The first and last congress of Buddhists of the USSR
Author: Andrey Filimonov

From January 20 to 27, 1927, the First Congress of Buddhists of the USSR was held in Moscow. Looking ahead, it should be noted that it was the last. Lamas from Buryatia and Kalmykia, as well as representatives of the People's Commissariat of Foreign Affairs and the OGPU, participated in the congress. It was a remarkable time—the 1920s, the New Economic Policy (NEP)—when the godless regime not only tolerated religion but also entered into alliances with various faiths to achieve its political goals. In Buddhism, as in Orthodoxy, a Renovationist movement emerged that sought to adapt to Soviet ideology, declaring that Buddha's teachings were not religion, but rather science. As for the doctrine of emptiness, it can be understood in the spirit of modern physics, which splits the atom until matter completely disappears.
What won't you say to survive?
The Chekists and Buddhists established a dialogue because both sides had their own interests. The Buddhist sangha hoped, through compromise, to preserve temples and other religious sites from destruction and confiscation. Meanwhile, the secret services hoped to use Buddhism to cover their intelligence activities in Tibet, China, Korea, and other Far Eastern states, where the Comintern planned to soon establish Soviet power. From the perspective of the OGPU and the Comintern, things were going well in the Far East: the Civil War was raging in China, and Comrade Mao Zedong and his communist comrades already controlled several regions of the country.

At the same time, contacts were being established between the Council of People's Commissars and the Tibetan government. In the summer of 1926, Nicholas Roerich arrived from there. In Moscow, he was personally received by the People's Commissar for Foreign Affairs, Chicherin, to whom the artist presented a box of "sacred Himalayan soil" for Lenin's mausoleum and a message from the "mahatmas"—the secret "rulers of the world" from Shambhala, located somewhere in the Himalayas. The message pompously praised the October Revolution and promised the Bolsheviks "cosmic support" in the name of "Asian unity." Interestingly, Roerich himself first heard about Shambhala from the famous Khambo Lamas Agvan Dorzhiev, who served as Tibet's representative in the Russian Empire from 1901 and, after the Bolsheviks came to power, led the renovationist movement in Russian Buddhism.

As one of the teachers of the 13th Dalai Lama, he had long been involved in the grand political game. As early as 1904, when British troops entered Tibet and the Dalai Lama fled Lhasa for Mongolia, Dorjiev negotiated His Holiness's possible relocation to Russia.

The "Yellow Russia" party—advocates of creating Russian puppet states from Tibet to Korea—was highly influential at the tsarist court. The Dalai Lama's presence in St. Petersburg (or Buryatia) could have been a powerful trump card in this game. But the Russian Empire was already short of resources, suffering defeat at the hands of Japan, and was unwilling to antagonize either the British or the Chinese government. The negotiations came to nothing.
However, this is only one episode in the extraordinary biography of Agvan Dorzhiev. Born into a humble Buryat family, he established connections with rulers of Asia and Europe, built a Buddhist temple in St. Petersburg, and held a "Buddhist mass" in Paris.
Buddhist Mass in Paris
On June 27, 1898, an event was taking place at the Paris Museum of Asian Arts, a gathering many wanted to attend, but only a select few were admitted. By midday, the museum library was filled with about 200 people, including scholars, journalists, politicians, and socialites. Georges Clemenceau, a member of parliament and future Prime Minister of France, was there. Parisians were about to witness a "Buddhist mass," as the newspapers dubbed the event. Poet Innokenty Annensky was among the lucky few to attend the third Buddhist "service" in European history (another misnomer for the ceremony conducted by Dorzhiev).
The basalt Mongol performed the sacred rite,
And the mysterious verb slowly melted away
In a capriciously created temple in the middle of a museum…
Annensky wrote in the poem “Buddhist Mass in Paris.”
During the ceremony, the lama used ritual musical instruments—a bell and a damaru (prayer drum), which, combined with the low-throated chanting of Tibetan mantras, produced a hypnotic effect. Even the ladies of the house stopped whispering as the monk sat on the throne with a serene expression. Complete silence reigned in the hall.
A quarter of a century later, the "basalt Mongol" himself would recall this event when, at the request of orientalist Fyodor Shcherbatsky, he described his life in verse in the Old Mongolian language:
I was approached with a request to perform a prayer possessing the perfect wisdom of Clemenceau and many others. They wished for the Supreme Savior to offer holy sacrifices, ask for mercy, protection and patronage for their living souls. Agvan Dorzhiev. Entertaining Notes
He was one of the most unusual diplomats of the turn of the 19th and 20th centuries. Dorzhiev began as a student at a Transbaikal datsan and took Buddhist vows early (in his autobiographical poem, Dorzhiev emphasizes that at the age of 14, he "forever gave up vodka and tobacco"). He then embarked on a "great study" in Central Asia: via Mongolia and the Himalayas, he reached Tibet, studied for many years at the largest monastic universities, and became part of the inner circle of the 13th Dalai Lama.
When the hope of the living, Dalai Lama Gegen, celebrated my thirteenth birthday, I was among those who taught him the complete teachings of the Tsannid, and accompanied him for ten years without interruption. Agvan Dorzhiev. Entertaining Notes
In Lhasa, Dorjiev found favor not only as a theological scholar but also as a figure "from outside" the Tibetan world: a subject of the Russian Empire, speaking several languages and understanding European politics. During the "Great Game" between Britain and Russia, he effectively became Tibet's intermediary—going on missions, establishing contacts in St. Petersburg, advocating for Russian patronage of Buddhist Tibet, and simultaneously working on "Buddhist infrastructure" within the empire itself, including overcoming the resistance of the Russian Orthodox Church, which was displeased with the construction of the St. Petersburg datsan.

