Time to read: 12 minutes(s)

"Siberia is no more, from now on this is Russia"

How Siberian Tatars are punished for their dislike of Yermak

Author: Andrey Filimonov.

Vasily Ivanovich Surikov, "The Conquest of Siberia by Yermak"

On November 8 (October 26, old style), 1582, the Stroganov PMC, led by field commander Yermak, stormed Isker, the headquarters of Kuchum, the last Siberian khan. 300 years later, during the reign of Alexander III, this date became celebrated as Siberia Day. At that time, the term "colony" didn't have a pronounced negative connotation. Therefore, every year, on October 26, Petersburg, Moscow, Tomsk и Irkutsk The intelligentsia held meetings and banquets with speeches and reports on how to organize the largest colony of the Russian Empire to equalize the rights of Siberians and Russians. The process was underway, but extremely slowly. Tomsk University and the Tomsk Technological Institute remained the only imperial universities beyond the Urals. The empire itself collapsed before it could grant the residents of Siberia zemstvo self-government, the need for which regionalists led by Grigory Potanin had been arguing for forty years.

Eventually, Siberians stopped talking and started acting. When that empire collapsed during the Civil War, Siberia separated from the mother country for several years. However, the Red Army soon reconquered it. In Soviet Russia, Siberia Day was not celebrated, and the idea of ​​Siberian autonomy was largely forgotten. The word "colony" no longer had such a harmless ring in the 20th century.

Britain set a bad example by letting its English-speaking possessions—Australia, Canada, South Africa, and India—go free. Stalin categorically forbade even thinking of Siberia as a colony. Siberian peoples were ordered to be considered to have voluntarily joined Russia as soon as they saw the pioneering bands of peace-loving Cossacks on the horizon. The term "conquest of Siberia" was frequently replaced by the misleading notion of "annexation." Rulers like Khan Kuchum, who resisted Yermak, were declared villains because they stood in the way of the inevitable historical process of their lands' incorporation into the Russian state. And this process was considered unquestionably progressive.

Russian voivodes, landowners, merchants, and clergy levied taxes on the local residents and robbed them. Local feudal lords served the Russians. But the annexation of lands had a progressive effect. There was constant warfare between the khanates, and peoples oppressed each other. The Russian state was more developed than the khanates... Incorporation into Russia was of great significance for the peoples of Siberia. Intertribal wars and raids (for example, by the southern Manchu feudal lords) gradually ceased. The Russians brought rye, wheat, other crops, and a three-field system; crafts and trade developed; riches (forests, iron, salt, gold) were exploited. Northern and eastern peoples, who did not know iron, acquired iron tools. Among the Yakuts and Buryats, tribal relations disintegrated, and feudalism arose.

M. V. Nechkina, P. S. Lebedev (and a group of authors). History of the USSR. Textbook for the 7th grade of secondary schools. Moscow: Prosveshchenie, 1971.

At the same time, Soviet textbooks constantly emphasized that Tsarist Russia was a "prison of nations." They claimed that government officials, landowners, the nascent bourgeoisie, and the Orthodox Church that aligned themselves with them cruelly oppressed and exploited the workers. The indigenous peoples suffered from a double oppression: that of their own feudal lords and that of visiting Russian colonizers.

Tsarism provided landowners and the bourgeoisie with the opportunity to plunder the Russian people and the peoples of the national outlying areas without restraint. Despotically ruling the country with the help of the police, gendarmerie, and military, tsarism turned Russia into a "prison of nations." I. B. Berkovin, I. A. Fedosov. History of the USSR. Textbook for 9th-grade secondary schools.

M.: Education, 1982.

Why the peoples of Siberia (and other Russian colonies) voluntarily sought refuge in the "prison of nations," where they were treated with every kind of oppression, was not explained in the textbooks. They simply stated that previously, all nations in Russia had fared poorly, but now (under Soviet rule), they were doing well. Implicitly, it was apparently assumed, the "annexed" peoples sensed the progressiveness of their "annexation" and seemed to sense that someday in the future, the "prison of nations" would transform into "the world's first state of workers and peasants." It's no coincidence that Soviet history departments invariably had a department called the "Department of Pre-Soviet USSR History," and no one found this paradoxical name jarring. This rather illogical dogmatic approach was called "dialectics," and also "historical materialism."

Surprisingly, after the collapse of the USSR, the Soviet narrative of the national question didn't fade into oblivion, but rather was passed around and is still actively used today. Decolonial activists like to use the image of "Russia—a prison of nations." Patriotic statists nostalgically recall the "indestructible union of free republics," which "Great Rus' forever united."

The son of the author of these lines, demon-eater Nikita Mikhalkov recently attacked a Tatar activist in his program Louise Shamsutdinova, who erected a monument to Khan Kuchum's wife, Queen Suzga, in the Tobolsk district. This legendary Siberian Cleopatra, after her husband's defeat, chose death over Russian captivity, slitting her throat on the banks of the Irtysh. According to another version, she threw herself into the river.

