Time to read: 12 minutes(s)

The Empire from the carriage window

Why did Nicholas I send his son to Siberia?

Author: Andrey Filimonov

In June 1837, an unprecedented event in the history of the Russian Empire occurred. The heir to the throne, Grand Duke Alexander Nikolaevich, visited Siberia. The trip had been the idea of ​​his father, Nicholas I, and was quite extravagant. Previously, no Muscovite tsar had ever considered sending their offspring to Siberia, even as a form of punishment. Tsarevich Dmitry was exiled to Uglich, and Tsarevich Alexei was held in the Peter and Paul Fortress. But Siberia? Unthinkable!

Among other regalia, the Romanovs bore the title of Tsars of Siberia, however, they had neither the time nor the desire to personally visit “places not so remote.”

Nicholas I was the first to come to the conclusion that life could no longer be as it was. In the 18th century, German scholars, returning from distant travels, brought the Russian sovereigns detailed descriptions of their possessions in the east and north. Miller, Pallas, Messerschmidt, and other traveling academics carried out enormous research under Peter and Catherine. But back then, Siberia was almost completely unexplored territory, like another planet, and it was necessary to at least roughly determine what was happening there.

By the 19s, information had been gathered, and the state's mission had changed. Nicholas wanted to "sew" the entire empire into a single style: "Orthodoxy. Autocracy. Nationality."

Wedding with Russia

Nicholas I's primary concern was strengthening the prestige of his government. The Russian throne had been tottering too often over the past hundred years due to palace conspiracies and coups. The threat of rebellion was too great. At least, that's how it seemed to Nicholas, who ascended the throne in a blood-stained uniform on Senate Square. This was because not only the Decembrists but also the autocrats were terribly disconnected from the people. With the exception of those living in the capital, the vast majority of the population had never seen their monarch in person and easily mistook impostors like Yemelyan Pugachev and other miraculously saved "Peter IIIs" for the true tsar.

The heir's journey across Russia in 1837 was part of a grand campaign to rebrand the image of the House of Romanov. Subjects were expected to see the future tsar with their own eyes and love him as their own.

Alexander had two tasks to accomplish on this business trip: 1) to show himself; 2) to see people.

Nicholas formulated the main goal of the journey in the “General Instructions” written especially for this purpose: “… To get to know Russia as much as possible, and to allow oneself to be seen by future subjects.”

It was further specified that Alexander should maintain a polite distance from the provincial nobility and, on the contrary, demonstrate a relaxed, welcoming attention to the representatives of the democratic classes – the merchants and the peasantry.

Essentially, it was a visit to the people. Admittedly, it was organized in the highest style—accompanied by an entourage, gendarmes, doctors, bakers, and other necessary personnel. Concerned that his son might be poisoned by some nasty thing at a provincial dinner, Nicholas forbade Alexander from accepting dinner invitations from anyone except Prince Sergei Golitsyn, whose cuisine met the VIP standards of the time.

Having protected his offspring from all sides and surrounded him with a triple ring of guards, Nicholas nonetheless demanded that Alexander "learn the truth" during this trip. At his farewell audience, the emperor declared to the heir's retinue: "I want the Grand Duke... to see things as they are, and not poetically. The Grand Duke must know Russia as it really is."

The Tsarevich's most famous companion on this journey was his mentor, the poet Vasily Zhukovsky, who arrived late for the imperial briefing and, contrary to the Tsar's wishes, in the best traditions of Romanticism, declared his protégé's journey a "wedding with Russia." Alexander's itinerary included 30 provinces, each like a bride about to be crowned. This was precisely the poetic vision the Emperor feared.

Playing "The Inspector General"

Alexander and his entourage entered Siberia on May 31, 1837. Yuryevich, a member of the heir's retinue, described the day as follows:

"Today at 4 o'clock in the afternoon, having climbed the highest point of the Ural Mountains (near Reshety station, 30 versts from Yekaterinburg), on the border between Europe and Asia, my companion K.I. Arsenyev and I ordered a glass of wine, and we drank to the health of our families, each of us, for all we had left behind in Europe. We looked once more at Europe, each sighed to ourselves, and a minute later it was already beyond the mountains."

None of the 19-year-old Tsarevich's companions had ever been to Siberia before. Everyone felt out of place. How would they be greeted by this land of fantastic riches and wild peoples, located beyond the Urals?

