Andrey Kuraev: "Be careful who you open your soul to."
In August, the Russian Orthodox Church announced the discovery of the relics of Dmitry Donskoy in the Kremlin's Archangel Cathedral, and then the right hand of Saint Spyridon of Trimythous was brought to Moscow.

The host of our program on the YouTube channel "NeMoskva Segodnya" spoke with renowned theologian and deacon Andrei Kuraev. He explains his understanding of the reasons for the excitement, why he believes Patriarch Kirill and the authorities need the relics, what military chaplains are saying, and where the line is drawn between comforting a soldier and propaganda.
Kuraev on relics: where did the cult come from?
— Recently, there's been a surge of interest in the relics of saints in Russia: first, the excitement around the relics of Dmitry Donskoy, then that of Spyridon of Trimythous. Do you think it's fair to say that the authorities have turned to the relics for help?
"The Orthodox community is stuck, as they say, in the oral stages of development. Everything is done orally: kissing, eating—a cult of physical contact. This has a basis in Christian dogma. Because Christianity is such good news for the flesh. It's not the message of the immortality of the soul—the immortality of the soul has been proclaimed by various religions before. But here there's the idea that your body, moles and all, is also destined for eternity."
The first Christians believed in an optional resurrection—that this option was not for everyone, that only the bodies of true Christians would be resurrected, that only they would enjoy a blessed immortality. But how can we know who among us is a true Christian? There was a clear criterion: someone who was killed for their faith in Christ is a true Christian. Therefore, they were in no hurry to part with his body; it was kept in catacombs and crypts and venerated.

Moreover, a tradition has been established that the relics of a holy martyr must be placed at the base of the altar—without this, even the liturgy cannot be celebrated. For the liturgy is the proclamation of the future kingdom, and we strive to be partakers of it. In communion, we partake of a piece of the future universe—the body of the risen Christ. And at the base of the altar lies a body that will also certainly be resurrected. Such are the dogmatic foundations for the special veneration of relics throughout the Christian world.
How relics became part of propaganda
But when something becomes very widespread, very popular, and even a bit state-owned, all sorts of deviations arise. Even things that should seemingly be metaphysical and transcendental are exploited for the moment. And so, for example, in the Middle Ages, wars broke out between cities for the possession of relics. There's also the universal belief that only a cause that's bloody is lasting. Any archaeologist will tell you countless stories of children's skeletons being found under the steps or altars of ancient sanctuaries and temples all over the world. This is also part of the cult of the dead, the cult of relics.

And in the modern world, propaganda adds to this. Imagine: the infamous Belt of the Virgin Mary has arrived in Moscow, at the Cathedral of Christ the Savior. Huge lines. And right next door, a hundred meters away, is the Church of Elijah the Obydenny—a piece of the same belt is there, but there's no line. Why is that? Because it's an export. Rembrandt, which is always on display at the Hermitage, doesn't generate such a stir. But if we say we brought [his works] from somewhere in Europe for a week, then everyone will come.
Another modern peculiarity is that large outdoor gatherings are banned in Russia today. And people rejoice when they have the opportunity to go outside, to participate in some kind of mass celebration, be it Maslenitsa or a religious procession.
Spyridon of Trimythous as a "business project"
Take Spyridon of Trimythous, for example—he wasn't well-known or venerated in Rus'; there were practically no churches there. All churches dedicated to Spyridon in Russia were built in post-Soviet times. This is the result of a successful PR campaign by the Greeks, who organized religious tourism. And they came up with a truly remarkable miracle for Spyridon: it turns out he, like Father Frost, walks around at night distributing gifts. So, several times a year, his slippers are changed right in his coffin because they wear out. They also spread a rumor that people should pray to Spyridon to get a mortgage or solve their housing problems.

