Involuntary pictures
The story of Grigory Soroka, an artist who never experienced freedom
Author: Sergey Tashevsky

"...He wandered thoughtfully through the village, not drunk, and then, around vespers, he left and disappeared somewhere. His wife, seeing her husband's absence, went looking for him and found him hanged in a burning hut. Taking his hand and feeling it still warm, she immediately ran to the deceased's brothers living across the street and announced what had happened, asking them to help free her husband from the noose. And although one of them untied the rope and Soroka fell to the floor, he was already dead. No one knows why Soroka took his own life, and they assume it was due to the mad thoughtfulness of drunkenness. The deceased was quiet and modest in demeanor."
Thus, according to art historian Grigory Ostrovsky, "the era of serf artists" in Russian art ended. Soroka, who committed suicide at the age of 40, could well have been considered the last of them. However, his death occurred during a time of "freedom," occurring two years after the abolition of serfdom, in 1864. But in a more important sense, Soroka never lived to see his "freedom." His life was destroyed in advance, many years before.
By the standards of a serf's life, Grigory Vasiliev, nicknamed "Soroka" as a child for his keen eye and curiosity, initially had a prosperous life. He was born in late 1823, the second son of a peasant named Vasily Savelyev, who lived in the village of Pokrovskoye in the Vyshnevolotsky district of the Tver region (hence the surname "Vasiliev"—it was often given to peasant children based on their fathers' names). The village was small, with only 26 households and 200 residents, so it had no church of its own. Grigory was baptized in the neighboring village of Poddubye, where a miraculously preserved register of births records his baptism.
But the village, the hamlet, the church, the peasant Vasily Savelyev, his wife Ekaterina Ivanova, and even the newborn Grigory himself, undoubtedly belonged to someone. Specifically, they all belonged to the retired captain Pyotr Ivanovich Milyukov, a baptized Tatar. According to neighbors, the Milyukovs were "good" landowners, meaning they weren't beasts: they didn't revel in torturing the peasants, punished them only for serious offenses, and even sought to educate them to some degree. Nikolai Milyukov, the captain's son, who soon inherited part of the estate, even opened a "one-class school for peasant children" in Poddubye in 1836.
In fact, it was his job description to do something like this, since he was listed as the honorary superintendent of the Vyshny Volochok schools. Moreover, it was a new era; many were building schools for peasants, which was considered good form. For example, the Milyukovs' neighbor, artist and academician of the Imperial Academy Alexei Venetsianov, had recently opened a school in his village of Safonkovo, where he taught painting to talented children, including peasants and serfs.

Milyukov respected Venetsianov greatly and considered it a special honor to occasionally spend time in the famous artist's company. Therefore, he not only opened a school for peasants following Venetsianov's example but also hired Priest Vasily Vladimirov, Venetsianov's spiritual mentor, as a teacher.
Young Grigory was certainly lucky – school opened when he was 12, and instead of working in the fields from morning until night, he went to school. He enjoyed his studies – the school taught not only literacy and religious studies, but also the basics of mathematics, and they even had drawing supplies. Perhaps it was then that his artistic talent was discovered. There is, however, a version that Soroka taught himself drawing as a child, even painting icons for the local church, before the priest noticed him and sent him to study at the village school. But something doesn't add up. There were no icon-painting workshops in such small villages, and no one would have entrusted a 12-year-old peasant's son with brushes and paints, which were precious in those days. So, most likely, Grigory entered school "on a general basis" and began drawing there.
And then, it seems, he struck it lucky again. Father Vasily, Venetsianov's spiritual mentor, noticed the boy's talent and told the artist about it. He became intrigued and took Soroka under his wing. That this was indeed the case is evidenced by an album of drawings that Grigory gave to his schoolteacher in 1842. The album has miraculously survived to this day; it's a small, pocket-sized book containing about twenty pencil portraits on thick paper. Fellow villagers, classmates, and Grigory's relatives. These are Soroka's earliest works known to art historians, but they already reveal the hand of a true master. He was likely about 15 years old when he began making these pencil sketches, and it was from them that Father Vasily, and later Venetsianov, recognized his talent.
Little village "Venetsianov School" By that time, the school was famous throughout Russia, attracting young men from Moscow and St. Petersburg to study there. There were even, it seems, a few French students. But Venetsianov, despite being the official court artist and academician, was a firm supporter of "peasant talent." His school always included several children from the surrounding villages, and some of them actually became accomplished artists. For example, Alekseyev and Zlatov, whom Venetsianov personally ransomed from serfdom (though he managed to negotiate a rather modest sum with their owners). So, given the friendly relationship between the artist and Milyukov, the young Soroka had truly brilliant prospects.
At first, it seemed, everything was indeed going well. In the spring of 1842, Grigory found himself at Venetsianov's school for the first time. But it was only for a short time. Apparently, just a few weeks later, Milyukov recalled him back to the estate to do farm labor. But Soroka no longer wanted farm labor. And so he rebelled.
Venetsianov, too, was perplexed: "I received your letter and gave you news of Grigory's appearance before me... Didn't I foretell you, or rather, with my fears, did I not warn you of what happened to your Grigory? He's not to blame, but you are—you gave him direction, and then stopped him, you made him feel inner pleasure, you touched his soul from its positive crypt, and then stopped him," he wrote to Milyukov in April 1842. It seems the letter had the desired effect; Soroka returned to canvas and paint—but again, only temporarily. This continued, time after time.
It seems there was a real battle between Milyukov and Venetsianov over the talented young man. But it was a very polite one. Trying to convince Soroka's master that the young man needed to develop his talent, Venetsianov wrote to his correspondent cautiously, as if he were mad:

