Time to read: 12 minutes(s)

How Stolypin Relocated Russia to Siberia

On November 22, 1906, an agrarian reform began in Russia, which was called the "Stolypin" reform after the Chairman of the Cabinet of Ministers, Pyotr Stolypin.

Author: Andrey Filimonov.

Pyotr Stolypin with his wife. Photo from 1907.

"The government wants to boost peasant land ownership," he said, speaking to State Duma deputies. "The government wants to see the peasant wealthy and prosperous, because where there is prosperity, there is, of course, education and true freedom."

Stolypin believed that personal land ownership would lead to the emergence of a class of politically conservative farmers, as in Germany and other European countries. Therefore, the main goal of the 1906 agrarian reform was the creation of a new human species, previously unknown in Rus'—the independent landowner. This same "kulak" (a peasant) would be savagely exterminated by the Bolsheviks 20 years later, forcing the peasants into a new form of serfdom—the collective farm system.

Resettlement Directorate or Siberian Order?

A peasant hut in the village of Martyanova. An early color photograph taken by Sergei Mikhailovich Prokudin-Gorsky as part of his work documenting the Russian Empire in 1909–1915. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

It was from the collective farm, known before the revolution as the commune or "mir," that Pyotr Stolypin sought to liberate the Russian peasant. This goal was served by the government decree of November 9 (22), which proclaimed the peasants' right to personal ownership of their land plots, previously held in the legally vague status of communal ownership. These personal plots of land were called "otruba" or "otrubnye khozyaistva." If a peasant built a house there, the land was called a khutor.

The second most important point of the reform was the resettlement of peasants to vacant lands in Siberia. This was voluntary, of course, and, what's more, state-funded. Families who decided to move beyond the Urals received:

  1. A plot of land from 10 to 30 hectares, depending on the resettlement area.
  2. Moving expenses to survive the first winter in a new place (on average, 100 rubles per family).
  3. Discounts on travel and baggage allowances on the newly constructed Trans-Siberian Railway, to which the state paid an additional 7,5 million rubles annually for the resettlers.
  4. Preferential loans from the Peasant Bank for land expansion and other agricultural needs. By 1917, loans totaling more than 1 billion rubles had been issued.
  5. Free consultations with agronomists and land surveyors.
Peasants sell bread, milk, and eggs. Photo from 1910.

All of this was handled by the Resettlement Administration, which also paved roads in the Siberian taiga (5200 miles in three years, costing 5 million rubles), opened rural schools (about 100 schools annually), built hospitals and churches, dug wells, conducted soil research, and helped the settlers “cut up the land.”

At the beginning of the 20th century, land surveying was the most in-demand profession in Siberia. State-appointed land surveyors received a salary from the state and did not charge peasants. But there was a critical shortage of them; those who wanted this service for free had to wait a year or two. No one could or wanted to wait, so private land surveying companies flourished; in Tomsk alone, there were four, each with a hundred employees. But they were expensive, and few settlers could afford commercial services. And here again, the Resettlement Directorate came to the rescue. According to Stolypin himself, it "involuntarily oversaw almost all of Siberia and became an institution that could be called by the old name of the 'Siberian Prikaz.'"

At first, Stolypin's project aroused doubts in Nicholas II. It was simply too grandiose. In the second half of the 19th century, the government had also resettled peasants to Siberia, but gradually, slowly, and, so to speak, without shaking the foundations. Stolypin, however, proposed lifting all previous restrictions on resettlement to Siberia and expediting the process exponentially. Against this backdrop, even the reforms of his grandfather Alexander seemed less of a major upheaval of the old regime. Russia had certainly never seen anything like it before. The autocrat was concerned about the unpredictable consequences of land redistribution and the "great migration of peoples." But, on the other hand, agrarian reform promised obvious political benefits for the monarchy, which had only recently, with great difficulty, survived the 1905 Revolution. The embers of the estates burned by the rebels were still hot, and there was no way to control them. Therefore, the resettlement of hundreds of thousands of rural peasants beyond the Urals seemed to the emperor a good solution to the peasant question. Moreover, the departure of the settlers freed up their land holdings, thus relieving the tension caused by the land shortage in the European part of the country. Finally, Nicholas decided to sign a decree with the dull title "On Amending Certain Provisions of the Current Law Concerning Peasant Land Ownership and Land Use."

