Time to read: 9 minutes(s)

The last portrait of Admiral Makarov

War through the eyes of an artist, a naval commander, and scrap metal collectors

Author: Sergey Tashevsky

Stepan Osipovich Makarov

Admiral Stepan Osipovich Makarov is a legendary figure, practically a symbol of all that was best in the Russian Navy. He was an inventor, a scientist, a brave naval commander. And, undoubtedly, a Russian patriot who gave his life for the Tsar and the Fatherland. It was he who devised the idea of ​​dividing ships into compartments to make them unsinkable and created a "bandage" for patching breaches that could always be kept at the ready (and this bandage saved thousands of lives). It was Makarov who carried out the first successful torpedo attack in world history (in 1878, during the Russo-Turkish War, Russian sailors sank a gunboat with British torpedoes). He also devised special armor-piercing shells with caps, the so-called "Makarov caps," for combating cruisers (though no one produced them before the Japanese War; otherwise, they say, everything would have turned out differently at the Battle of Tsushima). He was also one of the initiators of using icebreakers to explore the Northern Sea Route, the designer of the icebreaker "Ermak," which was also built by the British (and its first captain on the expedition to Franz Josef Land). And so on, so on, so on... Basically, almost everything that is known about Makarov is his discoveries, inventions, achievements, and victories. Therefore, all his biographies are similar to one another, like the lives of saints replicated in many copies. They differ only in the admiral's remarkable qualities they emphasize: courage, ingenuity, hard work, dedication, resourcefulness, fidelity to moral principles... And yes, all this is true. But there is one problem: the living man is invisible through these panegyrics. As was said in Sytin's Military Encyclopedia, after Makarov’s death in the Port Arthur roadstead, “…all that was left of the admiral was his coat.”

Lev Lagorio, "The Sinking of the Turkish Steamship Intibah in the Batumi Roads by the Mine Boats of the Steamship Grand Duke Constantine on the Night of January 14, 1878."

There are no coherent memoirs of him, no diaries, no testimonies from his contemporaries. This is hardly surprising, however: while his contemporaries typically lived on land, Makarov spent most of his adult life at sea, moving from ship to ship. He even fell in love and proposed to his future wife without leaving the captain's bridge. And the ocean waves also became his grave. Only a few letters and biographical fragments remain, which nevertheless hint at Admiral Stepan Makarov's complex nature, as they say, "a restless soul." Especially in the final weeks of his life.

“There is a brutal war going on here, very dangerous for the Motherland, although beyond its borders, — he writes in a letter to his son from Port Arthur in the winter of 1904. "The Russian fleet, you know, has performed even greater wonders, but I sense—and you won't tell anyone yet—that we, including me, are being hindered—not by Admiral Togo, no, but by a nudge from the side, as if someone were sneaking up from behind. Who? I don't know! My soul is in turmoil, something I've never experienced before. I'm beginning to grasp something, but it's still vague. There's Vasily Vasilyevich Vereshchagin trying to explain something, but haltingly, like all artists and poets... That's how I feel, my son. But you're the only one who knows about it for now. Be silent, like a man should, but remember..."

What did he mean? What did he mean? The looming first Russian revolution, literally on the threshold? But what "I don't know" was there? The newspapers had long written about that. Or was it the feeling of "betrayal" that arose in Russian society after the end of the Japanese War? But Tsushima and the Battle of Mukden were still more than a year away, and plans for the military campaign were highly optimistic. Even the artist Vereshchagin, his old friend, with whom he lived in Port Arthur next door and went to sea together (the same Vereshchagin famous for his "Apotheosis of War" and other scandalous anti-war paintings), wrote to Nicholas II: "Allow your loyal subject to inform you that in your army, well-fed, contented, cheerful, and eagerly awaiting the opportunity to clash with the enemy who has so insulted you and Russia, there is a serious fear that you might take pity on him and conclude peace without punishing him completely. This is all they fear." So, surely, he is talking about something else, which Vereshchagin himself "explains incoherently."

Perhaps it's about the changing eras—and the fact that fewer and fewer people are willing to fight for the interests of the state. They no longer understand or appreciate war. For people of his generation, such things feel like a premonition, like rejection and loneliness. Although sometimes it seems as if acquaintances, both close and distant, are retreating into the bourgeoisie, into private life. What could be worse and more insignificant? After all, there's a war going on, a matter of state, a question of the country's greatness—and then... He writes to his wife, barely containing his irritation. And not because of the money. Because of her lack of understanding of the historical moment, because of the need to explain himself to her in bourgeois language:

"I telegraphed about giving you 5400 rubles. Having received so much money, the first thing you'll want to do is update your wardrobe, and so the money will quickly disappear... I beg you to be reasonable; we've already had many examples of being broke... Now it's inappropriate for you and Dina to dress up in big hats. You'll benefit much more if you behave more modestly."