"Here, my most esteemed Nikolai Petrovich, I return your Grigory with a growth spurt—you'll see this growth for yourself. My Misha has a long way to go to reach this station, and Plakhov won't even be able to get there... You might allow Grigory to paint some of your interiors, but certainly not of your rooms, but whatever he instinctively finds appealing." "Misha" in this letter is Venetsianov's nephew, Mikhail Erassi, one of Soroka's fellow students who showed great promise, while Plakhov had by then graduated from the Academy of Fine Arts, completed an internship in Berlin, and was an accomplished artist. It appears this village "nugget" outgrew them all. His paintings from that period attest to this, though, unfortunately, few survive. One of the most famous is "Threshing Floor," obviously painted in the footsteps and after the example of Venetsianov's painting of the same name. But soon, completely independent works appeared, such as the winter landscape "Outbuilding in Ostrovki." It seems to be from a different time altogether, not from the mid-19th century, but rather from its end. It seems to anticipate Polenov and Levitan.

But not only landscapes (though Soroka achieved perfection in them), but also interior painting and portraits—all of these he excelled at, becoming increasingly accomplished. In 1844, at Venetsianov's request, he sought out "the interior that he instinctively finds welcoming," and painted "Study in Ostrovki," and then "Reflection in a Mirror."

Why was all this happening in Ostrovok (a neighboring village) and not at the main estate? And why did Milyukov increasingly seldom allow him to attend art school, insisting that Soroka serve as the gardener at Ostrovok? There seems to be an explanation for all this.

According to village legend, a romance blossomed between Soroka and one of the landlord's daughters, Lydia Milyukova. She was beautiful (at least judging by Grigory's portrait), and he, too, had an almost Byronic appearance (again, according to his self-portrait). Their passion was said to be mutual, and it was for this reason that Milyukov "exiled" Soroka to Ostrovki, an extremely picturesque village, though remote from the main estate.
For the same reason, he obstructed his in-depth studies with Venetsianov—after all, Venetsianov always brought up the idea of "freedom" for the talented artist. And what did "freedom" even mean? He'd propose, his daughter would accept, and then, lo and behold, they'd elope and marry against their father's wishes! Milyukov, a "progressive" landowner as he was, certainly couldn't allow such a thing. And he couldn't explain the situation to Venetsianov either. Therefore, under various pretexts, year after year, he "excommunicated" Grigory from his patron. Nevertheless, Venetsianov supplied his student with canvases and paints and repeatedly insisted on his presence at the school. Far too many hopes were pinned on him. And, apparently, Soroka was already confident that his patron's concerns would gradually prevail, that he would receive his "freedom." Indeed, right before his very eyes, Venetsianov secured the release of one of his classmates, young Irinarkh Vasiliev, who, at the artist's insistence, was "manumitted" by Milyukov in the summer of 1847. And almost immediately, he was sent to Italy for an internship! There was no longer any doubt; Venetsianov would achieve his goal. Soroka painted more and more, ever better, and his paintings delighted the masters. After all, all the talented serf artists were being ransomed—Tropinin, Kiprensky, even Taras Shevchenko… No matter, they'll ransom him too—it won't be long now!