The future ruler of a multinational empire gazed upon his Asian subjects with the wide-eyed amazement of a European caught among barbarians. In letters to his father, he described a Vogul (Mansi) woman he saw in Tobolsk as "the most hideous monster, small, black, with a flat face, two slits instead of eyes—in a word, a beast, not a human being..." The Bashkirs, for him, were "all hideous monsters," and the Kyrgyz sultans devoured horsemeat at dinner "like ghouls." It seemed the heir was gradually beginning to understand what it meant to be the "Tsar of Siberia."

If the representatives of the indigenous peoples were completely incomprehensible creatures from a scary fairy tale for him, then the provincial officials and ordinary people, on the contrary, seemed like well-known characters - thanks to Gogol.

The literary coda to Alexander's journey was "The Government Inspector," a fashionable play that had premiered in St. Petersburg the previous year. Vasily Zhukovsky had pushed hard to promote his younger friend's comedy and persuaded Nicholas to allow its production. Nicholas granted his consent and didn't regret it. He was extremely pleased with the play. At the premiere, the emperor laughed a lot, applauded, and reportedly even said, "Everyone got it in this play. But I got it the most."

"The Government Inspector" showed Nicholas a comical portrait of provincial Russia, where the incognito from the capital provokes an instinctive fear of exposure in the local administration. The heir's journey across Russia became a traveling production of Gogol's great play: the provinces displayed official admiration, but privately trembled over whether the tsarevich would like the hastily erected facades. The heir, meanwhile, wrote to his father with irony about what he had seen.

From Verkhniy Volochok, Alexander wrote: “The local mayor reminded us of the mayor from The Inspector General with his tournure.

Nikolai answered: “You will see not one, but many similar people to those in The Inspector General, but be careful and do not show in public that you find them funny; some are funny in appearance, but good in other important qualities; you must be extremely careful in this.”

A week later, Alexander again describes a real person, as a character from "The Inspector General." He's referring to the son of the landowner Zhadovskaya, with whom the heir spent the night:

"Her son, a retired officer, entertained us. He must be a remarkable eccentric, and reminded me of Pyotr Ivanovich Bobchinsky. Like him, he asked only for the favor of letting You know that I had spent the night in his house. But even on this occasion, I remembered Your instruction, dear Papa, not to show others what seemed ridiculous."

Nikolai replies with obvious pleasure: “I laughed when I read the scene with Bobchinsky, he must be a good goose; but thank you for teaching me not to show my laughter in front of others.”

Father and son amused themselves by imagining the ignorant provincials as Gogol's characters, unaware that their favorite author had another play, unpublished at the time. Gogol wrote "The Marriage" in 1835, but it wasn't published until 1842.

This comedy was no less fitting for the heir's journey than "The Government Inspector." Throughout the journey, its participants felt a disproportion between the pompous claim to "marry Russia" and the everyday awkwardness of the process itself. It was a Gogol-esque wedding procession, in which the groom is shown the bride piecemeal: province by province, city by city...

The many faces of the "bride" are the funniest thing about this "groom's" journey. It's tempting to reframe Agafya Tikhonovna's "thoughts": It's so hard to decide, so hard to tell! If only we could take the Tobolsk expanse and the Perm factories, and add to them the courtesy of Yaroslavl, the antiquity of Kostroma, the diversity of Kazan, the fertility of Taurida, the vastness of the Orenburg steppe, the aristocracy of Moscow, and the chic of St. Petersburg—then Russia would be truly remarkable. But in one province, all space and no water; in another, factories and billowing smoke; in a third, the people are hard-working, and the officials are like those from "The Government Inspector"; in a fourth, they greet you with delight, but outside the gates, there's poverty and dust. It would be good if only the best qualities were found in the bride: wealth, meekness, order, and vivacity, and without unnecessary petitions, without broken roads, without mayors and bobchinskys. Then the wedding wouldn't be scary.

The heir was probably scared, although he didn’t mention it in his letters to his father.

Siberia in Zhukovsky's diary

Even if Vasily Zhukovsky had some romantic notions of a mystical wedding before leaving St. Petersburg, they vanished during the journey. It's one thing to imagine a literary map of Russia while sitting in your study, and quite another to trudge day after day along dreadful roads in an uncomfortable carriage, and at night to battle merciless provincial bedbugs. Perhaps that's why Vasily Andreyevich's Siberian diary is written in a dry and matter-of-fact tone. Romanticism doesn't survive the harsh conditions of everyday life.

