city, in keeping with the latest in twentieth-century culture."

During the author's lifetime (he died in 1904), Palestine belonged to the Ottoman Empire. Therefore, the book's heroes lease the land on which the "renewed city" stands from the Sultan. It was difficult at the beginning of the 20th century to foresee a world war, the collapse of great and cultural empires, the rise of barbarians, concentration camps, and other abominations.
But what does Birobidzhan have to do with this?
Even during Theodor Herzl's lifetime, so-called "territorialists" emerged from Zionism. They believed that a national homeland for the Jewish people could emerge anywhere on the planet where free territory could be found. The first alternative to Palestine was Uganda, a British protectorate in Africa. Kenya, Australia, Crimea, and the Far East were also considered.
One of the active "territorialists" was Isaak Steinberg, a Left Socialist Revolutionary, member of the party's Central Committee, deputy of the Constituent Assembly, and the first People's Commissar of Justice of the RSFSR. However, he didn't hold his post for long—he fell out with Dzerzhinsky, rejected the Brest Peace Treaty, and then left Russia altogether in 1923, being stripped of his Soviet citizenship. He lived first in Germany, then, after the Nazis came to power, moved to London, then to Australia, where he attempted to establish a "national home."
Jewish ghetto in the Far East
Steinberg left, but the ideas of territorialism took root in the USSR. One of its supporters was Mikhail Kalinin, chairman of the All-Union Central Executive Committee (VTsIK)—formally the head of state. In the West, he was called the "Soviet president," and in Soviet Russia, the "All-Union elder." In reality, Kalinin's power was merely cosmetic, but he wielded some authority and vigorously lobbied for the Jewish Autonomous Oblast project in the Far East.
Polish journalist Israel Emiot moved to the USSR, seduced by the idea of a "national homeland" on Soviet soil. After World War II, Emiot was repressed in the so-called "Birobidzhan Affair." But in the 1920s, this was still a long way off. The younger generation was full of enthusiasm and saw themselves as builders of a new world. In his memoirs, Emiot recounts Kalinin's speech at the founding conference of the Society for the Land Settlement of Jewish Workers (OZET) in 1926.

"The Chairman of the All-Russian Central Executive Committee openly spoke about Birobidzhan's need to become a Jewish republic. Only by living compactly could Jews develop their statehood and preserve their national culture. I seized on this idea and agreed with it, even though Ilya Ehrenburg, even then, at the plenum, was fuming: 'You want to create a new ghetto!'" I. Emiot. "The Birobidzhan Affair"
In the mid-1920s, even Stalin had to accept the existence of debates within the party, different points of view, and alternatives. Two Jewish territorial projects were developing in parallel in the Soviet Union: the Far Eastern and the Crimean. Both were financed by international organizations such as the Joint and ORT.
Jewish farmers
ORT is not “Public Russian Television,” but “The Society for Craft and Agricultural Labor Among Jews,” created at the end of the reign of Alexander II and bearing his name.
ORT's budget was replenished through crowdfunding. In its first year, 12 Russian citizens donated 204 rubles (approximately 500 million in today's money) to support education and awareness-raising, as well as the resettlement of Jewish artisans from the Pale of Settlement to Russia's interior provinces.
At first, things were going well, but just a year later, the Narodnaya Volya (People's Will) assassinated the Tsar-Liberator. His son and heir developed a hatred for liberal ideas. Liberalism was already being linked to the Freemasons and the global conspiracy, and the Jews were "to blame" for everything. A couple of decades remained before the fabrication of the "Protocols of the Elders of Zion." But the Black Hundreds movement had already emerged and was gaining momentum. During the reign of Alexander III, pogroms against Jews began, dramatically changing the routes of Jewish migration—not into Russia, but beyond its borders.

Nevertheless, ORT continued to operate. From 1906, it was headed by Leonty Bramson, a lawyer and First Duma deputy. After the revolution, he too emigrated and created World ORT, which still exists today.