This is a serious business project. And every time an event of this kind is held, a business plan is agreed upon, that is, an agreement on the percentage of revenues to be divided: how much goes to the owners, that is, the dioceses where the relics will be kept for several days, and how much goes to a particular church.
Kuraev on the relics and the patriarch: why do the authorities need this?
— The war has been going on for five years—why is there such a surge now?
"This has nothing to do with the situation at the front. The patriarch simply has this constant headache: how to prove that he's needed and can do something, including through some specifically church-based means. Because in the time of Peter the Great, the church was the only mass media for all of Russia, but in the age of newspapers, radio, television, and the internet, that's no longer the case."

It's clear that Kirill's sermons are far less persuasive and effective than those of Vladimir Solovyov and the other General Staff zealots. Therefore, it's important for him to find a niche in his own language to serve those in power.
Putin, Boris, and Gleb: Why Saints Are Not Honored
"I recently heard that Margarita Simonyan is waging an active campaign to expose canonized saints. And before that, Putin also denied the feats of Saints Boris and Gleb..."

"I haven't heard about Margarita. As for Putin, it's true. He has a clear Soviet-Chekist position of power; he rightly and honestly referred to the St. Petersburg underworld that raised him. And, of course, for the St. Petersburg underworld, any bespectacled guys, nerds, weaklings who didn't fight back, who didn't fight back, can't be heroes. Take the martyrs Boris and Gleb, the royal family—those who supposedly had access to the sword but didn't use it—their behavior is unpleasant for Putin. And he didn't hide it.
Kuraev on military churches: what does a priest do?
— What do you think about military churches? Is this a new practice?
"That's a fairly common thing in itself. When someone finds themselves in a situation where their freedom is restricted against their will, it's logical to ask: what guarantees do you have for freedom of religious activity? Let's say someone is in a hospital and can't leave. So, it's perfectly normal for there to be a hospital chapel, with a priest having access to that room. Or if someone is in prison, there might be a prison chapel, and the priest would have the right to enter, and the prisoners would have the right to communicate with him."
Then questions arise: how confidential will this prisoner's communication with the priest be, who this priest works for—but these are details. Or the ship was sent out to sea for several months—it was believed that a military ship in the Russian Empire needed a monk, because a family priest couldn't be sent out to sea for six months. So the mere presence of a priest in such a closed community is natural. And if there is a priest, there should also be a place where one can pray, even without a priest—today there are such chapels at airports and train stations.
Soldiers and Compulsory Service: Denikin's Lesson
Here's another question: what's going on in this military church? There's a truly horrifying memoir by General Denikin. In "Essays on the Russian Time of Troubles," he writes about one of the regiments stationed on the Romanian front. In 1916-1917, the front stood still. And since the positions were stable, somewhere in the third line of trenches, the soldiers themselves dug a large dugout and built a church there. But as soon as the emperor abdicated and it was announced that Orthodoxy was no longer mandatory, the soldiers voted to turn their church into a toilet. The Bolsheviks hadn't yet arrived—this was a response to the mandatory veneration. It's crucial that there be no mandatory veneration, that soldiers not be herded together to venerate some relics.
What the priest says to the soldiers
The second question: what is the priest doing in this church? What is he encouraging the soldiers to expect? What is he telling them? There's a huge gap between what priests say today to civilians and what they say during actual military operations. A chaplain in the army is essential to give soldiers a respite, to encourage them to live beyond the garrison regulations. He's there to remind them that if hostilities break out, they must behave in accordance with international law and the demands of Christian ethics: not to kill prisoners, not to torture them, not to touch civilians, not to commit violence. And upon returning from service, not to carry the brutality of the frontline back to their homeland.

