Time to read: 2 minutes(s)

Unemployed, but no workers: the paradoxes of Russia's labor market

Political scientist Ilya Grashchenkov He drew attention to the paradoxical situation developing in the Russian labor market: recent statements about a total personnel shortage are being followed by warnings from businesses about impending layoffs. 

Ilya Grashchenkov. Photo from his personal page.

Labor market: structural gap, not general unemployment

“There is no contradiction here – it is not so much about general unemployment, but about a structural gap,” считает Grashchenkov: In this case, layoffs in some economic sectors occur simultaneously with a severe shortage of specialists in others.

On the risks of mass layoffs previously stated head of the Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs Alexander ShokhinHe believes that a high key rate and tax increases could push GDP growth toward zero or even push the economy into the red. 

“Many companies that maintained their headcount while switching to a three-day, four-day, and so on, will begin to make cuts,” — Shokhin explained.

Which industries and specialists are under attack?

According to Ilya Grashchenkov, the industries most at risk are those dependent on affordable credit and consumer demand: housing construction, certain segments of the metallurgy, coal, and automotive industries, as well as contractors and carriers. The second risk area is office staff: banks, retail chains, and corporations are laying off mid-level managers, accountants, HR specialists, and marketers, further facilitated by automation.

“But at the same time, the country lacks completely different people,” writes Grashchenkov. — In agriculture, energy, water supply, and utilities, labor shortages persist even as the economy cools. Electricians, mechanics, welders, adjusters, drivers, and skilled workers are in demand.

The main problem, according to the political scientist, is that a laid-off office worker cannot quickly become an electrician, and a resident of a single-industry town cannot easily move to another region due to differences in qualifications and salaries.

"Therefore, labor shortages and rising unemployment can easily coexist—sometimes even within a single industry. A developer may cut management, but its contractor still needs welders." — says Grashchenkov.

According to the Ministry of Labor's forecast, by 2032 the economy will need to replace about 11,7 million retiring workersAccording to Grashchenkov, without retraining programs, increased population mobility, and increased labor productivity, the market risks ending up in a situation where job seekers and employers search for each other without finding each other.

EconomyUnited States of America