Meteorite or comet: what exploded near Podkamennaya Tunguska?
June 30 is International Asteroid Day. It was on this day, 118 years ago, that the Tunguska meteorite impact occurred—the largest ever observed collision between Earth and a celestial body, witnessed by human eyes.
We've collected scientific—and parascientific—theories about what it was.
1. Asteroids Asteroids are celestial bodies orbiting the Sun in orbits similar to those of planets. Asteroids are typically found in the region between Mars and Jupiter, forming the so-called asteroid belt. They are composed primarily of rock and metal and can range in size from a few meters to hundreds of kilometers in diameter.
Meteorites These are fragments of asteroids or comets that penetrate the Earth's atmosphere from outer space and reach its surface. Upon entering the atmosphere, they heat up and begin to glow, forming a meteor or "shooting star."
2. On the morning of June 30, 1908, at around 7:15 a.m. local time, a large celestial body exploded in the atmosphere over the Podkamennaya Tunguska River basin in Central Siberia. Local reindeer herders reported seeing a fireball leaving a trail of smoke, followed by a flash brighter than the sun, and then a powerful explosion. Large forest fires and fallen trees were also reported for many kilometers from the epicenter. The shock wave was felt hundreds of kilometers away, and seismographs recorded vibrations worldwide.
3. “Suddenly, the sky split in two in the north, and a fire appeared high and wide above the forest, engulfing the entire northern sky. At that moment, I felt so hot, as if my shirt had caught fire. I wanted to rip it open and throw it off, but the sky slammed shut, and there was a powerful blow. I was thrown three fathoms off the porch. After the blow, there was a thud, as if stones were falling from the sky or cannons were firing. The earth trembled, and as I lay on the ground, I pressed my head down, afraid that the stones would crush my skull. At that moment, when the sky opened, a hot wind blew from the north, like a cannon, leaving tracks on the ground. Later, it turned out that many of the windows were broken, and the iron latch for the barn door was broken.”
Semyon Semyonov, eyewitness
3. Scientific expeditions to the Tunguska explosion site were not conducted for nearly 20 years, partly due to its remote location and partly due to World War I, the Revolution, and the Civil War. The Soviet Academy of Sciences first sent geologist Leonid Kulik on an expedition to the site in 1921, but the terrain proved so inaccessible that he was unable to reach it. It was not until 1927 that Kulik succeeded in reaching his destination.
Later studies in the 1950s and 1960s revealed an 830-square-mile butterfly-shaped zone of destruction, extending from 9 to 22 miles from the epicenter, with millions of downed trees.
4. Why was there no crater left at the site of the explosion?
Because, unlike ordinary meteorites, the Tunguska meteorite didn't reach the Earth's surface. Upon entering the atmosphere, it experienced tremendous pressure, disintegrated, and almost completely evaporated in the air. This is why scientists speak of an airburst rather than a meteorite impact. The only remains of the object could have been microscopic particles of cosmic matter, later discovered in soil and peat bogs.
5. What exactly exploded? There are two main scientific theories.
Rocky asteroidThis is the most widely accepted hypothesis. Calculations suggest that an object 50–100 meters in diameter disintegrated upon entering the atmosphere, releasing almost all of its energy. This model best explains the height of the explosion and the nature of the destruction.
The nucleus of a small cometThis theory explains the absence of large debris by the fact that the comet consisted primarily of ice, which completely evaporated. However, modern models consider this scenario less likely.
6. Earth also holds geological evidence of other cosmic impacts. For example, in 1990, geologists identified the partially submerged Chicxulub Crater on Mexico's Yucatan Peninsula as the likely impact site of the 6-mile-wide asteroid that, 66 million years ago, wiped out not only the dinosaurs but also 75 percent of Earth's species. And near Winslow, Arizona, lies Meteor Crater, a crater nearly a mile wide, formed by the impact of a 165-foot-wide asteroid about 50,000 years ago.
7. The Tunguska explosion has become one of the most popular plots in world science fiction. Science fiction writers have particularly favored the hypothesis that the Tunguska meteorite was actually a crashed alien spacecraft. For example, in Stanislav Lem's novel "The Astronauts," the ship was sent by warlike inhabitants of Venus to destroy life on Earth. And in the Strugatsky brothers' story "Monday Begins on Saturday," the ship was not only alien, but also traveling from the future to the past.
This topic was so popular that in the 1980s, the magazine "Ural Pathfinder" warned: "Works that reveal the mystery of the Tunguska meteorite are not considered."