Meanwhile, the Russian ORT channel's management was filled with people loyal to the Soviet regime, who succeeded in attracting funds from international foundations. As a result, Russia's oldest Jewish organization found itself in a unique position: on the one hand, it was an official partner of the Kremlin, and on the other, a conduit for foreign currency entering the USSR.
Between 1923 and 1925, lathes, sewing machines, and plows were imported with ORT's assistance. In the second half of the 1920s, approximately 5 million rubles (in foreign currency equivalent) arrived from abroad "through Jewish channels." These funds were used to establish workshops, cooperatives, and schools, and to support agricultural colonies in Crimea and southern Ukraine.
ORT served as a kind of transnational startup incubator for Soviet Jewry: it found resources, taught crafts, helped people acquire tools and even a plot of land.
Jewish agricultural organizations in Crimea and southern Ukraine received a wealth of agricultural machinery and breeding livestock, which allowed them to quickly become wealthy. Poor peasants from the towns of the former Pale of Settlement, hearing of the new "promised land," flocked to these uninhabited areas with their less-than-favorable, or rather, sharply continental, climate and, in just a few years, transformed these places. It seemed that everything was heading toward Northern Crimea becoming an administrative unit of Jewish origin.

But the leader of the Crimean Tatars, Veli Ibraimov, head of the Republic of Crimea, opposed the establishment of a Jewish autonomous region in the north of the peninsula. For some unknown reason, Stalin heeded Ibraimov's opinion (he was executed on false charges in 1928 and rehabilitated in 1990) and favored the project of Academician Vasily Williams, who had already advocated the colonization of the Amur region at the beginning of the 20th century. In the summer of 1927, an expedition consisting of agricultural scientists, as well as representatives of OZET and KOMZET, visited the Birsko-Bidzhansky district. The commission's conclusions were optimistic—the site was ideal for the creation of a new economic colony. At that time, the word "village" did not yet have negative connotations.
Seekers of happiness
The creation of the Jewish Autonomous Oblast was officially announced on May 7, 1934. By then, the first Jewish settlement on the Amur River, Birofeld, had already emerged. Jewish activists from Europe and America were arriving in this Far Eastern proto-Israel. Western journalists wrote about "vitamin BB" (from the word Birobidzhan), which was reviving hopes for Jewish statehood, albeit in a truncated form.
In the Jewish Autonomous Region, collective farms with Yiddish names appeared: "Valdgeym," "Reuter Oktyabr," and so on. A city grew up around the Tikhonkaya station, the name of which was derived from the confluence of the Bira and Bidzhan rivers.

In 1936, the film "The Seekers of Happiness" was released in the Soviet Union. It was essentially a commissioned production and propaganda piece, but it had a high-quality script and lively dialogue:
"Fima, I'm wondering what kind of work I can get you for?" "And you're wrong about that. You and Rosa will be the ones working." "And you?" "I have a head. And don't worry about me..."
Or this:
"Is Birobidzhan bad? Why?" "I like these Jewish questions. 'Why'?! Because I don't want to uproot the taiga, feed my blood to mosquitoes, and wait to be torn apart by a tiger."