But if you listen to the speeches of military clergy leaders on both sides, you'll hear a escalation of hatred and the ultimate demonization of the enemy: they're all Satanists, anti-Christians, and so on. Each side in this conflict considers itself Christian and Orthodox, while the other side is utterly inhuman. Plus, they provide a historical precedent for this: our saints have always defended our land, never spared the enemy, and you should too.
And finally, the most important thing that Patriarch Kirill constantly emphasizes: religious faith, faith in the immortality of the soul, helps a soldier not fear facing certain death. Kirill promises all fallen soldiers paradise, so they become more obedient to their superiors.
Can a priest remain silent about war?
— Does a priest in Russia currently have the opportunity to express an alternative position that contradicts the official position of the Russian Orthodox Church?
"In some places, there's an alternative to silence. Today, in a totalitarian society, silence is a sign of dissent. If a priest simply talks about a holiday, about how today is the Feast of the Entry of the Mother of God into the Temple, and transports his parishioners' thoughts back to distant biblical times, that can also be considered a quiet protest. In Soviet times, many intellectuals went to work as museum curators, studying the history of the ancient world, just to work in a field that didn't adhere to the decisions of the last plenum of the CPSU Central Committee. A large number of Soviet intellectuals hid from the demands of Soviet censorship and ideology precisely in such ancient research. Something similar is happening today: if you want to be far from war, from brainwashing, choose the safety of the 17th century, or even better, the time before Christ."
A priest can hide behind the Bible, behind ancient church history, and if there are no informers or haters around him, he'll get away with it. But we see this in the chaotic manner in which people are declared foreign agents or arrested: often, it's simply a personal enemy who's decided to demonstrate civic activism and vigilance. The same thing happens in the church: some priest might say that Father Vasily, you know, doesn't call on parishioners to donate to the military fund and doesn't call for prayers in his sermons for the victory of our great and wonderful army.
This could be a denunciation from a colleague, an active parishioner, or a local government official who visited the church and somehow didn't sense the atmosphere he creates in his office. If there are no such activists or informers, the priest may not even recite this prayer for victory. In Moscow, of course, he won't succeed, but in some quiet village, where the bishop isn't politically engaged, he might get away with it.
The Secret of Confession: To Whom to Open Your Soul?
"What about the secrecy of confession today? Can a layperson hope that when they express their concerns about the war, their anti-war stance, their words will be heard only by a priest, and not by a major from the regional FSB department? Is there any other guarantee of that?"
There are no guarantees. But when you go to confession, you have the right, even the duty, to choose your interlocutor. In Orthodoxy and Catholicism, there is such a sacrament: when a canonically correct priest pronounces the words of the correct form of consecration, the Lord bestows His grace upon us. But there is an important condition: this only applies to the consecration of matter—water, bread, wine, a car, real estate, and so on. However, there is no guarantee that the priest's own mind will be consecrated. You can be a bishop and still be a fool. And while I don't care who consecrates my car, when it comes to invading my soul, as a parishioner, I must choose. It is my duty, my responsibility.
When it comes to treating a cold, you can turn to any doctor, even just your neighbor. But when it comes to serious illnesses, each of us searches through everyone we know to find a good doctor. Just as we search for a family doctor, normal people also search for a family psychologist, a priest, or a spiritual father. So, be careful who you open your heart to.
When can a priest violate the secrecy of confession?
Orthodox thinking is precedent-setting, and anyone with even a modicum of church education knows that Peter the Great issued a decree requiring priests to violate the secrecy of confession when it comes to crimes against the sovereign. Specifically, crimes against the sovereign personally, not some possible violation of Russia's national interests. But a less-than-literate modern activist in a cassock might reason like this: if someone doesn't want our army to achieve a swift victory and destroy Ukraine, then they are, in fact, our mental, ideological enemy, an enemy of our Fatherland, our Church, Patriarch Kirill, and President Putin.
I don't rule out the possibility of a shell-shocked priest deciding he must report this. But officially, if someone has confessed to some kind of socially dangerous intent—that they want to plant a bomb, kill someone, etc.—a priest can report it, but without naming the person or providing any circumstances by which the police could identify them. In other words, he can warn them that he has learned that a bomb may have been planted in a certain building.

And it's important to understand that the list of church sins discussed in confession and the list of political crimes are completely different. If someone tells a priest they sinned and ate a sausage on a fast day, the FSB finds this information completely uninteresting. And the fact that someone distributed a banned book isn't considered sinful, so they see no need to tell the priest about it in confession.