…when its construction began soon (1909), all these long-haired weirdos they began to call upon the king again and again: “If this filthy temple is built on our land, our faith will decline. It is therefore necessary to issue the strictest decree. on its prohibition and destruction." The king replied that he already permitted its construction. Then the malicious long-haired priests began to gather in Kazan, Irkutsk and Kyiv и look for ways, how to immediately expel and send them away from Russia the malicious Buddhist madman Dorzhiev... Agvan Dorzhiev. Entertaining Notes
Refusal of reincarnation
In the European press, he was often referred to as the "Tibetan ambassador," although his status was more that of a confidant and negotiator for the Dalai Lama, combining religious authority with political pragmatism. In the East, he was valued for his ability to communicate with Europeans, who all looked the same to Tibetans. In his memoirs, Dorzhiev writes that he had great difficulty explaining to the Dalai Lama's officials that Russia and England were different countries. In the West, he was perceived as a plenipotentiary emissary, almost a representative of the Buddha on earth. It is therefore unsurprising that enlightened Bolsheviks like Chicherin and Lunacharsky heeded Dorzhiev's opinions and considered him an authoritative expert on Eastern policy.
For his part, the Khambo Lama played along with the enlightened Bolsheviks. In the early 1920s, Dorzhiev, along with other Buddhist leaders in Buryatia, attempted to demonstrate the fundamental similarity between the tenets of Buddhism and communism. His supporters called themselves modernizers (renovationists) and interpreted Buddhism as an atheistic doctrine.

