Time to read: 7 minutes(s)

"They threatened me with Wagnerites": How a mother of many children was fined for writing "No to war"

Ekaterina Kartashova is a mother of many children from the city of Alexandrov in the Vladimir region. In March 2023, she wrote "No to War" at the entrance to a local volunteer center providing assistance to those fighting in Ukraine. Security forces tracked her down by her car's license plate number and forced her to confess. She was then tried and fined 30 rubles.

On the day Ekaterina decided to speak out against the war, she was thinking about family problems. Where to get medicine for her children, which was becoming increasingly difficult to obtain. Some had disappeared completely, while others had become several times more expensive since the beginning of the war. One day, she had to travel 300 kilometers along a winter road to get the medicine she needed for her children. And then there was Ekaterina, who had recently given a large sum of money to scammers, and complaints to the police and the prosecutor's office had yielded no results.

"We hear a lot on TV about how they help mothers with many children, and even more about how many Nazis there are in Ukraine. But in reality, they do nothing. And then, down the road, there was a volunteer center called 'Help the Front,' where they were weaving camouflage nets. I wrote 'No to War' at the entrance and tried to paint over the letters on the center's banner. I just wanted to ruin it. I'm not really a fighter; I've never participated in rallies before. It was just a surge of emotion," Ekaterina recalls.

 Law enforcement officers found her quickly, using her car's license plate number. Deputy Chief of Police for Operational Investigative Work in the Aleksandrovsky District, Police Lieutenant Colonel Ilya Shmelev, called and asked her to come to the station to answer a few questions. Ekaterina, who had no previous experience interacting with the police, agreed and went to the interview without a lawyer.

At the police station, Ekaterina was met by a woman who immediately searched her. She asked her to empty her bag onto the table—it was a restricted area, and they'd search everything anyway. She then began trying to get her to talk, asking where she lived, where her children were, and whether she had any relatives. Later, Shmelev came for her, and the interrogation began.

"He started off by bluffing that we had a case from such-and-such a date involving your car. I said yes. He said, 'Hey, did you write this?' At first, I said it wasn't me. Then he started threatening me with the Wagner group, saying, 'You know them, they're heroes, but they're thugs. And they know everything about you: where you live. Everything about your children. And we want to protect you. So tell us everything.'"

Since Ekaterina wouldn't confess, the police officer decided to blackmail her with the children. He said that if you weren't the one who wrote the graffiti, then it was your children. He also said that the police would go to the house, talk to the children without their mother present, and could throw them in solitary confinement.

"I pictured this. And they won't talk to minors in front of you, they'll do it alone. I thought I'd have to prove it was me so they wouldn't touch the children. All my friends are teenagers, so it could have been any of them," Ekaterina says.

After Ekaterina confessed, she was informed that police would be coming to her home to confiscate paint, a hat, and a laptop. The police needed the laptop because Ekaterina had ordered paint online. Without legal representation, Ekaterina consented to the search. A juvenile affairs inspector also went to the woman's home with the officers and photographed all the children's rooms.

"And then they sat there for a long time, processing everything. While they were processing, I managed to delete everything suspicious from my phone. I managed to do this because I left under the pretext of talking to the children and calming them down. I deleted all suspicious reposts and groups on Telegram and VK. I also realized from the conversation that the police officer who searched my home was receiving periodic calls from Center E. After these conversations, he asked me if I had been recruited in Ukraine. Or maybe even in the US."

At the trial, Ekaterina Kartashova was assisted by Anton Aptekar, a lawyer from OVD-Info. He advised and reassured Ekaterina. The lawyer insisted that Ekaterina be tried for vandalism, as the owner of the volunteer center had confirmed damage to property. He also noted that the article on discrediting the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation is unconstitutional.

"Her actions could have been assessed as property damage, not discrediting the army. The trial was as smooth as it could be here. The judge granted all our motions, but gave the minimum sentence under this article. But not less than the minimum. Perhaps this was influenced by her denial of guilt. After all, we considered this to be property damage, not discrediting the Russian Armed Forces. We believe such a statute shouldn't have existed at all. If Ekaterina had had another way to express her position—to picket or put an anti-war sign on her car—she would have taken it. Currently, any anti-war speech is effectively criminalized, and this statute is aimed at forcing people who don't support the SVO to refrain from expressing their opinions under threat of criminal punishment. Expressing one's opinion legally is impossible. That's why she acted impulsively." We filed a motion to suspend proceedings and request the Constitutional Court to declare this article unconstitutional because it suppresses ideological diversity and is discriminatory."

After the court decision was made laid out The news of Ekaterina's actions was published on the court's website by several Alexandrov-based VKontakte public groups. A couple of her classmates wrote to her son, saying, "This is your mother." A former classmate wrote to her daughter, asking her to convey words of support.   

“Yes, after the ruling, I changed my social media profile name. I became more cautious about adding people as friends. At first, I monitored the news about myself and read the comments. There were a lot of negative comments, but they never went beyond words. The people who wrote them didn’t try to find me. But for now, I’m scared. But I’ve also had a lot of support. A girl from Vladimir wrote to me and offered to help me pay my fine. A local Yabloko party member also found me through journalists from the Vladimir publication Dovod. He even gave me a tour and showed me other anti-war graffiti in Alexandrov. That deputy had also suffered from police brutality. At least I wasn’t beaten. It seems crazy, of course, that I wasn’t beaten, and that’s great. My daughters supported me; they share my views. And they follow the news. My eldest daughter even wanted to go to a rally in support of Navalny at one time, but I didn’t let her go because I would be the one who would have to drag her out later.”

Kateryna says she might not have felt the war so intensely if it weren't for her relatives in Ukraine. She has a cousin, aunt, and uncle there, and spent every summer as a child in the village of Klyuchovka in the Khmelnytskyi region. Now she sees them much more often. She also has relatives in Zaporizhzhia, right on the front line.

"I agree with Ekaterina Shulman, who says that the war will certainly end, but we need to live to see it. And in the future, relations between Ukraine and Russia will be like those between Germany and the Soviet Union. My peers, who learned about the war from their grandfathers, said that they couldn't even understand the German language. So, German means fascist. Something like that will happen, and I regret that I'll never get to Ukraine again."  

Ekaterina Kartashova is currently raising money to pay the fine. Her Rosbank account details are 40817810396190003481.