Will it work or not? Some officials and Z-bloggers are unhappy with the Telegram block.
Starting April 1, authorities promise to completely block Telegram; in many regions, it doesn't work without a VPN. Meanwhile, the Human Rights Council noted, that the messenger's management will "highly likely" comply with the authorities' demands. What are opponents of the blocking saying in the days leading up to it?
— State Duma deputy from the New People party Vladimir Plyakin saidHe said the blockades would still be circumvented, but citizens would have to use "questionable tools." He compared this to a crackdown on dissent.
"Back then, they also banned books, jokes, songs, and "wrong" thoughts... History teaches us that such methods ultimately fail, but they also manage to create a bunch of unnecessary problems and risks for everyone."
— Krasnoyarsk City Duma deputy from the Communist Party of the Russian Federation Alexander Safronov считаетthat without Telegram, Russia will be left without an instrument of “soft power of the Russian world” and will lose its “window to the world.”
"This will primarily harm Russian citizens and the Russian state. The platform has long been Russia's window to the world. Our means of influence, a soft power for the Russian world."
— State Duma deputy from the Communist Party of the Russian Federation Sergey Obukhov acted with a bill to ban blocking social media. He reminded citizens of their constitutional rights.
"We live in an information society. When you impose restrictions on communications, and society can't live without them, that's a problem... 'Whitelists' are like a rationing system for soap and tobacco, but for the modern conditions of a digital society."
— Z-blogger Sergey Kolyasnikov on his channel Zergulio acted against blocking, because, in his opinion, “a huge number of horizontal connections will die,” and the Russian point of view will disappear from the global agenda.
"Spend tens of billions of rubles, embitter and turn 100+ million people against the government, force millions of people onto VPNs and proxies... and all for a 15% reduction in reach. There's even a new saying. 'Before, I was too lazy to turn on a VPN for Instagram, now I'm too lazy to turn it off for MAX.'"