The first congress of Soviet Buddhists in January 1927 cemented the victory of Renovationism and its reforms over the conservatives. The Renovationists agreed to a ban on sending children to monasteries, which was unacceptable to the conservatives. Traditionally, children from Buddhist families entered monasteries as if they were going to a boarding school—starting at age seven and spending 10 to 12 years there, receiving an education and training, but not necessarily becoming monks. Now, by agreement with the Soviet government, entry into a Buddhist monastery in the USSR was restricted to those aged 18 and over.
The congress also declared that the highest lamas of Buryatia and Kalmykia would no longer be reincarnated after death. Thus, the OGPU succeeded in gaining control over even the transmigration of souls.
In his efforts to defend Buddhist teachings against the backdrop of state anti-religious policies, Dorzhiev used the most unexpected methods, claiming that Lenin, Zinoviev, and other Bolsheviks were “spontaneous Buddhists,” and that the Buddhist faith would one day be accepted throughout the Soviet Union on par with the teachings of Marx and Engels.
A seasoned diplomat with over thirty years of experience, Dorzhiev knew that there are no "objective truths" in politics—only conventions dictated by expediency. And if he could convince Stalin and Trotsky of the benefits of an alliance between the Bolsheviks and Buddhists, then Soviet children would learn the mantra "Buddha's teaching is omnipotent because it is true" in school.
Moreover, Dorzhiev was clearly successful in his game with the Soviet authorities. The Leningrad datsan became a separate stage in this political spectacle. In June 1926, Dorzhiev secured the temple complex and its annexes as the common property of "Tibet and Mongolia," with the Mongolian side assuming responsibility for the maintenance and repair of the buildings. The complex's purpose was defined as cultural—to strengthen ties between the Buddhist East and the USSR. Thus, an attempt was made to "reformat" the datsan, granting it the relatively secure status of a "cultural center" and scientific site. At the same time, government officials were not allowed to enter the premises, at least not without an invitation or approval "from the very top." The temple complex, like embassies, enjoyed a special extraterritorial status.
To build on his successes, Dorzhiev plans to hold the "first international Buddhist exhibition" in the USSR. He is writing a speech to deliver at the opening. The rhetoric is aimed at a Marxist ear: Buddha, Dorzhiev asserts, taught the absence of a creator God and instead proposed the idea of an infinite chain of cause and effect. This means that the world is infinite in time and space and was never created; nothing arises from nothing, what exists does not vanish without a trace, everything is in constant change.
Dorzhiev emphasizes that in Europe, it became possible to discuss such things only after the development of the exact sciences and the victory over "religious obscurantism." Therefore, Buddhism should be perceived as an "advanced teaching"—almost a science—and certainly not as "backward superstition."
Against this backdrop, the January 1927 Moscow Buddhist Congress appears to be a very serious attempt to formalize a compromise with the authorities. Delegates were inspired by the establishment of the Institute of Buddhist Culture at the Academy of Sciences, under the direction of F. I. Shcherbatskoy; the congress sent the academicians their gratitude and hope for a "correct understanding" of Buddhism in the country.
"The enemy is cunning"
However, it quickly became clear that this was the last year of unfulfilled hopes. The Buddhist exhibition remained a project. And the overall situation changed dramatically after Trotsky attempted to overthrow Stalin in November 1927. But Stalin prevailed, and Trotsky went into exile, initially to Alma-Ata. He would still have 13 years before he encountered an ice axe.
Henceforth, dual power in the Politburo was over. Having removed his main rival from the scene and intimidated Bukharin and other oppositionists, Stalin decided to rule the tarantass of Russian history single-handedly.
It turned out that the idea of a compromise with the church belonged to the defeated side (probably Bukharin). For the victor, it was all too subtle and unnecessary.
Stalin ridiculed the "absurd theory of the identity of communist and Buddhist doctrine." After which, the party press furiously attacked the "renovationists," including Dorzhiev and his associates.
In the spring of 1929, the Buryat-Mongolskaya Pravda newspaper published an article entitled “The enemy is being cunning – we must expose him to the masses”:
"A striking example of adaptation to modernity is the identification of the teachings of Marx and Lenin with those of Buddha and Christianity. Enemies are straining every effort and resource to prove that Buddha and Christ were the most ardent communists, orthodox Marxists, and the founders of agricultural collectivization, etc."

At this time, 75-year-old Dorzhiev was in Berlin, overseeing the casting of a large bronze statue of Buddha for the main altar of the Leningrad datsan. He had agreed to take part in a "debate" between believers and atheists organized by the local party committee in Verkhneudinsk (now Ulan-Ude). A scholar of the Buddhist canon, a diplomat, and a polyglot fluent in half a dozen languages, he returned to Buryatia to endure the boorish attacks of illiterate Komsomol members, who called the lamas "depraved priests" and "enemies of socialism"—the mildest of epithets. This public harassment had nothing to do with the debate.
Lama Dorzhiev understands that the time for diplomacy has clearly passed, and under Stalin's collectivization, renovationism has lost all meaning. The very possibility of negotiating with the authorities, who now demand not verbal submission but the complete elimination of all autonomous entities, including independent monasteries and any forms of non-Marxist education, is disappearing.
Since 1930, Sagan Sar, the lunar new year, and all religious holidays have been officially abolished in Buryatia and Kalmykia. To prevent Dorzhiev from "rocking the boat" by exploiting his authority, he is "invited" to Moscow and politely "explained" that he is "exceeding his diplomatic authority" as a representative of Mongolia and Tibet, allegedly "inciting the population of Buryatia against the Soviet state." After this, he is "suggested" that he establish permanent residence in Leningrad, effectively restricting his travel within the country.
Meanwhile, the Buryatia authorities are taking on a “communist obligation” to close 20 datsans every year.
At first, this powerful anti-religious initiative falters. It is said that Buddhists have begun actively joining "unions of atheists" and sabotaging their activities. But even such a cunning game cannot last long.
After Kirov's assassination in December 1934, a real reign of terror began. The "vegetarian two-room apartments" became a thing of the past. Denunciations began flying against both Buddhists and Orientalists—the NKVD was preparing a major case against "Japanese spies."
Buryats and Kalmyks, dissatisfied with the destruction of monasteries, are threatened with the threat that "those who speak out" will follow the dispossessed into exile. Afterwards, government officials collect signatures from workers demanding the closure of these "hotbeds of religious intoxication."
A side effect of this policy is an increase in mortality, since in Buryatia, for example, workers have virtually no treatment other than from lama doctors. But this doesn't particularly worry the authorities. If anything happens, they can always open another "sabotage case."
Many datsans aren't simply closed—they're demolished, along with their libraries and relics. And it's often not the "visiting crew" who do this, but local youth, for whom destruction becomes a pastime.
Letters from Orientalists at the Academy of Sciences defending the "museum value" of Buddhist books, statues, and ritual utensils have frankly irritated the Party leadership: "You'll first ask to preserve the datsan as a museum, and then you'll want to preserve the lamas." The "museum" argument no longer works. The NKVD will "preserve" the lamas in the camps—those who aren't executed under the "Japanese spy" quota.
Escape from Soviet power into nirvana
When hope fades, people clutch at straws. Especially since Stalin not only pumped up the repressive apparatus but also fooled everyone with the new USSR Constitution, adopted in December 1936.
The provision regarding discrimination against the clergy with regard to electoral rights is being removed from the text of the "fundamental law." This is causing enthusiasm among the clergy—for example, at the Gusinoozersky Datsan, lamas are "underground" discussing the Constitution.
A census conducted in early 1937 revealed a high percentage of believers in the country. People said the purpose of the census was to "collect information about believers," and they hoped that "if the census revealed a large number of them," the authorities would allow churches to reopen.
Far away in the Kremlin, Stalin laughed at this naive logic. He declared 1937 the first year of the "godless five-year plan," by the end of which not a single functioning church or free "clergyman" would remain in the country.

