A Beautiful Russia of the Future through the Eyes of the Decembrists
Author: Andrey Filimonov
Love for Good stirred their hearts. And Herzen slept, unaware of evil... But the Decembrists woke Herzen. He hadn't slept enough. That's where it all started. Naum KorzhavinIn memory of Herzen
This week, a conference was held in Russia to commemorate the 200th anniversary of the Senate Square uprising. Russian Justice Minister Chuichenko, whose department is responsible for designating "foreign agents," declared that the Decembrists were "foreigners and infidels" who confused the Russian people with Western ideas. Their uprising was a "rebellion" that had stalled "many significant reforms" in Russia (he did not specify which ones). The state allegedly "demonstrated weakness" and did not punish the "rebels" harshly enough. He deemed it necessary to state that "it is important for the state to always be strong, especially during periods of transition." scold Putin's minister, imperial Russia of two hundred years ago.
Six months earlier, Mr. Chuichenko, at a legal forum, demonstrated his knowledge of the famous formula, learned back in school, of a Russian revolutionary more successful than the Decembrists, generated An illustrative aphorism: “Of course, it would have been better if they had not woken Herzen up, let him sleep peacefully. I think“Russia would be a different country now then.”
NeMoskva asked why Putin's minister is so triggered by an event that happened two centuries ago? And what would have happened to Russia if the December 14 uprising had been successful?
The day when there was a lot of shooting in St. Petersburg

On December 14, 1825, a group of guards officers led approximately eight hundred soldiers of the Moscow Life Guards Regiment onto Senate Square in St. Petersburg. The leaders of the uprising explained to their subordinates that they were going out to the square for "Constantine and the Constitution." The soldiers understood this to refer to the Grand Duke's wife, whose portraits had been on display in the windows of Moscow's shops for several days, labeled "Emperor Constantine the First."
Throughout the empire, only a few inhabitants of the Winter Palace knew that Konstantin had long since been removed from the list of candidates for the throne. Alexander I decided that his younger brother, Nicholas, was better suited to govern the empire. However, the Tsar displayed his characteristic duplicity and announced his political testament only to a small family circle. The result of this indecisive decision was the December Crisis of 1825.

At the beginning of the uprising, the military governor-general of St. Petersburg, Mikhail Miloradovich, a hero of the Patriotic War, arrived at Senate Square. He was about to deliver a speech to the "rebels," but was shot by Pyotr Kakhovsky, a retired lieutenant assigned to the role of regicide because he was "a completely lonely man." The wound was fatal, and Miloradovich died a few hours later.
Nicholas, not yet fully crowned but already an active tsar, hadn't yet appeared on the square, and Kakhovsky was "warming up." His next victim was General Sturler, commander of the Grenadier Regiment, who had arrived "in the thick of the rebels" to "bring them to their senses." A shot, a sabre blow, and the general was carried off. He died the next day, having accepted the title of aide-de-camp from the new tsar in gratitude for his actions on Senate Square.

"The mutiny intensified; the entire Guards crew arrived at the initial mass of the Moscow Regiment and joined them from the direction of Galernaya; while the crowd of grenadiers stood on the other side. The noise and shouting became incessant, and frequent shots flew overhead." recalled Emperor Nicholas on his first day in power.
No Russian monarch had ever ascended the throne under such circumstances. And St. Petersburg had never seen street fighting on such a scale and ferocity.
Nicholas personally commands the troops loyal to him. The outcome of the battle, unfolding in the very heart of the empire, remains unclear until 5 p.m. The government forces are seriously outnumbered. But, as one foreign observer noted, "a properly positioned guards company" could change Russia's fate.