Thanks to the vibrant performance of Veniamin Zuskin (Pinya) and Maria Blumenthal-Tamarina (Dvoira), as well as Isakovsky's music, the film was a success. "People Haval" is an absurd socialist realist story: American Jew Pinya, dreaming of getting rich, suddenly sees the light in Birobidzhan, realizing that happiness lies not in money, but in Soviet power and Stalin's friendship among peoples.
Just a couple of months after the film's premiere, the "first president of the Jewish state," Iosif Lieberberg, head of the Jewish Autonomous Region, was arrested at the Metropol Hotel by NKVD agents and accused of participating in a Trotskyist conspiracy. A couple of months later, he began to give "confessions."
Iosif Lieberberg, a corresponding member of the Ukrainian Academy of Sciences and director of the Kyiv Institute of Jewish Proletarian Culture, "confessed" that his entire work was merely a cover for anti-Soviet activities, personally directed from abroad by Trotsky. The Jewish Autonomous Region's Soviet party organs decisively distanced themselves from the "Trotskyist Lieberberg"—the founder of these organs and this autonomous region—and decreed his expulsion from the party. In March 1937, he was executed in Moscow. Thousands of "Trotskyists" from Birobidzhan were arrested and repressed in the "Lieberberg affair."
Although it was under him that the Jewish Autonomous Region became a true Jewish Oblast, home to 17,000 Jews (23% of the population). Since then, the share of the Jewish population has declined: 1959 - 14,269 (8,8%), 1979 - 10,163 (6,6%), 1989 - 8887 (5,4%), 2002 - 2327 (1,2%), 2010 - 1628 (10%).

At its core, the Jewish Autonomous Region was an international project. How could it be otherwise, considering the people, whose members, without a state of their own, lived in virtually every country in the world? During the Great Terror, this fact became a real gift for the NKVD. Because in Birobidzhan, cases of espionage and foreign connections could be opened without any difficulty. Moreover, these cases (a rarity) were based on actual collaboration with international organizations, thanks to whose help Birobidzhan had come into being. The deeper Stalin's paranoia, the more terrifying the word "foreign" sounded.
And after the Second World War, when the “bacillus of anti-Semitism” (in Khrushchev’s words) penetrated Stalin’s brain, the accusation of “Zionism” automatically led to the highest penalty.
Jewish Switzerland in the Far East
The Soviet government's attitude toward the "Jewish question" was fickle. In the late 1930s, people were executed for what had been actively encouraged in the early 1930s.
To create Birobidzhan as an international dream, the Soviet government attracted foreign investment and invited specialists from abroad.
The master plan for the capital of the Jewish Autonomous Region was created by the director of the Bauhaus, the world-renowned architect Hannes Meyer from Switzerland, who inscribed the future streets of the Jewish capital into the relief of the Lesser Khingan hills, which (according to Meyer himself) are not inferior to the beauty of the Alpine foothills.