But in the winter of 1847, all these hopes were dashed overnight. On December 4, while passing through the Milyukov village of Poddubye on the way to Tver, Venetsianov died. He died in a strange, almost unbelievable way: he leaned out of the carriage window and hit his head on a roadside post.
This terrible death also spelled the end of all Grigory's hopes. He stopped painting for a long time, retreating into silence. He took up ordinary peasant chores. Only on Milyukov's orders did he occasionally pick up a brush to paint family portraits, but he painted reluctantly, as if forced. Perhaps he only agreed so he could glimpse Lydia once more, but Milyukov did everything he could to prevent their meetings. Finally, after three years, the master demanded that his serf marry (he had chosen a wife for him himself) and take up a craft befitting him. Soroka obeyed unquestioningly. Soon afterward, a son was born (Lydia volunteered to be his godmother), and this "ecclesiastical" relationship seems to have completely appeased his father. However, Lydia herself soon remarried. And Soroka, at 33, was left with an unloved wife, amid the ruins of his life and craft.
Perhaps that's when he started drinking.
But it's true what they say: "You can't drink away talent." To make ends meet, Grigory, not particularly accustomed to peasant labor, turned to the common crafts of village artists: he began painting icons. He immediately became a popular iconographer. He painted walls and icons for churches in the Nikolo-Terebensky Monastery on the Mologa River, in the villages of Makovishche, Dubrovskoye, and even Poddubye. Money literally flowed to him like a river, and after a few years, he built a two-story house with a small room—a "studio" (the only two-story house in the village), where he even opened an art school for children. He himself had another son and a daughter. He now paid Milyukov a rent of 25 rubles a year. A considerable sum! But he had much more left over for himself and his family. Life, though not quite what he had dreamed of, was somehow improving. He even began painting again, though, as they say, they no longer had that former, free spirit. But formal liberation came to him along with all Russian serf-owners with the manifesto of February 19, 1861. There was no need for any "freedom" now. Freedom.
But what kind of freedom was that? Nearing 40, with three children, responsibilities, and a salary? And besides, his fellow villagers were demanding that he, as a literate man, now handle their affairs and the dispute with Milyukov.
The aging Nikolai Milyukov was no longer a "progressive lord." He hated his peasants, who had gained some measure of independence from him with a stroke of the imperial pen. Moreover, litigation with them began. As was the case throughout Russia, land allotments were at issue. Milyukov gave his serfs the worst, most worthless land, while jacking up the prices for the good land to unbearable levels, offering exorbitant ransom terms, practically a form of reverse serfdom. Of his 14 villages, 12 teetered on the brink of rebellion.
Soroka, an artist and icon painter, naturally couldn't care less about the land buyout. But he eagerly took it upon himself to help his fellow villagers: he filed complaints against Milyukov in courts and councils, drafted petitions, and generally acted as an activist, trying to inflict as much annoyance as possible on the man who had ruined his life. He probably succeeded. Because Milyukov himself filed a lawsuit against him, and in April 1864, Soroka was summoned for questioning and immediately sentenced to three days' arrest. As if in the old days of serfdom, the interrogators, unaware they were speaking with an artist, yelled at him and, although they released him "for health reasons," sparing him punishment, they still humiliated him in front of everyone. A slave, he had always been. And for Soroka, as it seemed then, there was only one path to freedom: a strong noose.
"The bailiff's investigation revealed that the deceased had taught himself drawing from childhood, and later, after marrying, had studied painting with various artists and supported his family through such labors. He frequently consumed alcohol. On April 5th, he was summoned to the Zaimishchenskoye Volost Administration, where he was sentenced to three days' arrest for rude behavior and spreading false rumors in the volost. However, due to illness, the elder released him. This circumstance, it must be assumed, was the cause of his death, because on the 10th, he was wandering pensively through the village, not drunk, and then..."
This is a story, almost like Leskov’s “The Toupee Artist”.
And the ending is equally sad. But Soroka's paintings, especially the early ones, were nonetheless fine, and some of them found their way into private collections and museums as early as the late 19th century. They were preserved haphazardly, without attribution or dating, like the paintings of "some" talented but virtually unknown serf artist. Soroka's true fame as a "social figure" came under Soviet rule, and not immediately. It took another half-century for his work to be properly understood. Only in 1974 (the year "Soviet serfdom" ended and collective farmers began receiving passports) was the first major exhibition of Soroka's work held in Leningrad and Moscow, and then he began to be spoken of as a great master ahead of his time. His biography, however, is still being pieced together, but it still contains more speculation than fact.
The only one monograph about Soroka The art historian Ostrovsky wrote this in 1991. Also Grigory. It seems his book has created a compelling picture, a coherent image of this talented and unfortunate man, the last serf artist, whom serfdom, as they say, caught up with and killed "at his last gasp." Or perhaps at his last gasp? Who knows. History in Russia tends to repeat itself. Perhaps that's why, having barely finished his monograph, Grigory Ostrovsky packed his bags and, before the book was even published, left for Israel forever in 1992.
He was not a serf, and this happened relatively easily for him.