The Horse Guards' attack on the rebels' serried ranks was unsuccessful. The Decembrists repelled them with a few rifle volleys. Cavalry is ill-suited for street fighting, especially in the winter of St. Petersburg, where horses slip on the icy cobblestones. Seeing the failure of the cavalry attack, Adjutant General Vasilchikov told Nicholas that it was urgent to load the cannons with grapeshot and strike the rebels before they launched a counterattack. According to his memoirs, Nicholas allegedly responded:
"— Do you want me to shed the blood of my subjects on the first day of my reign? [Do you want me to shed the blood of my subjects on the first day of my reign?] — I answered Vasilchikov. — To save your empire [To save your empire], — сказал he told me. These words brought me back to my senses; having come to my senses, I saw that either I must take upon myself the shedding of the blood of some and almost certainly save everything; or, sparing myself, decisively sacrifice the state."
In Russia, the state has always been more valuable than any amount of spilled blood of its subjects. Soon the cannons began to fire. Grapeshot decimated the squares. The rebels scattered, some were caught in the alleys, others tried to cross the Neva on the ice and drowned in the ice holes. The death toll remains unclear. It could have been two hundred or twelve hundred. In our latitudes, the number of victims of state measures to establish national prosperity is traditionally counted more or less approximately.
With God against the Tsar
Two weeks after the massacre on Senatskaya Street, the Chernigov Regiment Uprising began in the Kyiv Governorate. It was led by members of the Southern Society, Alexei Bestuzhev-Ryumin and Sergei Muravyov-Apostol (grandson of the last Ukrainian hetman, Danylo Apostol).
The Chernigovites lined up on the parade ground, and the regimental priest read them the “Orthodox Catechism,” composed by the conspirators:
Question. Why did God create man?
Reply. So that he believes in it, is free and happy.
Question. What does it mean to be free and happy?
Reply. There is no happiness without freedom...
Question. Why are the Russian people and the Russian army unhappy?
Reply. Because the kings stole their freedom.
Question. So, do kings act contrary to God's will?
Reply. Yes... Christ said: you cannot serve God and mammon, that is why the Russian people and the Russian army suffer...
Question. What does our holy law command the Russian people and army to do?
Reply. Repent of long servility and, taking up arms against tyranny and wickedness, swear: let there be one king for all in heaven and on earth, Jesus Christ...
With such a pompous farewell, the regiment, fully equipped, marched in column to... an unknown destination. Either Zhitomir or Bila Tserkva. The leaders themselves couldn't decide and led the soldiers from one village to another for several days until they ran into an ambush by government troops. Here, too, gun barrels awaited the Decembrists. Not believing that the artillery would fire on their own (Matvey Pykhachev, a horse artillery company, whom the revolutionary commanders considered a member of a secret society), considered "His own," Muravyov-Apostol orders a march straight toward the cannons. When the front rank of Chernigovites is a few dozen meters away, Pykhachev orders "Fire." No warning shots or blanks. A lethal volley, leaving the infantry no chance. Muravyov is wounded in the head, and soldiers fall dead around him. The rear ranks, throwing down their rifles, scatter in all directions.

Bestuzhev-Ryumin recalled during the investigation:
"We, without a word, almost both of us (Sergey Muravyov and I – ed.) walked along unconscious, not knowing where we were going. Meanwhile, the column had broken up, and the hussars began to ride up to it. Then some soldiers from the Chernigov Regiment rushed at us, probably trying to drag us toward the hussars. But a hussar officer galloped up to us, and we surrendered to him."
Thus, in less than a month, the Decembrist movement was ended. The secret societies that had spent nearly a decade plotting the largest elite conspiracy in Russian history ceased to exist. Russia had made its choice: Tsar Nicholas, the gallows for the rebellion's leaders, prisons and Siberian exile for the remaining participants. For the populace—Orthodoxy, autocracy, and nationality.