In 1933, Mayer personally visited Birobidzhan to survey the area. By then, the first settlers had already built houses to their own tastes, in keeping with the traditions of the villages from which they had come. The Swiss expert was categorically displeased with this folk art:
"The diverse range of buildings, combined with their varied construction methods, creates the impression of a haphazardly arranged exhibition of the homes of various peoples of the world: a block house of a Latvian or Belarusian Jew, a whitewashed adobe hut of a Ukrainian Jew, or a two-story brick structure of a Jew from the German 'Reich.' The wooden structures, in particular, showcased all types of construction—from the 'natural economy' of Korean houses, woven from branches and twigs, coated with clay and whitewashed, to the standard panel houses of the Central Housing Union."
Mayer and his assistants spent several months in Birobidzhan and created a design for a "Jewish socialist city" that could have become a Bauhaus masterpiece in the Far East. But it didn't. In August 1934, Mayer's project was rejected without explanation. Already in the 21st century, the writer Iosif Brenner, while working on his book "The Country of Birobidzhan," discovered a note from the People's Commissariat of Health of the RSFSR in the archives, marked "not subject to disclosure." It stated:
"Part of the territory designated for the first stage of construction was withdrawn from the city's jurisdiction by the People's Commissariat of Defense without the approval of GIPROGOR, and by now it has already been developed primarily for the construction of a military town."
An old Soviet song goes, "On the high banks of the Amur stand sentries of the homeland." In the borderlands, the military reigned supreme and did whatever they pleased. Second in power was the NKVD, which, since 1936, had taken control of Jewish (and indeed all) immigration to the USSR. Vigilant comrades in caps with blue bands meticulously checked the forms of those wishing to resettle in Birobidzhan and turned away anyone suspected of "anti-Soviet sentiments." Understandably, under such conditions, the number of applicants dwindled.
And yet, according to contemporaries, "the Jews in Birobidzhan felt 'at home.'" Israel Emiot, in his book "The Birobidzhan Affair," writes that, against the backdrop of the anti-Semitism that flourished in the western USSR, Birobidzhan was, if not a promised land, then at least an oasis of calm:
"...I remember the scene when a citizen who had just arrived from Ukraine shouted in the middle of the street in a drunken stupor: 'Beat the Jews!' Former front-line soldiers came running from all sides, from every nook and cranny, and, right there on the street, they stripped the drunkard of his clothes and beat him so hard that he, half-naked, raised his hands and screamed: 'I love, I love the Jews!' It sounds like a joke, but it's a fact; I saw it with my own eyes." I. Emiot. "The Birobidzhan Affair (Chronicle of a Terrible Time)"
Jewish front-line soldiers could easily bring a drunken, foolish anti-Semite to his senses with their fists. However, no one could find a way to deal with the country's leading anti-Semite, who sat in the Kremlin. Stalin "celebrated" the New Year of 1948 by ordering the liquidation of Solomon Mikhoels, chairman of the Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee. According to one theory, the reason for the massacre was Mikhoels' overly vocal position on the issue of a Jewish republic in Crimea. In any case, Stalin had the Jews and plans for how to deal with them on his mind. He planned to create a completely different kind of Jewish "socialist city" in the coastal taiga—one surrounded by barbed wire...
The mistakes of Comrade Bakhmutsky
In 1948, a commission from Moscow arrived in Birobidzhan with the task of finding incriminating evidence against Birobidzhan "nationalists" who "artificially introduced Jewish classes into Russian schools in Birobidzhan."
They decided to blame Alexander Bakhmutsky, the first secretary of the regional committee of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks) for the Jewish Autonomous Region.
"Comrade Bakhmutsky, in his printed and oral speeches, made political errors, asserting that the Jewish region was being built and would be built only by Jewish hands, and promoting fanciful plans to transform the region into a union republic, about the need to distribute the region's printed publications among all Jews in the Soviet Union, thereby distracting the party organization from addressing pressing political and economic issues."
"Comrades Bakhmutsky and Levitin not only failed to correctly assess the regional organizations' long-standing ties with the American-Birobidzhan Committee in the United States, but also accepted handouts from this committee... they also failed to correctly assess the numerous private ties between citizens of the Jewish Autonomous Region and America as a channel for the penetration of enemy propaganda and the fact that citizens were receiving material parcels as a phenomenon that demeans the dignity of Soviet citizens," stated the Politburo of the Central Committee of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks) decision to change the leadership of the Jewish Autonomous Region.
Comrade Bakhmutsky turned out to be "guilty" of exactly the same thing for which he had recently been praised and awarded. However, such was the fate of every official in Stalin's regime. There were no innocents.
The editorial staff of the Birobidzhan Shtern newspaper (including Yisroel Emiot) and several Yiddish poets were arrested in the "Birobidzhan Affair." All received lengthy prison sentences, ranging from 10 to 25 years, but were released and rehabilitated after Stalin's death.
Following the crackdown on the "cosmopolitans," the Jewish Autonomous Region, in an act of anti-Semitism, was led by a non-Jew, P.V. Simonov, who was tasked with cleansing the region of "nationalists." Comrade Simonov and the other comrades who succeeded him accomplished their task admirably. Within a couple of decades, there were no more "nationalists" or even Jews left in the Jewish Autonomous Region.