Realizing where things were heading and recognizing his own impotence, Dorzhiev wrote a will in late 1936 in the form of a letter to his grandnephew, Sanja Dylykov, then a graduate student at the Institute of Oriental Studies. The veteran diplomat transferred his status as "Tibet's representative to the USSR" to the young scholar, thereby saving Dylykov from arrest.
The NKVD has already planned the destruction of the Leningrad datsan. The Chekists have long since ignored the extraterritoriality of the "representation of Mongolia and Tibet": three years ago, they already carried out arrests there. But now they are talking about its complete liquidation.
In August 1937, "Black Marias" arrived at the house next to the datsan where the remaining free lamas lived. The residents of the "Lama Dormitory" on Staroderevenskaya Street (now Primorsky Prospekt) were herded into black cars.
This was the first wave. The remaining 12 employees of the "Mongolian-Tibetan Mission" were taken in September. Almost all were executed, except for one woman, who was sentenced to 10 years in a labor camp.
Throughout the arrests in Leningrad, Dorzhiev lived in his house in the suburban village of Olgino, along with a lama from Transbaikalia who served him. He had no one else left—no loved ones (except Dylykov, who could do nothing to help) and no potential protectors. The enlightened Bolsheviks had faded from the political scene. Professor Oldenburg, who had rescued Lama Dorzhiev from the Cheka in 1918, had died several years earlier. The lama felt it was time for him to depart from samsara, too.
The final point in his life was Atsagatsky Arshan in Buryatia, where Dorzhiev had his "residence"—a modest wooden house—where he was arrested on November 13, 1937. The Khambo Lama was charged with the standard set of Article 58 charges: "treason," "armed uprising," "terrorist acts," and "organizing counterrevolutionary crimes." His only interrogation took place on November 26. Investigator Nikolaev read all this ritual nonsense to the aged Dorzhiev, who allegedly immediately confessed to being one of the leaders of the "Pan-Mongolian rebel terrorist organization" and claimed to have hated the Soviet regime for closing monasteries and "attacking religion." The interrogation report then ends with a note, "due to illness," written in different ink.

Two months later, Agvan Dorzhiev died in the prison hospital "of cardiac arrest"—a diagnosis that prison doctors were not shy about making under Stalin. Rumors circulated that the lama might have been quietly murdered in the hospital. But many in Buryatia believed neither the Khambo Lama's death to be violent nor natural. And to this day countsthat he did not die, but “went into Nirvana” away from Soviet power.
Whatever the true circumstances of his death, Dorzhiev lived to be 84 years old—exactly the same age as the great teacher Buddha. On an internet forum of the Buryat people being discussed the question of searching for the next reincarnation of Agvan Dorzhiev.
"I once attended a conversation between officials of the foundation named after him about the need to find his (Dorzhiev's) incarnation. The initiative was met with humor, I thought. Apparently, there are khubilgans in Buryatia, although the BTSR (Buddhist Traditional Sangha of Russia) doesn't approve of this," writes a forum participant.
Apparently, the decisions of the January congress of 1927, which abolished the tradition of reincarnated khubilgans, are still relevant for Russian Buddhism.