But this might not have happened. If not eight hundred, but eight thousand soldiers had gone over to the rebels. If the artillerymen had refused to fire. And if Kakhovsky had stood by Nicholas's side and fulfilled his assigned role… What then? The Decembrist constitutions, written long before December 14, contain at least three scenarios for a "beautiful Russia of the future."
Three drafts of one country
The first and earliest version of the "constitution" was the "Green Book," named for the color of its binding. It was a Masonic and slightly moralistic project of the "Union of Welfare," aiming to "spread true moral and educational principles and assist the government" in transforming Russia into a great and prosperous power.
The second draft, Nikita Muravyov's Constitution (Northern Society), describes Russia as a federation of thirteen "powers" and two federal regions (Moscow and St. Petersburg). The form of government is a constitutional monarchy.
The most radical political scenario is Pavel Pestel's "Russian Truth" ("Southern Society"). The monarchy is abolished. The Romanovs are sent to the scaffold. A temporary revolutionary dictatorship is established in the country. The rebellious peoples of the Caucasus and the Jews will be deported abroad.
Let's be like bees
The Union of Welfare is a noble fantasy of young officers and officials, mostly Masons, who agreed among themselves: "Let us first become impeccable people ourselves, and then we will improve the order in the country."
A swarm of bees was the emblem of the new secret society. One of the Decembrists testified during the investigation: they believed that every major city should have 150 members of the secret union, and when this was achieved, "the hive would be full." The open section of the charter clearly stated: the union's goal was to spread morality and education and thereby assist the government in raising Russia to the heights of prosperity to which it was "destined by the Creator Himself."
In the second, "secret" part, according to recollections (the book was burned), things are much more concrete: the abolition of serfdom; the introduction of representative government; the gradual "preparation of society" for a constitution.
Violence as a method is not welcomed. The Union must act through education and persuasion.
"The Union is diligently engaged in disseminating true principles of virtue among all classes of the people, reminding and explaining to everyone their duties regarding faith, neighbor, Fatherland, and the existing authorities. It demonstrates the inseparable connection between virtue, that is, good morality, and the people's well-being, and makes every effort to eradicate the vices that have crept into our hearts, especially the preference for personal gain over public gain, baseness, the gratification of vile passions, hypocrisy, extortion, and cruelty to those under authority. In short, by educating everyone regarding their duties, it strives to reconcile and bring into harmony all classes, ranks, and tribes in the state and encourages them to strive unanimously for the goal of government: the common good, so that from the general public opinion a true moral tribunal may be created, which, with its beneficial influence, would complete the formation of good morals and thereby lay a firm and unshakable foundation for the well-being and valor of the Russian people."
If we imagine a parallel reality in which the "beehive" wins on December 14th, we get a country where the monarchy is overseen by enlightened men in uniform, serfdom is abolished half a century earlier, and ministries are run by "Masonic brothers, men, and boyars" from the "Union of Welfare."
The Romanovs remain with their people. They are neither liquidated nor exiled. They are merely asked to sign a manifesto abolishing serfdom. The country is undergoing a lengthy course of treatment for autocracy. It is relatively gentle, but with potential relapses, since Russia has known no other form of government than despotism since the Moscow tsars destroyed Novgorod and its liberties.
Muravyov: Peasants with a Constitution

Nikita Muravyov was a descendant of an ancient noble family, the son of the poet Mikhail Muravyov, tutor to the Grand Dukes Alexander and Konstantin Pavlovich. Nikita's background included a university environment, liberal philosophy, faith in reason, and romantic patriotism. In 1812, at the age of 16, he ran away to the front to fight Napoleon. He took with him a map and a diary, which he wrote in French, like any educated nobleman. A few days later, the suspicious young nobleman was captured by peasants who suspected him of being a spy. The French notes, combined with the map, only strengthened their confidence. The young man was handed over to a military patrol, which, after an investigation, returned the fugitive home. From this adventure, the future Decembrist gained a love for his people, who could be trusted because they were reasonable and kind.
Muravyov is Russia as a federal constitutional monarchy. "The Russian people, free and independent, is not and cannot be the property of any individual or family." Greetings to the Romanovs!
Russia is divided into 13 "states" or federal subjects: Bothnia, Volkhov, Ob (Western Siberia), Lena (Eastern Siberia), and so on. Moscow and St. Petersburg are kept apart. It was specifically stipulated:
“60. The House of Representatives shall be composed of members elected for two years by the citizens of the Powers.
61. At the time of his election, the representative must reside in the State which has elected him."
The regions are free to pursue independent domestic policies, like the Swiss cantons. Siberia has its own school reform, the Caucasus its own tax policy, and the Baltics its own trade tariffs. The capital of this entire system is Nizhny Novgorod, renamed Slavensk. The People's Assembly, a bicameral parliament, meets there.
The Emperor is the "supreme official of the Russian government." Something like a prime minister. He heads the executive branch, but the laws are passed by the Veche.
A monarch doesn't necessarily have to bear the surname Romanov. Muravyov clarifies: we have no irreplaceable ones. If the royal family refuses to accept the constitution, "as a last resort," their exile is permissible.
All citizens are equal before the law, censorship and serfdom are abolished.
Serfdom and slavery are abolished. A slave who touches Russian soil becomes free. The division between nobles and commoners is not accepted, as it is contrary to the Faith, according to which all people are brothers, all are born for good by the will of God, all are born for good, and all are just people: for all are weak and imperfect.
Peasants receive two dessiatines of land. The landowners' land interests are also protected by law.
If the "Northern Party" had won the Senate, then, let's dream, Russia would have been 50-80 years ahead of its current history, having received a full package of civil liberties while Karl Marx was still in elementary school. Half a century later, Marxists would not have been able to tempt Russia with the specter of communism. This line of thought lacks the explosive year of 1905 and the apocalyptic year of 1917. Modernization proceeds smoothly and without shock.
Pestel: A united anti-Semitic Russia
Under Alexander I, Pavel Pestel's father was Governor-General of Siberia. But he preferred to live in the capital.
There's a joke about how the Tsar once asked one of his courtiers, "What kind of bird is that sitting on the church dome in the distance?" "Your Majesty, we should call Ivan Borisovich [Pestel] here," the courtier replied with a bow. "He has such excellent eyesight; he can see what's happening in Siberia from his home in St. Petersburg."
The Pestels were a family of German descent—Saxon nobles who entered the tsar's service under Peter the Great. Raised in an atmosphere of bureaucratic virtue and Lutheran discipline, Pavel attended a German school in Dresden and then graduated from the Page Corps in St. Petersburg. Unlike Muravyov, he was a true front-line soldier of 1812.