Photo: Historical and Memorial Complex "Isker"

Black-eyed Suzge, whose beauty "rivals the morning star Sholpan," became a heroine not only of Siberian Tatar legends but also of Russian literature. The romantic poem "Suzge" was written in 1837 by the Tobolsk poet and teacher Pyotr Yershov, the same author of "The Little Humpbacked Horse." In Yershov's poem, the death of the "Siberian Venus" turns into her moral victory over the brutal conquerors.

The poor queen walks
In his bedchamber,
He breaks his white hands,
A gloomy gaze wanders
And my melancholy and sorrow
So he says out loud:
“I know that this is what God wants,
So that great possession
Lord Kuchum
Destroyed! Why?
Has such a misfortune befallen us?
How did you anger fate?
Yesterday I was a queen,
And today, maybe I will
Russian captive, slave!
And my child... Oh God!
And the child... Oh, no! It can't be!
No, I will not be a slave!

The appearance of a monument to the rebellious Suzga somewhere in Siberia outraged not only Mikhalkov, but also many patriots of Russia, whose president espouses the morality of a rapist: "Like it or not, be patient, my beauty."

True to the ideals of the Soviet past, Nikita Mikhalkov took the form of a public denunciation, accusing Luiza Shamsutdinova of "inciting national hatred" on the grounds that 10 years ago she wrote on VKontakte that "Yermak is a bandit who came to the Siberian Khanate with the intention of robbery."

At the time, the idea of ​​erecting a monument to the pioneering ataman was being discussed in Tyumen. The idea didn't pass. Shamsutdinova also wrote about this on social media:

"The Tatars will never allow a monument to Yermak to be erected! To us, he's a brigand; Kuchum captured him by plague on the Isker and drowned him in the Irtysh! But a monument to our Great Khan Kuchum must be erected!"

Moscow and Isker: How Relations Between the Tsar and the Khan Soured

Stanislav Yakub Rostvorovsky, "Ermak's Envoys at the Red Porch Before Ivan the Terrible"

Kuchum's predecessor on the Siberian throne, Khan Ediger, declared himself a vassal of Ivan the Terrible after the Moscow Tsar took Kazan и AstrakhanPerhaps Ediger feared that his turn would now come, and preferred to pay off his debt with wool (the oath of allegiance to Moscow that the foreigners took) rather than fight Moscow.

In 1563, power in Western Siberia was seized by Kuchum, a member of the Shibanid dynasty that had ruled the Sibir Khanate until the coup staged by Yediger's grandfather. Nikita Mikhalkov, in his program, indignantly stated that Kuchum had overthrown (and executed) his predecessor, and therefore, he claimed, was an illegitimate ruler and a legitimate military target for Yermak.

In fact, at that time, everyone was overthrowing and executing each other at the first opportunity. Ivan the Terrible didn't care at all about the moral character of the Siberian khan, as long as he paid tribute. Kuchum, for his part, accepted the terms of the 1555 treaty with Moscow, and for a time everyone lived relatively peacefully.

Until 1570, when Moscow sent a letter to Isker demanding confirmation of the oath of allegiance that governed the relationship between the khan and the tsar. While Kuchum was considering whether to acknowledge vassalage, the Crimean Tatar army descended on Moscow. Ivan fled his capital, and the city was burned. After this, Kuchum refused to swear allegiance, which Moscow perceived as treason. But there was nothing they could do; Russian troops were bogged down in the West in the unsuccessful Livonian War.

Over the next decade, a vast and complex political game unfolded between rulers who considered themselves the successors of the Golden Horde, spanning the space from the Black Sea to Central Asia. Among them were Ivan the Terrible and Kuchum.

Until 1581, the Moscow government formally avoided direct war with Siberia. When the Stroganovs, holding royal charters to develop the "empty lands" beyond the Urals, sent Cossacks led by Yermak against Kuchum, Ivan the Terrible sent them a "letter of disgrace," which stated: "You waged war against them, and with your arrogance you set us at odds with the Siberian sultan." However, the autocrat's displeasure was feigned. Just a year after the "letter of disgrace," Ivan received Yermak's envoys in the Kremlin and gave them a chainmail for the ataman. Perhaps the very same one in which he drowned.

The cool imperial Ermak

Ataman Ermak Timofeevich

Surprisingly, Louise Shamsutdinova's opinion about Ermak Timofeevich largely coincides with the opinion of the historian Nikolai Karamzin, whom even Nikita Mikhalkov would hardly dare to accuse of "discrediting" the SVO of 1581-1585.

«A small band of vagabonds, driven by both crude greed for gain and noble love for glory, acquired a new Kingdom for Russia…” — Karamzin wrote in Volume 9 of his History.

Greed as a motive is understandable—Siberia is a rich country. But where did this "noble love of glory" come from? In Russian culture, Yermak Timofeevich has long ceased to be a person—he has become a symbol. Since the 18th century, his name has been a constant presence in chronicles and songs, where he is depicted as the conqueror of Siberia, a man who "conquered" an entire continent. Yermak's brutally contradictory image has proven fertile ground for many literary genres.