Already in the 21st century, invited image makers from Moscow decided it would be cool and attractive to tourists to write street names in "Hebrew letters." Even if no one but tourists from Israel would be able to read them. However, such cases are extremely rare in Birobidzhan's recent history.
Yiddish remains the "declarative language" of the Jewish Autonomous Oblast. Declarative, but not the official language. This subtle distinction would have been appreciated by medieval Talmudists. The fact is that, according to Russian law, the official language of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation can only be one written in Cyrillic. Yiddish, as luck would have it, uses the Hebrew square script, which, incidentally, is much older than the Russian Federation. Thus, in practice, Yiddish is not used by state authorities—neither in court nor in official documents of the Jewish Autonomous Oblast. Only a handful of representatives of the "titular nation" speak both the language and the script. Jews themselves have long since become a national minority in the autonomous region.
From the "Birobidzhan Affair" to the "Birobidzhan Diary"
In Birobidzhan, Sholem Aleichem Street (who never visited) intersects with Kazakevich Street. It's unclear which of them is meant—the elder, Genakh Kazakevich (one of the first editors of "Birobidzhaner Shtern"), or the younger, Emmanuel, a wartime writer and author of the famous war stories "Star" and "Two in the Steppe." It's likely Genakh, who was Birobidzhan's true Yiddish guru until he was dethroned along with Lieberberg.

Emmanuil Kazakevich, although he published a collection of poems, "Birebidzhanboy" ("Birobidzhanstroy"), in 1932, was more involved in agriculture than poetry. He worked for five years as director of the Valdgeim collective farm, and then left for Moscow.
Nevertheless, in Birobidzhan he is considered “their” writer.
Emmanuil Kazakevich's "The Star," a Stalin Prize-winning novella about intelligence officers, was part of the Soviet school curriculum. The opening line was familiar to millions of schoolchildren: "The division, advancing, penetrated the endless forests, and they swallowed it up." Ninety years later, musician and conceptual writer Pavel Kushnir responded to Kazakevich from Birobidzhan:
"The division, advancing, plunged into the endless forests, and they swallowed it up. And fuck it! Damn it, damn it, damn it, damn it! Swallow all the divisions, all the armies, all the corps, forests. May all the scum in uniform disappear into the forests forever!"
Kushnir lived in Birobidzhan for less time than Kazakevich, about a year and a half. But he managed to paint a rather sympathetic collective portrait of Birobidzhan's residents.
"People are similar to the Vietnamese in mentality. Kindness has not yet completely perished here, not as a personal strength, but as a tradition, a national soul, and at the same time with an Asian tinge. Add to this Russian purity and Jewish walking under the close eye of God, as well as my own cowardice and foolishness, and you will understand that life here is magical." Pavel Kushnir. "Birobidzhan Diary."

It's possible that one day a Pavel Kushnir Street will appear on the map of Birobidzhan. He earned this distinction through his work and his death in the Birobidzhan pretrial detention center on Karl Marx Street. Thanks to Kushnir's notes, we can vividly imagine the current image of this city and feel the fear in which people lived here during the years of Russia's full-scale aggression against Ukraine.
In such times, the chronicler also needs courage:
“Prayer readings in memory of the victims of Soviet repressions. Somewhere, they say, they take place with the cops, with arrests, like a real protest (in the absence of fish...), but in Birobidzhan there were six people, including me; five were girls; a priest in front of a small pulpit with a microphone; behind them were three candles on the ground, an icon - the face of Christ; a white cloth; a little further away - two speakers; the setting sun; space. He reads, not exactly in a singsong voice, but sometimes he strays from the secular and switches to the priestly; he asked for mercy for those who informed on, slandered, mercy for those who tortured and for those who shot, have mercy on the executioners and after that it was possible to go up to the microphone to say something on your own and one girl in a headscarf and glasses came up and after every two words she made a long pause, I think for self-censorship, that’s why the cops are not needed; “People have been driven out of the country, and those who remain in Russia have been driven out of the desire to burn their hearts with the word…”
A year ago, the same number of people attended the farewell ceremony for Pavel Kushnir in Birobidzhan as attended the readings he described in memory of the victims of Soviet repression. It's likely that in both cases, these were the same people—the righteous ones without whom the city would not exist.