Pestel considered any attempt to make the monarchy "good and obedient" foolish. He had before him the recent example of the restoration of the monarchy in France, where the Bourbons returned to power, having "forgotten nothing and learned nothing." Therefore, Pavel Ivanovich intended to deal decisively with the tsars and their heirs, leaving no claimant to the throne.
"Russian truth" Pestel's work is a terrifying document in its uncompromisingness. Muravyov couldn't have imagined the mass execution of the Romanovs even in his worst nightmare.
Pestel's form of government must be a unitary republic. No "subjects," no autonomy. Any separatist "talk in the ranks" is prohibited by supreme law. The disadvantages of federalism are explained in four clear points:
“The general disadvantages of a federal state structure are, among many others, the following four: 1) The supreme authority in a federal state essentially does not issue laws, but only advice: for it cannot enforce its laws except through regional authorities, lacking other special coercive means. If a region does not want to obey, then, in order to force it to obey, it is necessary to start an internecine war; from which it is clear that the seed of destruction already lies in the very foundations of the structure. 2) Special laws, a special method of persecution, and the special concepts and ways of thinking that arise from it will further weaken the ties between the different regions. The regions will regard the supreme authority as something tedious and unpleasant, and each regional government will reason that it would have arranged state affairs in relation to its region much better without the participation of the supreme authority. Here is a new seed of destruction. — 3) Each region, constituting, so to speak, a small separate state in a federal state, will be weakly attached to the whole and even during war may act without zeal for the general composition of the state; especially if a crafty enemy will be able to entice it with promises of some special benefits and advantages for it. The private good of the region, although temporary, will nevertheless still have a stronger effect on the imagination of its government and people than the common good of the entire state, which, perhaps, does not bring at that time obvious benefit to the region itself. 4) The word state under such a formation will be an empty word, for no one anywhere will see a state, but everyone everywhere will see only his own private region; and therefore love for the fatherland will be limited to love for one’s own region.”
The capital is planned to be moved to Nizhny Novgorod (again!), renaming it Vladimir. To avoid confusion, the former Vladimir is proposed to be called Klyazmin.
After the coup, power is assumed by the Provisional Supreme Government, a five-member directory headed by a dictator (Pestel). Then, when everything has been shattered and rebuilt, elections to the People's Assembly are held.
Serfdom is abolished without any preliminaries. Land is divided into private and public. Public land is a volost fund, not for sale, but distributed among the peasants so that no one is dependent on the whims of a rich neighbor. Private land is completely marketable: buy, sell, and develop farming.
Estates are abolished, and a unified civil status is introduced. Everyone is equal before the law.
A special place in "Russkaya Pravda" is occupied by the discussion of how multinationality is a problem for a unitary republic. Regarding the diverse population of foreign nationals, it explains frankly and quite meticulously:
"Finland, Estonia, Livonia, Courland, Belarus, Little Russia, Novorossiya, Bessarabia, Crimea, Georgia, the entire Caucasus, the Kirghiz lands, all the Siberian peoples and various other tribes living within the State have never enjoyed and never can enjoy independent independence... And in the future, due to their weakness, they will never be able to form separate States; and therefore, they are all subject to the Right of Convenience, while at the same time must forever renounce the right of a separate Nationality."
An exception is made only for Poland, but with some reservations:
...By the rule of nationality, Russia must grant Poland an independent existence. But the final determination of the borders between Russia and Poland must be left to the rule of convenience for Russia, and this independent restoration of Poland must be arranged on such principles and conditions that will fully safeguard Russia in the future against any actions that might be contrary to its firm security or its complete tranquility.