In Karamzin's "History," Yermak isn't just a mercenary—he's a hero whose Cossacks "took a vow of valor and chastity" and marched "to the Ural Mountains for a glorious deed." Karamzin imagines a kind of Siberian Crusade, transforming the bandits into penitent knights and their raid into a spiritual feat.

The myth of Yermak transforms the chronicle of colonial conquest into a moral parable, albeit with a touch of criminal romanticism. "Suddenly, the Lord awakened the conscience of a fierce robber."

Kuchum's escape from the city of Kashlyk

In a song from Kirsha Danilov's collection, "Ermak Took Siberia," former thieves die for Russia—their death washes away their past sins. In the 19th century, Russian poets continued to develop the legend. In Alexei Khomyakov's drama "Ermak," the conqueror falls victim to a shaman who lures him into a trap to "avenge Siberia." But the noble warrior, Ermak, prevents his enemies from killing him. He throws himself off a cliff into the river, delivering a patriotic monologue as he flies, concluding with the line: "Siberia is no more, from now on, Russia is here."

In the poem by the future Decembrist Ryleyev, Yermak appears not just as a patriot, but as a man of statesmanship: “Siberia was conquered by the Tsar, and we did not live idle in the world.”

Beyond colonial discourse, poetic recollections of those Yermak conquered also survive. Siberian Tatar songs echo apocalyptic imagery, as if taken from "The War of the Worlds": "The iron men came, spitting fire, thundering, and conquering us."

(F. Yusupov. “Historical legends of the Siberian Tatars”).

In Siberian Tatar memory, Yermak is not a "repentant sinner," but a guest who betrayed trust: "The old men said, 'Don't trust Yermak...' He lived with Kuchum for a year, saw everything, and ran away; and then he came back with an army."

This stark difference in perspective emerges when looking at Yermak Timofeevich through the eyes of the peoples he conquered. True, to find their legends, one must resort to libraries for limited-edition scholarly collections.

The Russian myth of Yermak as a "cultural hero" is obvious. It's everywhere and still ready for use at any moment. Alexei Ivanov's novel "Tobol" describes a miraculous chainmail that "keeps Yermak's warmth... Whoever dons it is as if clothed in Yermak's spirit."

The iron shirt in which the conqueror drowned becomes a metaphor for the Russian culture brought to Siberia: heavy, rusty, weighing down the body. For the imperial narrative, Yermak dead is even better than alive. He did his job and lay low. For the peoples of Siberia, primarily the Siberian Tatars, whose ancestors he fought, Yermak is an armored, merciless "terminator."

"In Tyumen, Tobolsk, and other cities in Siberia and the Urals, where there are large Siberian Tatar populations, you can see institutions and organizations called 'Ermak.' For example, in Tyumen, there's a bank called 'Ermak,' and a recreation center called 'Ermak.' Naturally, Siberian Tatars react differently to the name of this bank, recreation center, and other institutions and organizations that bear the word 'Ermak.' Some believe that all buildings and institutions bearing the name 'Ermak' should be destroyed, razed, or blown up. Among Siberian Tatars, there are also those who see no difference between the words 'Hitler,' 'Napoleon,' and 'Ermak.'" — wrote publicist Vasil Khasanov in his essay “The Word of Ermak.”

People without the right to census

According to the 2010 census, approximately 7 people identified themselves as Siberian Tatars. However, they are not recognized as a distinct people. For nearly 40 years, activists from the Tyumen organizations "Sybyr" and "Heritage" have been seeking to have Siberian Tatars included in the official list of indigenous peoples of the Russian Federation. So far, to no avail.

Luiza Shamsutdinova compiled a chronology of the refusals activists received from Soviet and Russian officials. In 1990, Vadim Solntsev, director of the Institute of Linguistics of the USSR Academy of Sciences, wrote to the Ministry of Public Education that the creation of a written language and grammar for Siberian Tatars was "advisable for humanitarian reasons." He was supported by Academician V. Tishkov, director of the Institute of Ethnography, who recommended that the Central Statistical Directorate of the USSR include Siberian Tatars in the list of peoples of the USSR.

The following year, the country ceased to exist. The fledgling Russian bureaucracy had no time for the Siberian Tatars. In the 1990s, the State Duma Committee on Nationalities declared that "there is no legal procedure for officially recognizing the status of a people."

Then the authorities of the Tyumen region declared that Siberian Tatars live "in cities gravitating towards urban settlements," and therefore cannot be considered a small people of the North entitled to their own territory.

In 2011, the Federal Statistics Service absolved itself of responsibility, citing the census law, which stipulates that respondents' answers about ethnicity "cannot be grounds for inclusion in the list of indigenous peoples." Thus, activists were denied the right to ethnic agency and cultural identity by virtually all branches of government.

On October 16, 2025, the Tobolsk Court found Luiza Shamsutdinova guilty of "inciting hatred toward the process of Siberia's incorporation into the Russian state, toward the people who developed Siberia, including Yermak and his associates." For this crime, the activist was fined 17,500 rubles. The "illegally erected" monument to Suzga is subject to confiscation in favor of the state.

It took less than two months for Nikita Mikhalkov's complaint to turn into a court verdict.