Nicholas II on a boat in the Alexander Park of Tsarskoye Selo, 1906-1907.

In his diary, the emperor made a terse entry for November 7, 1906: "Received Stolypin." Now, it seemed, the agrarian reform should have proceeded smoothly. But the grand plan stalled in the swampy realities of Russia. First, there were intrigues. According to the memoirs of Grand Duke Alexander Mikhailovich, Nicholas II's cousin, "court circles were envious of Stolypin's successful government activities." Empress Alexandra Feodorovna disliked the chairman of the cabinet because Pyotr Arkadyevich made no secret of his antipathy toward her favorite, Rasputin. Fortunately for Stolypin, Nicholas's mother, the Dowager Empress Maria Feodorovna, who disliked her daughter-in-law, interceded for him. Finance Minister Kokovtsev, in his memoirs, quotes her words to her son: “A man was found whom no one knew here, but who turned out to be both intelligent and energetic and managed to bring order after the horror we had experienced, and now this man is being pushed into the abyss…”

Secondly, there was the conservatism of the landowners and right-wingers, who considered the "Great Reform" of 1861 a mistake, severing the "family ties" between landowners and peasants. Thirdly, there was criticism from the left. The opposition-minded State Duma considered Stolypin's reforms insufficiently liberal and dissected every government decree for a year, sometimes even two. All this hindered the progress of the reforms.

Nikolai Dmitriev-Orenburgsky, "The Murder of Stolypin in the Theater"

But the main problem was that history had not granted Russia the "20 years of inner peace" Stolypin had hoped for. An assassination attempt in Kiev in September 1911 ended the prime minister's life. Bogrov, an anarchist and neurasthenic who was also a paid agent of the secret police, shot Stolypin in the theater, as if imitating Abraham Lincoln's assassin, who had also killed the president who had liberated the slaves in a theater box. Bogrov was convicted and hanged just two weeks after the attack. The motive for the crime was absurd: "I wanted to do something extravagant." After hearing the verdict, the killer shrugged and said, "I don't care if I eat another two thousand cutlets."

Agrarian reform and resettlement to Siberia continued even after Stolypin's death. However, his successors clearly lacked Stolypin's charisma and political will. The process continued, but somewhat sluggishly; until the start of World War I, the flow of settlers to Siberia declined, despite an increase in the resettlement budget.

A group of Siberian settlers. Photo from 1910.

Traces of a strange beast

Siberian archives contain some fascinating reading: collections of police reports in which officers reported to their superiors on incidents in their assigned territory. The information was for official use only and was not published in newspapers.

For example, in 1899, a police officer in the Mariinsky district of Tomsk province reported that a group of peasants saw something flying over the forest while mowing, something with either four or six wings (witness accounts differ). One of the men, carrying a double-barreled hunting rifle, fired and hit the unidentified flying object. When it fell to the ground, the mowers chopped it up with axes and burned it at the stake. The police were then notified of the incident. The police officer who arrived at the scene found a large, cold fire pit containing stumps of bones.

Tramps at the station. Photo from 1910.

In another district of Tomsk Governorate, residents of the village of Nelyubino also reported the sighting of unknown animals, whose tracks they had discovered on the ground. Fortunately, in this case, there was no shooting or cremation. A police officer arrived at the scene, along with informants, following the tracks of the "unknown animal" and came to a clearing where walkers from European Russia had set up camp, wearing bast shoes—an item unfamiliar to Siberians.

For a long-time Siberian resident, a UFO or a peasant in bast shoes coming from beyond the Urals were equally otherworldly phenomena. Likewise, newcomers from Kursk or Vladimir provinces felt as if they were on another planet in Siberia, where even the sun shines differently. Many settlers complained that Siberian bread wasn't enough to satisfy their hunger. Cows and horses also went hungry, even though they ate more grass and hay than in Russia.