Regarding nomadic peoples, “half-wild people, and some completely wild” and “not knowing their own good,” Pestel’s constitutional project provided for:
“…to reveal to them the light of the Orthodox Faith and the rays of true enlightenment: sending to them Missionaries who, through meekness and persuasion, little by little would enlighten and calm these unfortunate peoples.”
In the long term, it was intended to transform the nomads into farmers as they became “enlightened”.
The "Jewish question" is a separate issue. Its "Pestel solution" was shamefully ignored in Soviet history textbooks. The Decembrist accused Jews of "special cohesion" and "subordination to rabbis," which led to their "lack of respect" for state laws.
“This state of affairs, which has established the hostile attitude of Jews towards Christians and placed them in a position contrary to the public order in the State, cannot continue any longer.” — writes Pestel. He offers two options, which have predictable associations for the modern reader: either de facto assimilation or organized resettlement (of approximately two million people) to a separate territory outside of Russia.
"The method depends on specific circumstances and the specific course of foreign affairs and consists of assisting the Jews in establishing a separate, distinct state in some part of Asia Minor. To this end, it is necessary to designate a rallying point for the Jewish people and provide them with several troops as reinforcements. If all Russian and Polish Jews were to gather in one place, they would number over two million. Such a number of people seeking a homeland would easily overcome all obstacles the Turks might oppose them and, after traversing European Turkey, cross into Asiatic Turkey and there, occupying sufficient territory and land, establish a separate Jewish state. But since this gigantic undertaking requires specific circumstances and truly brilliant enterprise, it cannot be made the absolute responsibility of the Provisional Supreme Authority and is mentioned here only to hint at all that could be accomplished."
If the uprising of December 14 had resulted in the victory of the so-called "Committee of Public Safety" led by Pavel Pestel, the first months of the new government would have been marked by the execution of members of the royal family and the arrests of those who could have organized the restoration of the dynasty.
Then came the years of the dictatorship of the reformers: land redistribution, a new administrative grid, a new capital and a new calendar of holidays.
Peasants receive land from the public fund and cease to be "souls." This dramatically changes the social landscape. The old elite is partially destroyed, some emigrated, or integrated into the new republican nomenklatura.
The multinational empire is being transformed into a country where everyone is invited to become "Russian citizens" in Pestel's sense; anyone who doesn't fit into this framework is relegated to the role of a forced "migrant."

This world comes closest to the revolutionary utopia of the 20th century. It horrified Nicholas so much that Pestel, arrested on the eve of the uprising and having used no violence against government officials, was sentenced to be drawn and quartered, which the Tsar "mercifully" commuted to hanging. Pestel was the only one of the five to be executed solely for his political views.
And what about Nikolai?
History ultimately “chose” an option not prescribed in any constitution: the autocratic rule of Nicholas I with his gendarmes and censors, who saw sedition everywhere.
I am the daughter of freedom, Away with the emperors from their thrones. I will untie the tongues of the senators with a cry for freedom. Kondraty Ryleyev/Alexander Bestuzhev-Marlinsky
It is interesting that after the Decembrists were sentenced, Nicholas ordered all poems to be removed from the files and destroyed (they are easy to remember, after all, and officials might spread them!).
Nikolaev's peace is stylistically very close to the current Russian regime. However, even the Russian Minister of Justice indirectly acknowledges that Nikolaev's reign was a dead period, when "reforms stalled."
But it is the Decembrists who are “to blame”, of course, and not those who shot and hanged them.