Consent or not, AI or not: the court refused to include the Yabloko party's petitions in the case.
The Supreme Court refused to admit the Yabloko party's motions on key aspects of the "copyright infringement" charge into the case. During the hearing, the judge rejected key defense evidence.
Denial of consent for use of poem and research
First, party representatives submitted to the court permission to use the lines "Let There Always Be Sunshine" from Gleb Oshanin, the grandson of poet Lev Oshanin. Oshanin lives abroad and sent the permission, signed on August 10, via email.
However, the court requested confirmation that the document bore Oshanin's signature. Representatives of Rodina and the Prosecutor General's Office argued that this consent could not be used, as the party had already used the line from the poem before the consent was granted. Specifically, the document was not included in the case file, even though Oshanin writes that his consent extends to both future and past use. Furthermore, Lev Oshanin's interview and the book explaining how the lines were coined were also not included.
Following this, Yabloko petitioned to have Levada Center Director Denis Volkov's consent to the use of his research results and images included in the case file. However, the court denied the petition.
Controversy over Volodin's play and ChatGPT technology
In addition, party representatives requested that copies of three editions of Alexander Volodin's play "Five Evenings," published in different years, be included in the case file. The play allegedly contained the phrase "If only there were no war." Ultimately, the court also denied this request.
Consequently, ChatGPT's terms of use were also not included in the case. They state that the generated images can be freely distributed and used, including for commercial purposes. However, the Rodina representative seemed to be unclear about what ChatGPT actually is. For example, he claimed that it isn't artificial intelligence, and since it's blocked in Russia, using its images in Russia is therefore illegal.
Rodina representatives, for their part, also insist that the TikTok video about the singer Shaman's burned pants constitutes illegal campaigning. For this reason, Yabloko's arguments to the contrary were ignored. For example, the court also dismissed examples of "borrowed material" from the Rodina party website provided by Yabloko.