Here in Port Arthur, Russia's fate is being decided. And they, in St. Petersburg, are thinking about fashion and only want money from him. And they, essentially, couldn't care less about this war.

The mood of the 19th century (and indeed all previous eras), when military valor was an absolute value, is fading. Vereshchagin, for whom war became both a curse and a narcotic, inspiring creativity, probably senses this in part. That's why, a few weeks after the declaration of war with Japan, he's already here, in Port Arthur (which the Japanese are at risk of blockading or capturing from the sea). That's why he will die along with Makarov on the battleship Petropavlovsk a few days later.

But yes, a new era is dawning. "Gallant wars" are a thing of the past. Now it's machine guns, heavy artillery, trenches, mud, and blood. Fewer and fewer people consider this valor. War is turning into a slaughter. Makarov himself wrote something along these lines more than once, sending objections to the Naval Department against the construction of enormous battleships: he claimed that these colossal "tin cans" could sink to the bottom after a single mine, taking with them not only the millions of rubles spent on their construction but also thousands of lives...

It was as if he had foreseen the future (though that's a bitter metaphor here). The armored cruiser Petropavlovsk, on which he and Vereshchagin would set sail on March 31, would strike a Japanese moored mine right in the Port Arthur roadstead, two kilometers from the port. In fact, right before the eyes of the entire city. And instantly, in less than two minutes, it would sink, taking nearly 600 people with it to a grave at sea. Including the artist, the admiral, and his entire staff...

Unknown author "The Death of the Petropavlovsk"

But for now, Makarov continues writing to his son, as if trying to argue with (maybe even outshout) this feeling within himself:

“…Some fool and coward might show up home practically in tears and say to his wife from the doorway: ‘Looks like they’re sending you off to war. Is it worth it?’ What would a loving mother, wife, or sister say? ‘You’ll die for nothing. You’re our only one. Just get out of it somehow.’ Women know what to expect. But a real man should show up home cheerful and say: ‘Well, darling, get me ready for the journey. There’s some fun to be had here at the border.’ She’ll cry, get you ready, and calm down, trusting in God’s will. I embrace you, my son. Study hard. Help your mother and sister. Fear God, serve the Tsar.”

What's it like to read this now, when yet another "funny affair on the border" is in its fourth year? It's also a war "very dangerous for the Motherland, even beyond its borders." However, even at the beginning of the 20th century, for many, like Leo Tolstoy, the war all clear"War again. Again unnecessary, unprovoked suffering, again lies, again the general stupefaction and brutalization of people."

But my God, how much peaceful work could and should still be done! The Northern Sea Route, the "lower" currents of the Bosphorus, which Makarov discovered but didn't have time to properly study, and hydrological research in the La Pérouse Strait...

But no. From the first days of the war, Makarov felt like the one left in charge. He knew, after all, that Port Arthur wasn't ready for defense. He wrote reports, demanded that action be taken... The response was indifferent silence. They said there wouldn't be a war. The Japanese wouldn't dare attack Russia. "They'll send me there when things get really bad for us," Makarov bitterly tells an acquaintance. And indeed, immediately after the attack on Port Arthur, he is appointed there. As commander of the Pacific Squadron.

And now, at the end of March 1904, he was preparing to set out to sea. In pursuit of Japanese cruisers. He was sitting in the wardroom, studying a map. Across from him was Vereshchagin, sketching his portrait. And, as if in a tragic perspective, "observer after observer," they were both being painted by another artist, Makarov's longtime friend, Yevgeny Stolitsa. Not a great master. But his portrait, painted four days before the sinking of the Petropavlovsk, was his last. And we know what Makarov and Vereshchagin looked like on the eve of their deaths.

Evgeny Stolitsa, "Vice-Admiral S.O. Makarov and battle artist V.V. Vereshchagin in the cabin of the battleship Petropavlovsk in 1904"

The two men in the wardroom, their beards thick, seemed to have sworn some sort of military Old Believers' vow. "Do what you must, and come what may." And in four days, not a trace of them would remain. Only a greatcoat with admiral's shoulder straps, which would be fished out of the cold water at the site of the cruiser's demise.

In a few years, the Japanese businessmen who bought the Petropavlovsk's hull will be preoccupied with finding the ship's treasury. The bodies discovered on board in 1913 will be buried in a mass grave. Only six bodies, however. Unrecognizable. There's no genetic analysis yet, and no one will even remember the grave's location. And then the Petropavlovsk, along with all its dead sailors, will disappear.

This became clear in the early 2000s, when divers from the Pacific Fleet's Iskra center began searching for it. They found only a few fragments of armor plates. The rest, it seems, was secretly raised by the Japanese in 1943 and taken away for scrap.