The heir's retinue arrived in Siberia from the Ural industrial centers of Yekaterinburg, Nevyansk, and Tagil; on May 31, 1837, the route passed through Tyumen to Tobolsk. Zhukovsky describes Tyumen without enthusiasm: "a long city on the banks of the Tura River," rain, a meeting, a crowd, Bukharans; a poor city, with only a few stone houses for the common people, and government offices housed in an inn. Tobolsk, in his account, is also a "poor city": the lower part is poor, the upper part suffers from a lack of water, and cold coastal winds blow. Fifteen churches, a bishop's residence, and wooden pavements are noted.  

In Tobolsk, Zhukovsky managed to sketch the site of Yermak's death and meet with Pyotr Yershov, the author of "The Little Humpbacked Horse," who had previously visited Zhukovsky at his literary Saturdays in St. Petersburg. They discussed Pushkin's death—the most important event of that year.

The return journey from Siberia to the west was supposed to pass through Yalutorovsk, where exiled Decembrists lived, including Ivan Yakushkin, a close associate of Zhukovsky. A meeting was planned, but was disrupted by an accident: Zhukovsky's coachman hit a woman. The poet tended to the injured woman, drove her to the nearest station, and tried to get help, which resulted in him missing the grand ducal train. As a result, he hesitated to linger in Yalutorovsk and later agonized over himself: "I'm so frustrated that I didn't stop in Yalutorovsk." In a letter to the empress, he wrote that he had missed the opportunity to console the "poor exiles," and that this opportunity would never return.

But in Kurgan, on June 6, Trinity Sunday, a meeting with the Decembrists did take place. The heir was housed across from Mikhail Naryshkin's house; Zhukovsky recorded the house's furnishings in detail: a living room with two brick stoves, a piano, paintings—the head of Belisarius, the head of the Madonna, and family portraits above the sofa in the study. Even in distant exile, the Decembrists maintained an educated, cultured way of life, previously unthinkable in these parts.

According to the memoirs of Decembrist Baron Andrei Rosen, Zhukovsky told him: "Rest assured, I will present everything to His Highness... wherever he can do some good, he will do it willingly." Rosen also recalled that after their meeting, Zhukovsky "repeatedly interceded" for the Tsarevich on behalf of the Decembrists and wrote to them: "Rest assured, we will not cease to be your old troublemakers."  

After Kurgan, the Decembrist issue became Zhukovsky's most pressing concern. En route to Zlatoust, he sent Nicholas a petition requesting relief for their plight. The Tsar's reply arrived quickly, and on June 23rd, in Simbirsk, Zhukovsky learned that several Decembrists from Tobolsk Governorate were being permitted to enlist as privates in the Caucasus Corps. Signing the decree, Nicholas allegedly said, "The route to Russia for these gentlemen leads through the Caucasus."

Immediately after this, the Decembrists Naryshkin, Nazimov, Lorer, and Likharev were sent to the Caucasus via Kazan and Rostov-on-Don. Baron Rosen, due to a leg ailment, was allowed to serve in the Caucasian Line Battalion in quiet Kislovodsk.

To ease the plight of those whom Nicholas refused to release from Siberian exile, Zhukovsky developed a separate project—to grant the Decembrists freedom within Siberia. He wrote:

“Siberia needs people to be developed for enlightenment: will it forever be a desert or a den of robbers, meek from powerlessness?

But Providence, through one side's misfortune, seeks to bestow good on the other. These people, capable of laying the foundations of social education in the depths of Siberia, now exist there, and in great numbers. It is only necessary to take advantage of them early, before their moral strength is shattered by misfortune. Until now, misfortune has been their teacher; soon it may become their killer. Now they are still human; soon they will be breathing corpses.

Let the place of exile be turned into a homeland for them with all the benefits that every homeland offers to its children, and they will be resurrected.” — wrote Vasily Andreevich.

However, he never brought himself to share these thoughts with the emperor. The heir's journey ended, and a "Chronicle of Delight" was published, in which officials shared their joy at meeting the heir. Nicholas considered the "wedding with Russia" project a success. And he went abroad to rest. For the next few years, he wanted to hear nothing more about Siberia or the Decembrists.