A fragment of a postcard from the series "Siberia: Settlers"

One thoughtful rural scribe from the settlers, reflecting on the strange features of the Siberian nature, wrote down his thoughts and observations on paper:

"I chewed the grass and hay: Siberian grasses are neither juicy nor sweet, and therefore not nourishing. And why they are not nourishing—I think this: with the onset of spring, when the earth should be saturated with snow water and absorb the influence of the sun's rays, from which the earth's soil, from various root substances, like dough in a trough, becomes somewhat sweet, and at this moment the nascent plant quickly saturates its nerves with a sweetish solution. And then there are the May rains and poultices. In Siberia, this never happens: as soon as the snow melts, May is the most destructive month: clouds roll in from the Arctic Ocean, like in autumn, and from them there is neither rain nor sun rays, and the earth does not create such an evaporative solution. And then comes June with its hot, dry days: the plant is deprived, like a baby without breasts, of its nourishing product..." Russian Wealth. 1899. No. 3

"Siberia is growing like crazy"

Going to Siberia was scary. It was a foreign land—not Russia. And quite a few peasants, having looked around their new surroundings, turned around and went back. About a quarter of the settlers returned. But three-quarters stayed and settled. Stolypin's reforms, in just three years, transformed Siberia in a way the previous three centuries had not. By 1910, almost 3 million people had moved from Russia to Siberia. Before the "Great Migration," the entire Siberian region had a population of four and a half million.

In 1910, Pyotr Stolypin and the imperial land manager, Alexander Krivoshein, made an inspection tour of Siberia to observe the progress of the resettlement firsthand. The report of the trip filled an entire book. Judging by Stolypin's description, Siberia was seething as never before:

"It was clear that not everything was going well, not everything was organized, and not everything was even clear, both in the feverish movement beyond the Urals and in the mass settling of the settlers in new places. Crowds of unauthorized settlers, striving to get to Siberia at all costs, and a counter-current of those returning; the bottomlessness of the vast Siberian expanses—and persistent declarations that there was no more land there for settlers; demands for a further, immediate, tenfold expansion of resettlement credits, and of the resettlement itself—and at the same time, doubts as to whether it was even possible to proceed with this matter as broadly as now; a vague, but almost universal awareness that our state budget has few productive expenditures such as those for resettlement—and incessant, often harsh, attacks on the resettlement cause from a variety of sides."

During those times of freedom of speech, only the lazy failed to criticize the agrarian reform, the resettlement program, and Pyotr Arkadyevich himself. Perhaps only Rasputin evoked stronger public sentiment (but criticism of him was forbidden, despite freedom of speech). Stolypin's name became a household word. New expressions appeared in the Russian language: "Stolypin ties," meaning gallows, in memory of the harsh measures taken to suppress the rebels; "Stolypin carriages," which initially carried voluntary settlers to Siberia, and which the Soviet government later used to transport millions of people to the Gulag using "Stolypins." And finally, the "Stolypin reform," the results of which Pyotr Arkadyevich personally reported to the Tsar in a private letter:

"Siberia is growing at a phenomenal rate: in the waterless steppes, which two years ago were deemed unfit for settlement, not only settlements but almost cities have sprung up in the last few months. And the mixed stream of rich and poor, strong and weak, registered and unauthorized settlers pouring from Russia into Siberia—in short, a wonderful and powerful colonizing force. I'll add that this force is firmly monarchical, with a correct, pure, Russian worldview. 'We believe in God, we believe in the Tsar, we ask: give us a church, give us a school'—that's the common cry of all Siberian settlers. In every village, we were greeted with longevity for Your Majesty; everywhere, we were asked to convey to the Tsar-father the love of the people." October 26, 1910

View of Tobolsk from the north, from the bell tower of the Church of the Transfiguration. Russia. Photo by Prokudin-Gorsky. 1912.

Stolypin had less than a year to live; the "Tsar-Father" was given eight years before his death in the basement of the Ipatiev House. But Stolypin didn't live to see how it all ended. War, revolution, the end of agrarian reform. The Socialist Revolutionary slogan "Land to the peasants," used by the Bolsheviks to consolidate their hold on power. And then their conversation with the peasantry became brief: the food tax, poison gas for the Tambov rebels, and Stalin's collectivization.

The Soviet government had no desire to see the peasant "rich and prosperous." The Bolsheviks destroyed virtually all the achievements of Stolypin's reforms, except for one fact that could never be undone: part of Russia moved to Siberia, which led to a national reorganization. Russia "before" and "after" Stolypin are two very different countries.